View:

Connections, in both directions

Match Point poster
Writer/director Woody Allen ("Melinda and Melinda") tints his own "Crimes and Misdemeanors" with George Stevens's "A Place in the Sun," leaves his beloved New York completely behind for the first time ever and delivers his best film in years.
Reeling Reviews • Jan 10, 2020
reelingreviews.com ↗
The electric encounter between Chris and Nola (Scarlett Johansson) over a ping-pong table is Allen's answer to "A Place in the Sun," in which Montgomery Clift and Elizabeth Taylor did their mating dance over a pool table.
Mick LaSalle, Chronicle Movie Critic • SFGate • Jan 6, 2006
archive.org ↗
And like Shelley Winters in George Stevens' "A Place in the Sun," Nola becomes something resembling pure demand.
It needs to be mentioned, though, that Johansson -- even though her character is made out to be more and more a nagging, whining bitch as the movie progresses; she's Shelley Winters in "A Place in the Sun," without any of the compassion shown that character -- survives the picture unscathed.
Yet the more obvious model for Match Point is Theodore Dreiser’s classic novel An American Tragedy, which was made into A Place in the Sun with stars Montgomery Clift, Elizabeth Taylor, and Shelley Winters.
Logan poster
Some things are a little on the point like the clips from the Western Shane (a clear influence on this story) being watched by the group in a hotel room.
Joseph Jammer Medina • Locomotive & Railway Preservation • Aug 30, 2007
lrmonline.com ↗
Not only does Logan make explicit reference to Shane, the film borrows the genre’s self-critical eye, questioning our need to mythologise heroes.
Tim Grierson, Senior US critic, Jeremy Kay, Nikki Baughan • Screen Daily • Feb 17, 2017
screendaily.com ↗
Traversing dusty American backroads haunted by the ravages of social downturns, this trio of interlocking misfits morph into warped western characters, a notion blatantly underlined by a scene in which Xavier and Laura watch Shane.
Slant Magazine
slantmagazine.com ↗
A closer analogue is the 1953 western Shane, which Mangold quotes liberally.
Peter Canavese • Groucho Reviews
grouchoreviews.com ↗
But mostly the movie is brilliantly on point in its influences — the 1953 Western classic Shane plays a key role — and how it ties in to the previous movies without being beholden to them.
Brian Truitt, USA TODAY, Brian Truitt • USA TODAY • Feb 17, 2017
usatoday.com ↗
Mangold uses clips and quotes to draw a pointed comparison between Logan and the protagonist of Shane, the 1953 Alan Ladd Western about an aging gunfighter whose attempts to settle down with a family lead to tragedy.
Tasha Robinson • The Verge • Feb 17, 2017
theverge.com ↗
There Will Be Blood poster
Inspired by Upton Sinclair's 1927 novel 'Oil!' and Margaret Leslie Davis' biography of the oil tycoon Edward Dehaney 'The Dark Side of Fortune', and shot in the same place (Marfa, Texas) where oil saga Giant was filmed in 1956, There Will Be Blood taps into a deep seam of American ideology and iconography.
musicOMH
archive.org ↗
There are also echoes of the 1956 James Dean classic, Giant.
Clocking in a a bursting 158 minutes, the latest Paul Thomas Anderson epic comes onto the scene reminding viewers more of the 1956 George Stevens opus "Giant" than anything else in recent or past memory.
Those who remember the 1956 James Dean classic "Giant" will notice hints and whispers from that epic in the crude-soaked new film.
Their travels are determined by Daniel’s brutal speculations, from Texas to California (the film was shot in Marfa, Texas, same location as George Stevens’ Giant, another epic melodrama about land, oil, and blood, though its CA setting suggests Anderson’s abiding interest in the state’s entwining commercial histories).
PopMatters
popmatters.com ↗
It was shot in Marfa, Texas, the location of George Stevens’$2 1956 oil epic Giant .
Dana Stevens • Slate • Dec 24, 2007
slate.com ↗
Legends of the Fall poster
The movie is a showcase for acting, and in addition to Ormond and Hopkins, it also shows how strong Aidan Quinn and Brad Pitt are, in roles that have inescapable parallels to the Rock Hudson and James Dean characters in "Giant."
RogerEbert.com
rogerebert.com ↗
In fact, what "Legends" will remind veteran moviegoers of most is the 1956 George Stevens-directed version of Ferber's "Giant," with Brad Pitt, Aidan Quinn and Julia Ormond standing in nicely for James Dean, Rock Hudson and Elizabeth Taylor.
KENNETH TURAN, www.latimes.com, kenneth-turan • Los Angeles Times • Dec 23, 1994
latimes.com ↗
Because Brad Pitt is routinely compared to American cinema's great tragic romantic rebel youth, James Dean-whom he resembles in appearance, style and, most important, talent and charisma-it probably explains why so many critics have compared "Legends of the Fall" to Dean's last movie, "Giant."
The Man Who Would Be King poster
Though there are echoes here of the 1939 film Gunga Din (also adapted from Kipling), The Man Who Would Be King perhaps best recalls The Treasure of the Sierra Madre and The Maltese Falcon, Huston's earlier classics about enterprising men who seek treasure and discover the darkness of their hearts.
Peter Canavese • Groucho Reviews
grouchoreviews.com ↗
On the one hand, it's a rollicking tall tale, a light, comical, swashbuckling yarn in the tradition of RKO's "Gunga Din."
John J. Puccio • DVD Town
archive.org ↗
In marvelous old movies like "Lives of the Bengal Lancers" and "Gunga Din," this world is very far removed and terribly romantic, as it still is in John Huston's highly entertaining new film, "The Man Who Would Be King," based on the short story by Rudyard Kipling.
The movie invites comparison with the great action films like "Gunga Din" and "Mutiny on the Bounty," and with Huston's own classic " The Treasure of the Sierra Madre ": We get strong characterizations, we get excitement, we even get to laugh every once in a while.
RogerEbert.com
rogerebert.com ↗
In its own way, Huston’s film is part of that last stand, even though it’s an old-fashioned adventure yarn of the Gunga Din (1939) school.
Mountain Xpress
archive.org ↗
Drive poster
Ryan Gosling exudes no-sweat professionalism in Drive, a shamelessly entertaining genre movie from director Nicolas Winding Refn that plays like an exalted episode of Miami Vice or a stealth version of Shane.
Carrie Rickey, Inquirer Movie Critic • The Philadelphia Inquirer • Sep 15, 2011
philly.com ↗
Albert Brooks and Ron Perlman are on fine form as the terrifying heavies, but it's Gosling who anchors the movie with a strong, silent (and undeniably pretty) performance that's oddly reminiscent, as is the set-up, of the 1953 Alan Ladd western Shane.
Radio Times • Jan 25, 2011
radiotimes.com ↗
With Gosling like an outsider gunslinger trying to protect a decent but compromised family - and sharing a chaste love for the wife and a grudging respect for the husband - Drive at times feels like a super-charged, modernised version of George Stevens' classic western, Shane.
FilmInk
com.au ↗
The Passion of the Christ poster
This movie is no more anti-Jewish than Jesus Of Nazareth, or King Of Kings, or Jesus Christ Superstar, or The Greatest Story Ever Told.
"The Last Temptation of Christ" had this feeling to it even "The Greatest Story Ever Told" had a few moments of true glory amidst its "Gospel According to Hollywood Squares" aesthetic.
Savage and often shocking, Gibson's film is a far cry from the corny, stately religious epics many of us grew up with, such as "The Greatest Story Ever Told," in which special guest star John Wayne appeared as a Roman soldier overseeing the crucifixion.
Interbridge
interbridge.com ↗
The crucifixion is much more real, unlike anything we've seen before, from 1927's silent film "The King of Kings" to George Stevens' classic, "The Greatest Story Ever Told."
The Real Deal
thereeldeal.co ↗
Moreover, the movie doesn't even try to encapsulate the Christian message in the way that the second "King of Kings" and "The Greatest Story Ever Told" did so lovingly.
The Seattle Times
archive.org ↗
Historical accuracy was clearly the directorial watchword throughout, and this is where problems creep in: The Passion of the Christ trumps The Greatest Story Ever Told but comes perilously close to being The Greatest Snuff Film Ever Made.
Chronicle Staff • The Austin Chronicle • Sep 15, 1995
austinchronicle.com ↗
La La Land poster
Chazelle dresses Mia and her friends in colors straight out of a primary crayon box (one of several nods to Demy’s Young Girls of Rochefort ) and places them in a dreamscape that’s tantalizing, bracing, yet naggingly derivative of everything from Swing Time to Cover Girl.
Michael Sragow • Film Comment • Dec 8, 2016
filmcomment.com ↗
Whiplash writer-director Damien Chazelle’s dazzling, ambitious modern-day musical is fresh yet nostalgic, paying tribute to song-and-dance classics such as Singin’ in the Rain and Swing Time.
Tricia Olszewski • Washington City Paper • Dec 15, 2016
washingtoncitypaper.com ↗
Purple Hearts poster
They remind me of a modern version of Katharine Hepburn and Spencer Tracy in Woman of the Year.
AuthorsDen
authorsden.com ↗
Once Upon a Time in the West poster
Argento and Bertolucci included references or quotations to several American Westerns, including High Noon (in the opening scene), The Searchers (in the closing scene), Shane (again, in the closing scene), as well as 3:10 to Yuma (in a line of dialogue), John Ford�s cavalry trilogy (brief shots in Monument Valley), and numerous others, in effect making Once Upon a Time in the West the first post-modern Western.
Ben Nieporent • eFilmCritic
efilmcritic.com ↗
Shane would never do this, although Wilson (Jack Palance) might have in Leone's universe.
Tony Macklin
tonymacklin.net ↗
Exodus: Gods and Kings poster
Bale's Moses, despite the miscasting, is a conflicted, sometimes compelling figure, but the rest of the actors recall John Wayne's cameo as a Roman soldier in "The Greatest Story Ever Told" more than they do Willem Dafoe in "The Last Temptation of Christ."
Such movies were big, in every way, in the '50s and '60s, when pictures like Ben-Hur , Quo Vadis , King Of Kings , The Ten Commandments and The Greatest Story Ever Told regularly ran between two-and-a-half and four hours, their vast desertscapes rendered in widescreen, CinemaScope and VistaVision to tempt viewers away from their 4:3 TV screens.
Jamie Graham • GamesRadar+ • Dec 1, 2014
gamesradar.com ↗
Killer Joe poster
In appearance he channels Jack Palance’s Wilson in George Stevens’ Shane, the sure-shot (and coffee-drinking, like Killer Joe) dark spirit called forth to take on the new, eponymous threat.
Nope poster
Thus, when a man named Angel (Brandon Perea) comes to their aid, he is following a noble trail laid down by the hero of “Shane” (1953), who rode to the rescue of the Starretts, in their imperilled homestead.
Anthony Lane • The New Yorker • Aug 1, 2022
newyorker.com ↗
Palmer in particular shines with an easy exuberance that feels entirely her own, and Kaluuya embodies the precise kind of laconic cowboy masculinity that defined the leading men of movies like George Stevens’ Shane .
Charles Pulliam-Moore • The Verge • Jul 21, 2022
theverge.com ↗
Heaven's Gate poster
In George Stevens's Shane the Johnson County war is enacted on two planes: the sodbusters confronting the pioneer rancher Ryker on a realistic level; Alan Ladd's angelic Shane facing up to Jack Palance's evil gunslinger Wilson in a mythic manner.
Philip French, www.theguardian.com • The Guardian • Aug 3, 2013
archive.org ↗
The Awful Truth poster
But it's in this segment that Giant's objective--to redefine masculinity for Bick as something not founded on chauvinistic principles--surfaces, leading to a thoughtful denouement that, like the epilogue of Leo McCarey's The Awful Truth , shows "'til death do us part" from a comforting angle.
Bill Chambers • Film Freak Central
archive.org ↗
The White Tiger poster
I could not help but be reminded of “Gunga Din”, Kipling’s awful poem that was made into an even more awful film.
Outlaw King poster
It’s quite old-fashioned and classical, but in a pleasing way, reminiscent of “Gunga Din” and particularly Kurosawa in its widescreen images and reveling in mud and rain.
Oliver Lyttelton • The Playlist • Oct 17, 2018
theplaylist.net ↗
Speechless poster
Instead, the film seems to have been inspired by such screwball pen pals as Tracy and Hepburn in “Woman of the Year.”
Rita Kempley • The Washington Post • Dec 16, 1994
washingtonpost.com ↗
The Pianist poster
The Pianist has already, jokingly, been referred to as ‘The Diary of Anne Frank meets CastAway’ and that’s not too far from the truth.
ViewLondon
co.uk ↗
Excalibur poster
It may be a coincidence, but when Merlin makes his first appearance in the film, his image taking shape out of swirling, back-lighted mist, he looks startlingly like Max von Sydow's Jesus in George Stevens's ''The Greatest Story Ever Told.''
Manohla Dargis, Beatrice Loayza, Glenn Kenny, Alissa Wilkinson, Calum Marsh, Jeannette Catsoulis, Ben Kenigsberg, Erik Piepenburg, Brandon Yu, Natalia Winkelman • The New York Times • Mar 12, 2026
nytimes.com ↗