Those who know Shyamalan's films, which are rapidly becoming a spooky mini-genre (also including "Unbreakable" and "Signs") know that the plot's the thing: The still-young writer/director likes to toy with our fears, surprising us with both the monster under the bed and the specter that walks in broad daylight.
The Village isn't really much worse than Unbreakable or the silly Signs, but Shyamalan's carny act already feels like it's decades old -- it's a shame, because some good ideas are squandered in a muddled thriller that ends up duping itself.
I loved both ‘The Sixth Sense” and “Signs” True enough, I didn’t like “Unbreakable”, but even that was preferable to what I witnessed on screen in the form of “The Village”.
With The Sixth Sense, Unbreakable and Signs, Shyamalan created new and glorious cinematic experiences, twisting known conventions in ways I had never seen, taking huge risks and having them pay off, throwing all of our preconceptions to the wind in the process.
The man has talent--I loved both The Sixth Sense and Unbreakable --but he has, too, the kind of ego that finds his name in three-story letters over the titles of his films and his mug on the covers of his DVDs alongside Bruce Willis and Mel Gibson.
The bond between 'their' world and ours was further extended in Unbreakable.