Burn After Reading fits into the Coens' filmography on the Raising Arizona-The Hudsucker Proxy-O Brother, Where Art Thou? side of the aisle, where the brothers' built-in handicaps as screenwriters are most apparent.
Of course, the Coens also wrote and directed “The Hudsucker Proxy,” so they’re aren’t incapable of producing the occasional misfire.
They followed their Cannes darling Barton Fink with the zany The Hudsucker Proxy, the Oscar recognition for Fargo yielded the stoner classic The Big Lebowski, and the willfully difficult, demanding The Man Who Wasn't There was quickly followed by the lightweight Intolerable Cruelty and a flimsy remake of The Ladykillers.
From Raising Arizona to The Hudsucker Proxy to Fargo to The Big Lebowski to O Brother, Where Art Thou, the Coens regularly assemble their stories to satirize if not outright ridicule the best laid plans of men with the brains of mice.
And quite a swell comedy it is, too; not as many laughs-per-minute as in Lebowski, certainly, nor even in The Hudsucker Proxy , but thanks to the supremely talented cast working at the peak of their abilities, it never wants for gut-busting dry comedy ("gut-busting dry comedy", now that I think of it, is another hallmark of the Coen style).