(To this day, I get annoyed when I see articles that spell out the twist in Shyamalan's splendid 1999 thriller "The Sixth Sense"; surely there are a few of you out there who haven't seen it yet.)
But as a writer, he's becoming a parody of himself: Eager to top the climactic twist of The Sixth Sense, he has masterminded three subsequent movies in which (unlike Sense) the "gotcha!" endings seem to be the only reason for their existence.
When this works -as it did in The Sixth Sense - the payoff can be immense.
I loved both ‘The Sixth Sense” and “Signs” True enough, I didn’t like “Unbreakable”, but even that was preferable to what I witnessed on screen in the form of “The Village”.
With The Sixth Sense, Unbreakable and Signs, Shyamalan created new and glorious cinematic experiences, twisting known conventions in ways I had never seen, taking huge risks and having them pay off, throwing all of our preconceptions to the wind in the process.
In The Sixth Sense , red announced the approach of the supernatural; in The Village, it announces Shyamalan's debt to not only the master, but also to greats like Vittorio De Sica and Nicholas Roeg.