In 2019’s The Lighthouse, he recovered and re-envisioned the spirit of Edgar Allan Poe by marooning two nineteenth-century lighthouse keepers in the same space as a tentacled Lovecraftian monster to better orchestrate a fever dream about fragile masculinity and the menace of isolation.
It is, you might say, the film he was born to (re)make, for the talon-prints of Murnau’s spectral frightshow are evident on Eggers’ first three period films, The Witch, The Lighthouse and The Northman.
And while the monstrous mermaid in The Lighthouse isn’t a fully fledged character, her mixture of aggression and sensuality toward wickie Ephraim Winslow is one of the film’s defining motifs, a representation of both the allure and unknowability of the natural world and, maybe, of a woman’s mind.
…a straight line could be drawn from the shadowy crookedness of German Expressionism in early cinema to The Lighthouse or The Witch.
A mermaid looms over a delirious descent into madness of two lighthouse keepers in 1890s New England in The Lighthouse.
…a similar moment occurs in Eggers’s The Lighthouse (2019) when Winslow (Robert Pattinson) is beating Wake (Willem Dafoe) and he sees Wake briefly take on the form of a seductive siren, whom Winslow kisses.