View:

Connections, in both directions

A Star Is Born poster
In Bradley Cooper’s strong feature directorial debut A Star Is Born – a remake of the three namesake films that came before, touchstones of their generations as much as this one will be – Lady Gaga makes her indelible mark as a true blue movie star of the highest calibre, a designation earned only by her undertaking considerable risk that has paid off against odds more stacked than one might readily admit.
Dazed • Sep 10, 2018
dazeddigital.com ↗
Cooper isn't the first one to go down the film's familiar road: This is the fourth “A Star Is Born,” which tosses in references and story points from earlier iterations – notably, the 1954 film with Judy Garland and James Mason, as well as the 1976 version starring Kris Kristofferson and Barbra Streisand.
Brian Truitt, USA TODAY, Brian Truitt • USA Today • Oct 1, 2018
usatoday.com ↗
Telling the downfall story requires more finesse than A Star Is Born is able to manage — the Garland version does this very well and it’s inevitable that this version will always be compared to the ones before it.
Wenlei Ma • Bitly • Oct 17, 2018
bit.ly ↗
The parallel trajectory of a star on the rise and another on the downhill skid has been popular fodder for Hollywood since its first incarnation in the 1932 drama What Price Hollywood?
Kristen Lopez • Culturess • Oct 3, 2018
culturess.com ↗
Bradley Cooper makes an assured directorial debut with this fourth mounting (fifth if you count the original inspiration, 1932's What Price Hollywood?) of the venerable tale of two talents falling in love as their careers head in opposite directions.
The earliest riff on the story, also directed by Cukor and produced by David O. Selznick, is frankly titled What Price Hollywood?, with certain different details—a love triangle, a child—but the outcomes and themes the same.
The Ringer • Oct 8, 2018
theringer.com ↗
The Invisible Man poster
There are echoes of Ingrid Bergman in this performance – not only from Gaslight but from Notorious.
James Berardinelli • ReelViews • Feb 28, 2020
reelviews.net ↗
There are parallels here to the classic 1944 film "Gaslight," about a man who bullies and manipulates his wife into thinking that she is going crazy.
Noah Berlatsky • NBC News • Feb 29, 2020
nbcnews.com ↗
Following their doubts, an abused partner eventually stands up to their abuser to the audience’s satisfaction: see 1944’s Gaslight to 2002’s Enough , with many other examples in between and beyond.
Jordan Calhoun • Black Nerd Problems • Mar 12, 2020
blacknerdproblems.com ↗
Moss plays Cecilia Kass, the abused partner of a controlling tech entrepreneur who is developing advanced optics technology—and apparently watching 1944’s Gaslight on his down time.
josh • Larsen on Film • Mar 1, 2020
larsenonfilm.com ↗
No one believes her that her dead, invisible, abusive ex-boyfriend is pulling off the greatest gaslighting job since Charles Boyer in "Gaslight."
Dann Gire • Daily Herald • Feb 27, 2020
dailyherald.com ↗
The Princess Diaries poster
A similar theme in My Fair Lady was also acceptable to me.
Mark Lubischer, Betty Jo Tucker • ReelTalk Reviews
reeltalkreviews.com ↗
This is, of course, the same kind of Pygmalion story which launched Andrews herself to fame as Eliza Doolittle in the Broadway production of My Fair Lady all those years ago.
It's also a treat to have Andrews -- the actress who rose to fame playing such protegees as Eliza Doolittle in "My Fair Lady" and "Cinderella" in the Rodgers and Hammerstein musical of the same name -- back on the screen again, brightening up every one of her scenes just by being there.
Interbridge
archive.org ↗
Those of us who've fretted for years over Julie Andrews being dumped for Audrey Hepburn for the screen version of "My Fair Lady" can finally calm down — sort of.
So the story is a kind of "My Fair Lady," with Andrews taking on the Henry Higgins role of giving the girl a spectacular makeover, teaching her manners, filling her with noblesse oblige and overcoming her heel-dragging reluctance.
The Seattle Times
archive.org ↗
Adapted from Meg Cabot's novel by Gina Wendkos ("Coyote Ugly"), "The Princess Diaries" blends bits of  "My Fair Lady," "Anastasia," and "Pocketful of Miracles" for its tale of a commoner whose royal grandmother grooms her for a global stage.
Reeling Reviews • May 9, 2020
reelingreviews.com ↗
Kingsman: The Secret Service poster
Director Matthew Vaughn mixes a wallop of James Bond with a bit of Austin Powers, stirs in a little “Hunger Games,” adds a flavor of “My Fair Lady,” and finishes it off with a dash of “28 Days Later.”
Rebecca Cusey • The Federalist • Feb 14, 2015
thefederalist.com ↗
Cross-genre pollination has brought us My Fair Lady meets James Bond, Jason Bourne and Jack Bauer.
Alex Doenau • Trespass • Feb 16, 2015
trespassmag.com ↗
With nods to John Steed (the umbrella) and Harry Palmer (the glasses), this finds Taron Egerton’s “Eggsy” recruited by an elite super-spy unit of gentlemanly spooks who attempt to transform him from effing estate kid to Old Etonian killer in My Fair Lady fashion.
Mark Kermode, www.theguardian.com • The Guardian • Feb 1, 2015
theguardian.com ↗
Adapted by Vaughn and Jane Goldman from the Mark Millar and Dave Gibbons comic as a kind of self-aware riff on Pygmalion or, really, My Fair Lady, the writers keep things moving.
Stephen Rebello • Playboy • Feb 10, 2015
playboy.com ↗
It's the story of a streetwise London youth named Eggsy (Taron Egerton) who is rescued from his life of petty crime and run-ins with the law by a posh secret agent named Harry Hart (Colin Firth) and trained to be a new generation of spy (as the film cheekily points out, it's basically "Pretty Woman" or "My Fair Lady," but with way more guns), working for a top secret, privatized spying operation.
Drew Taylor • IndieWire • Feb 11, 2015
archive.org ↗
She's All That poster
"She's All That" is basically yet another tale of how clothes make the girl, another brick in the "My Fair Lady"/"Guys and Dolls"/"Pretty in Pink" wall.
A modern take on Pygmalion and My Fair Lady, She’s All That really offers nothing new.
Euegene Novikov • Film Blather • Feb 19, 2013
archive.org ↗
There have been numerous versions of George Bernard Shaw's Pygmalion story produced on big and small screens, the most popular of which is probably 1964's My Fair Lady.
Of course it is an unbreakable rule of this formula that the ugly duckling is a swan in disguise: Rachael Leigh Cook is in fact quite beautiful, as was Audrey Hepburn , you will recall, in "My Fair Lady."
RogerEbert.com
rogerebert.com ↗
La La Land poster
As their fortunes start to seesaw, the film acquires some of the stormy turbulence of “A Star Is Born,” as well as glimmers of the doubt and disconnection of “The Umbrellas of Cherbourg.”
Owen Gleiberman • Variety • Aug 31, 2016
variety.com ↗
Does it reinvent or improve upon “Singin’ in the Rain”, “A Star is Born”, “The Umbrellas of Cherbourg” and the legions of classic films and musicals it references, borrows from?
Roger Moore → • Rogers Movie Nation • Nov 29, 2016
rogersmovienation.com ↗
And throughout “La La Land,“ there are references to many musicals, from the faux Paris dance finale of “An American in Paris” and the career trajectory melodrama of the 1954 version of “A Star is Born,” as well as the dream ballet from “Oklahoma” and the jazz club scenes from “Funny Face.”
Gary Kramer • Salon • Dec 15, 2016
salon.com ↗
That’s what Chazelle has done with musicals like The Umbrellas of Cherbourg and A Star Is Born and Singin’ in the Rain.
The story, a star-crossed romance between a down-and-out actress (Emma Stone) and a brooding jazzbo (Ryan Gosling), may echo Martin Scorsese's New York, New York (1977) and, earlier still, George Cukor's A Star Is Born (1954).
The plot—her artistic career competes with his artistic career—is an old one, A Star Is Born for the iTunes generation.
Tom Shone • Newsweek • Jan 7, 2017
newsweek.com ↗
Miss Congeniality poster
You would never guess it from the trailer, but "Miss Congeniality" was probably inspired by either the musical "My Fair Lady" or its inspiration, George Bernard Shaw's stage play "Pygmalion."
"Miss Congeniality" has a hard time getting past its by-the-numbers, routine plot that pulls in the usual chestnuts of undercover cop tale, "My Fair Lady," fish-out-of-water story and, for good measure, a romance.
Reeling Reviews • Jun 3, 2020
reelingreviews.com ↗
Little surprise, really, that Miss Congeniality was not only better as My Fair Lady , but also better as a straight farce a year earlier with Drop Dead Gorgeous .
She's the Man poster
From Katharine Hepburn's bizarre early disaster Sylvia Scarlett on, the concept of girls being boys never really seems to take onscreen.
Crimson Peak poster
Instead, he’s billed it as a “Gothic romance” in the vein of Alfred Hitchcock’s Rebecca or George Cukor’s Gaslight.
David Sims, Erica Moriarty, Conor Friedersdorf, Jaclyn Skurie, Caitlin Cadieux, Alice Roth, Nadine Ajaka, Julia Ioffe, Matthew Stewart, Russell Berman • The Atlantic • Oct 16, 2015
archive.org ↗
Kingsman: The Golden Circle poster
Thus here is a bigger and sillier movie, albeit one not nearly as clean and well-structured as 2015’s My Fair Lady by way of axe-wielding superspies.
David Crow • Den of Geek • Sep 19, 2017
denofgeek.com ↗
It was a spy version of My Fair Lady, and it worked, because in it’s world building of an original action series, it was also a tongue in cheek parody of the James Bond franchise, to the degree of creating brand excitement for young people in it’s audience to consider the purchase of sharp, tailored suite carried by the Mr. Porter brand in the same way Bond timelessly sports a Timex watch and drives an Aston Martin.
Evan Griffin • The Young Folks • Sep 19, 2017
theyoungfolks.com ↗
2014’s Kingsman: The Secret Service has a fairly succinct premise: an ultra-violent, laddish James Bond crossed with My Fair Lady, from Kick-Ass director Matthew Vaughn.
Adi Robertson • The Verge • Sep 18, 2017
theverge.com ↗
While not shy on carnage, the earlier “Kingsman” focused on Eggsy’s transformation from a streetwise hood into a dapper young super-spy — basically, the movie was “My Fair Lady” meets James Bond, as Eggsy learned to dress smart, talk properly and save the world, taking his shirt off just often enough to remind what the movie was really selling.
Peter Debruge • Variety • Sep 18, 2017
variety.com ↗
If the first film drew its magic from a “My Fair Lady”-like attempt by Firth to prove breeding doesn’t determine gallantness, the sequel lacks a central idea.
Toronto Sun • Sep 20, 2017
torontosun.com ↗
At the end of the first film, he’d gone through his My Fair Lady-riffing transformation to become a fully-fledged member of the titular secret service operation; this one drops us, Bond-style, into the midst of a big set piece involving a former rival and a ludicrously violent and over-the-top punch-up in the back of a speeding cab.
The Scotsman
scotsman.com ↗
Pretty Woman poster
(Roberts in the red gown is meant to remind us of the transformed Audrey Hepburn in My Fair Lady.)
MaryAnn Johanson • Flick Filosopher • Sep 9, 1999
flickfilosopher.com ↗
Written by newcomer J.F. Lawton, the comedy is a mosaic of "Moonstruck," "Splash," "The Fabulous Baker Boys," "Working Girl," "My Fair Lady" and "An Officer and a Gentleman," among others.
Rita Kempley • The Washington Post • Mar 23, 1990
washingtonpost.com ↗
Elizondo plays the My Fair Lady game as solid as I’ve ever seen, and Alexander plays the soulless short asshole as only he can.
FilmCritic.com
archive.org ↗
Whitney poster
There are points where Whitney feels a little bit like George Cukor's 1950s version of A Star Is Born, a film whose domestic conversations and confrontations have a bracing chill because the camera keeps its distance and the moments aren't excessively hyped with background music.
Matt Zoller Seitz • Vulture • Jan 18, 2015
archive.org ↗
There’s also a touch of shorthand in the depiction of Brown, what with the story’s “A Star Is Born”-like aspects as her career soars while his operates on a more mortal plane.
Brian Lowry • Variety • Jan 15, 2015
variety.com ↗
DaCosta and other cast members, including Arlen Escarpeta as Brown and Mark Rolston as music mogul Clive Davis , almost manage to overcome a cliche-ridden script by Shem Bitterman that proves, if nothing else, that he’s seen either George Cukor ’s “What Price Hollywood” or various versions of its spawn, “A Star Is Born.”
The Half of It poster
As if it’s isn’t enough to have such an intelligent pairing that includes odes to Casablanca , The Philadelphia Story , and references to Sartre, Camus, and even Powell’s Books, there’s also another tender platonic love story in the growing friendship between Ellie and Paul, who could’ve easily come off as a dumb jock stereotype if he weren’t so tenderly written and played with sweet intensity by Diemer.
Andrea Thompson • The Young Folks • May 2, 2020
theyoungfolks.com ↗
The specter of those films is balanced by the classic movies (including “Casablanca,” “The Philadelphia Story” and “Wings of Desire”) Ellie watches with her father that cast a thematic glow over the proceedings.
Kevin Crust, www.latimes.com, kevin-crust • Los Angeles Times • Apr 30, 2020
latimes.com ↗
That’s how it starts, cribbing sentiments from the old film romances (“Casablanca,” “Wings of Desire,” “The Philadelphia Story”) her dad watches, nonstop.
Roger Moore → • Rogers Movie Nation • May 1, 2020
rogersmovienation.com ↗
Phantom Thread poster
In something of a “My Fair Lady” theme, Alma eventually comes to live at Reynold’s house, starts to learn the craft of dressmaking, and becomes his latest muse for fashion.
But this is not “Funny Face” or “My Fair Lady” or “Pretty Woman” or any number of “ugly” duckling turns to swan with the help of a hairbrush/expensive clothes/great man stories.
At times he recalls Professor Higgins in Shaw’s “Pygmalion” and in its musical version, “My Fair Lady,” as well as other protagonists from the British theater and cinema – characters who manage their lives with unswerving rigor and impose their egocentric authority on those around them from the heights of the upper class.
Uri Klein • Haaretz • Feb 12, 2018
haaretz.com ↗
Killers of the Flower Moon poster
Killers of the Flower Moon is a three-hander on an epic canvas, a corrosive analysis of America’s colonialist and capitalist excesses as refracted through a marital melodrama in the vein of George Cukor’s Gaslight or Alfred Hitchcock’s Suspicion. As those artists did in those films, Scorsese cultivates a spellbinding air of uncertainty, even though it’s clear from the moment Ernest courts Mollie at his uncle’s insistence that little good will come from their pairing.
Keith Uhlich • Slant Magazine • Oct 13, 2023
slantmagazine.com ↗
Black Swan poster
It's reminiscent of older, better movies: the late-'40s backstage dramas A Double Life (Ronald Colman plays Othello and becomes fatally jealous of his actress ex-wife) and the classic ballet melodrama The Red Shoes; and of films about tender, troubled psyches ?
Wild and woolly, the movie is a breathtaking head trip that hails from a long tradition of backstage melodramas: 42nd Street, A Star Is Born, All About Eve, and, yes, that kitschy '90s relic, Showgirls.
Steven Rea, Inquirer Movie Critic • The Philadelphia Inquirer • Oct 14, 2010
philly.com ↗
Before I Go to Sleep poster
But in addition to Ingrid Bergman in “Gaslight,” one can recall actresses as different as Barbara Stanwyck and Doris Day involved in such claptrap, the former in “Sorry, Wrong Number” and the latter twice, in “Julie” and “Midnight Lace.”
Sleepless in Seattle poster
The best romantic movies aren't these dreamy tales of lovers destined for happiness; they're the movies--Gone With the Wind, His Girl Friday and Adam's Rib come to mind--that dramatize exactly why two characters are perfectly matched.
Standard8 Media
archive.org ↗
Fahrenheit 451 poster
Before long, Montag has secreted away a copy of David Copperfield, and his new life is born with expected complications.
Old School Reviews
archive.org ↗
Sex and the City poster
The sheer accumulated anticipatory goodwill of the audience is almost enough to carry the first hour of the film, and King has sated appetites with come-hither shots of Manhattan at its creamiest, funny cameos by some of Broadway’s most employed thespians, and a plethora of fashion parades—the hundreds of outfits sported by the four leads make this the most couture-heavy movie since the great days of Norma Shearer in Riptide and The Women.
Film Journal International
archive.org ↗