View:

Connections, in both directions

Eyes Without a Face poster
His driver, Céline (Edith Scob, "Eyes Without a Face"), tells him he has nine appointments this day, many hours of work before she can return to "Holy Motors."
Reeling Reviews • Jan 10, 2020
reelingreviews.com ↗
It's no accident that the old chauffeur is played by Edith Scob, the star of Franju's classic "Eyes Without a Face."
NJ.com
nj.com ↗
Carax is especially fixated on Franju’s greatest work, the nocturnal and terrifying 1959 masterpiece, “Eyes Without a Face,” about an obsessive plastic surgeon trying to rebuild his daughter’s face, which he had disfigured in a car accident, from the combined parts of transplants of beautiful kidnapped young women.
Emanuel Levy
archive.org ↗
The finale of Holy Motors sees Édith Scob, as the impeccably dressed Céline, donning the mask she wore playing a disfigured girl in George Franju’s 1960 horror classic Eyes Without a Face.
Toronto Star
archive.org ↗
His driver is Céline (Édith Scob — mostly known as the daughter with the disfigured face in Georges Franju's "Eyes Without a Face"), and she has two simple responsibilities: give him the detailed file for his next appointment and make sure he arrives on time for it.
NextMovie
archive.org ↗
A chameleonic blank page, he's a funnier version of the stiff financier in Cosmopolis, riding about in a limo driven by a trusted chauffeur (Edith Scob, whose performance in Franju's Eyes Without a Face is one of many allusions).
The Phoenix
thephoenix.com ↗
Frances Ha poster
When the film overtly cribs from the style and storytelling devices of the French New Wave, it's not out of some bland, "I like the New Wave" impulse, but because that's an extremely useful touchstone for a story about insular young people (it does, however, hurt the film that its best moment is an out-of-nowhere direct copy of a scene from the much better neo-New Wave film Mauvais sang ).
Otherwise, Baumbach’s style could be called homage-happy: It’s classic Truffaut meets vintage Woody Allen meets Girls, with one direct lift—an exhilarating, freewheeling David Bowie-scored street dance—from Leos Carax’s Mauvais Sang.
North Bay Bohemian • May 29, 2013
newsreview.com ↗
The film shows many influences, from Woody Allen (white titles on black backgrounds, New York City shot in glorious black and white) to Leos Carax (Gerwig dances through the streets to David Bowie's 'Modern Love,' just like Denis Lavant in "Mauvais Sang").
Reeling Reviews • Jan 10, 2020
reelingreviews.com ↗
Frances’s celebratory sprint through Manhattan, her speeding steps giving way gradually to outright pirouettes, is a remake of an identical set piece in Leos Carax’s Mauvais Sang (1986), only with the camera moving in the opposite direction.
Ryan Gilbey • New Statesman • Jul 25, 2013
newstatesman.com ↗
One sprint lovingly lifts from Leos Carax’s delirious tracking-shot trot in 1986‘s Mauvais Sang, same-tuned to Bowie’s “Modern Love,” and there’s an obvious and joyful French fixation here, with music cues plucked from The 400 Blows and Contempt, among others (it’s wall-to-wall Georges Delerue, to the happy sigh of Francophiles everywhere), and a matte-gray palette piped in from the French New Wave.
The Austin Chronicle • May 31, 2013
austinchronicle.com ↗
Just like Denis Lavant in Leos Carax's Mauvais Sang.
John Semley • Slant Magazine • Sep 18, 2012
slantmagazine.com ↗
Beauty and the Beast poster
And the longest section, with that nasty troglodyte, incorporates both one of Carax' earlier works (the same character showed up in his contribution to the 2008 anthology film "Tokyo!") and a bit of Cocteau's "Beauty and the Beast."
NJ.com
nj.com ↗
“Holy Motors” looks forward and backward, combining science fiction with an upended, funhouse mirror history riffing on Cocteau, Bunuel, “Beauty and the Beast,” and Fritz Lang’s “Metropolis” and “M,” among many influences.
Emanuel Levy
archive.org ↗
M poster
“Holy Motors” looks forward and backward, combining science fiction with an upended, funhouse mirror history riffing on Cocteau, Bunuel, “Beauty and the Beast,” and Fritz Lang’s “Metropolis” and “M,” among many influences.
Emanuel Levy
archive.org ↗
Billy Budd poster
He's formally dressed like a businessman, and one of his daughters calls from the roof: "Travaille bien" ("work hard"), a comic reference to Claire Denis's film Beau travail (aka Nice Work), a reshaping of Melville's Billy Budd set in the French Foreign Legion, in which Lavant played the Claggart figure.
Philip French, www.theguardian.com • The Guardian • Sep 30, 2012
co.uk ↗
Max My Love poster
That simian domesticity evokes Oshima Nagisa’s Max Mon Amour (1986), one of a number of references that will make this a cinephile’s wet dream.
Godzilla poster
Lavant also appears as a sort of milky-eyed Mandarin leprechaun who -- accompanied by Akira Ifukube's theme music from " Godzilla " (1954) -- emerges from a sewer to kidnap a supermodel (Eva Mendes) and to chew flowers stolen from graves marked with headstones that read -- in a brilliant sight gag -- "Visitez Mon Site" (French for "Visit My Website").
Beauty and the Beast poster
And the longest section, with that nasty troglodyte, incorporates both one of Carax' earlier works (the same character showed up in his contribution to the 2008 anthology film "Tokyo!") and a bit of Cocteau's "Beauty and the Beast."
NJ.com
nj.com ↗
Check out the headstones in Père Lachaise Cemetery, where Merde sprints through on his Beauty and the Beast quest, and you’ll see both direct jokes (“Visitez mon site”) and indirect ones.
Toronto Star
thestar.com ↗
Sure, we see the shout out to Beauty and the Beast, but the real world work, especially the scenes where Lavant is dealing with true tragedies, become all the more powerful and engaging.
Carax stuffs his film with innumerable film and literary references — Vidor, Merde’s “Beauty and the Beast” motif, 1960’s “Eyes Without a Face,” nods to Franz Kafka and quietly horrifying Kubrickian darkness — as one would expect from a director who got his start writing for the French film journal Cahiers du Cinema.
But there's dazzlingly bizarre comedy, too, as in a "Beauty and the Beast"-inspired sequence where Oscar absconds with a fashion model (Eva Mendes) and takes her into the catacombs beneath a cemetery.
Eric D. Snider • Eric D. Snider • Oct 17, 2012
ericdsnider.com ↗
The Crowd poster
Furthermore, the symbiotic connection between auteur and collaborator is established in the eerie and beautiful opening, as a man (played by the director) discovers a portal that opens to packed theater playing King Vidor’s “The Crowd,” leading to the introduction of the chameleonic protagonist.
Emanuel Levy
archive.org ↗
The nearly silent prologue evokes the social unease and transfixed audience of King Vidor’s 1928 rat-race commentary The Crowd.
Toronto Star
archive.org ↗
He is then on the other side, in the aisle of a cinema, where a packed audience is watching King Vidor’s The Crowd.
The Austin Chronicle • Dec 7, 2012
austinchronicle.com ↗
The frozen crowd is shot from the perspective of the movie screen as the audience watches the final scenes of King Vidor’s 1928 silent film, “The Crowd.”
Austin360
archive.org ↗
Mulholland Drive poster
You’ll hear lots of people comparing “Holy Motors” to David Lynch’s “Mulholland Drive,” and I guess that’s OK as far as it goes.
Andrew O'Hehir • Salon • Oct 19, 2012
salon.com ↗
(The structure could form a twin cinema with Mulholland Dr.'s Club Silencio.)
The Village Voice
villagevoice.com ↗
Swept up in the excitement, some of the first reviewers made it sound like a visionary cross between Metropolis and Mulholland Drive.
FilmInk
com.au ↗
Take David Lynch as an example: one moment he’s messing with our heads with spectacular aplomb in Mulholland Drive and the next he’s driving us cookoo with Inland Empire .
Matt's Movie Reviews
mattsmoviereviews.net ↗
You could also draw parallels with films such as Mulholland Drive and The Tree Of Life.
The Film Pie
thefilmpie.com ↗
Sunset Boulevard poster
There's a sense of ambivalence about what this means - the cameras have got smaller, Oscar complains at one point, in an intriguing echo of the famous line from Sunset Boulevard when, as Norma Desmond, Gloria Swanson declares: ''I am big, it's the pictures that got small.''
Philippa Hawker • The Age • Aug 24, 2012
com.au ↗
The Double poster
There are still clear references—one shot of Simon walking along a ridged, blue-painted wall recalls the “Modern Love” sequence of Mauvais Sang—but here he starts to come into his own as a filmmaker.
Movie Mezzanine • Apr 8, 2014
moviemezzanine.com ↗
The Vampires or, The Arch Criminals of Paris poster
Throwing in a family of monkeys, talking limos and a raging erection for good measure, Holy Motors slinks through Paris, its streets, sewers and rooftops, like the mysterious criminals in Louis Feuillade’s wondrous serials from a century ago: Fantomas, Les Vampires and Judex.
Mary Corliss • TIME • Oct 19, 2012
time.com ↗
Breathless poster
A shorthaired mystery woman, she is played by a quietly expressive Kylie Minogue, clearly channeling Jean Seberg’s character from Jon Luc Godard’s Breathless.
Mon Oncle poster
Now this man is inside a cinema, and we meet Monsieur Oscar ( Denis Lavant ), who lives in a house that seems designed by the same architect employed in Jacques Tati's " Mon Oncle ."
RogerEbert.com
rogerebert.com ↗
Little Women poster
Nos comparte su gozo por medio de una citación que ya era una citación: Jo corre por las calles de Nueva York como Frances (Greta Gerwig) en Frances Ha (2012) de Noah Baumbach, como Alex (Denis Lavant) lo hizo en el París de Mala sangre (Mauvais sang, 1986).
Cine Excepción • Feb 28, 2020
cinexcepcion.mx ↗
Heaven's Gate poster
(Michael Cimino's eternal transgression in having made Heaven's Gate has haunted his career ever since, even though he also made The Deer Hunter.)
Metropolis poster
“Holy Motors” looks forward and backward, combining science fiction with an upended, funhouse mirror history riffing on Cocteau, Bunuel, “Beauty and the Beast,” and Fritz Lang’s “Metropolis” and “M,” among many influences.
Emanuel Levy
archive.org ↗
Merde’s fellow sewer dwellers walk in formation like the dehumanized workers of Fritz Lang’s 1927 dystopian vision Metropolis.
Toronto Star
archive.org ↗
Swept up in the excitement, some of the first reviewers made it sound like a visionary cross between Metropolis and Mulholland Drive.
FilmInk
com.au ↗
Licorice Pizza poster
I love the long scene where Alana and Gary are running towards each other from opposite ends of the screen and the city--like something out of Leos Carax's Mauvais Sang , for instance, another film that is like this except all the way through, because it somehow resists shitting the bed with a gag that is hateful and sadly unnecessary.
Bill Chambers • Film Freak Central • Nov 22, 2021
filmfreakcentral.net ↗
It’s like a madcap mix of Linklater, “Punch-Drunk Love” and Leo’s Carax’s “Holy Motors.”
Jordan Ruimy • World of Reel • Nov 15, 2021
worldofreel.com ↗
Valerian and the City of a Thousand Planets poster
He’s a key figure in the so-called Cinéma du look, a term coined by critic Raphaël Bassan in 1989 to describe the spectacular visual stylings of movies like Leos Carax’s Mauvais Sang and Besson’s Subway.
Jo Livingstone • The New Republic • Jul 13, 2017
newrepublic.com ↗