View:

Connections, in both directions

GoodFellas poster
A birds eye massacre echoes the finale of Taxi Driver, a 360-degree camera move borrows from The Matrix, and the messy, unpredictable violence is cut from the same cloth as Mean Streets and Goodfellas.
Nitrate Online
nitrateonline.com ↗
Consider that Goodfellas, the picture to which City of God is most often compared, presents a strong social context for its tale of violence and retribution.
Film Freak Central
filmfreakcentral.net ↗
Tarantino’s influence is all over City of God though the effortless grace with which the entire film is assembled more accurately brings to mind Scorsese’s Goodfellas.
Ed Gonzalez • Slant Magazine • Nov 14, 2002
slantmagazine.com ↗
The film has been compared with Scorsese's " GoodFellas ," and it deserves the comparison.
RogerEbert.com
rogerebert.com ↗
Rocket, who dreams of escaping from the City of God and becoming a photographer, is nominally the film’s protagonist, and he’s around to report on the big events and to fill the audience in on who’s who: He narrates in the breezy, info-laden style of Martin Scorsese’s Goodfellas (1990) and Casino (1995).
David Edelstein • Slate • Jan 17, 2003
slate.com ↗
A master like Martin Scorsese pulls off just this sort of insular amoral universe in "Goodfellas," to which "City of God" owes more than a little.
The Young and the Damned poster
I was prepared to see something akin to Hector Babenco's "Pixote" or Luis Bunuel's "Los Olvidados", but was disappointed to discover that the film had more in common with Quentin Tarentino.
Columbia University
columbia.edu ↗
Age-wise, some of the killers are in the mid-single digits, but City of God isn’t played as a tragedy of lost youth, like Los Olvidados (1950) or Pixote (1981).
David Edelstein • Slate • Jan 17, 2003
slate.com ↗
The filmmakers also texture the narrative with the same gritty documentary feel that Bunuel achieves in his devastating Los Olvidados by using many non-actors from the actual City of God neighborhood with hand held cameras while effectively incorporating better aspects of Tarantino's Pulp Fiction narrative structure.
user68 • Old School Reviews • Feb 18, 2022
oldschoolreviews.com ↗
Slumdog Millionaire poster
“Slumdog” is every bit as stylized as Mr. Boyle’s early works, and the film’s theme and exotic Mumbai locale undoubtedly invite comparisons to “City of God.” Adapted from a Vikas Swarup novel by “The Full Monty” scribe Simon Beaufoy, “Slumdog” adopts a zigzagging, time-jumping narrative that lends itself to Mr. Boyle’s over-the-top treatment.
Critics Notebook
criticsnotebook.com ↗
He combines the suspense of a game show with the vision and energy of "City of God" and never stops sprinting.”
Stylistically, Slumdog Millionaire explodes off the screen with a frenetic energy I haven’t seen since Fernando Meirelles’ City of God.
Tim Regan-Porter • Paste Magazine • Nov 12, 2008
pastemagazine.com ↗
Like Fernando Meirelles' City of God, Slumdog Millionaire is at times guilty of aestheticizing the poverty that it seeks to critique.
Dana Stevens • Slate • Nov 13, 2008
slate.com ↗
Boyle's modern-day fairy tale -- part " City of God , " part " Forest Gump " -- is just that wonderful, that joyous.
Pixote poster
When compared to an absolutely heart-wrenching work like Hector Babenco�s similar Pixote, City of God is quite obviously a minor work of a director that could possibly make major ones one day.
Movie Martyr
moviemartyr.com ↗
"City of God" takes you to a place that has only been explored in such harsh films as Hector Babenco's "Pixote" and the cult flick "The Harder They Come."
Reeling Reviews • Apr 10, 2020
reelingreviews.com ↗
Hearkening back to another groundbreaking work of Brazilian social realism, 1981's Pixote, Meirelles cast real-life street kids for his movie and then developed their characters and naturalistic "nonperformances" in a series of extensive, improvisational workshops.
The Weekly Planet • Mar 12, 2003
archive.org ↗
I was prepared to see something akin to Hector Babenco's "Pixote" or Luis Bunuel's "Los Olvidados", but was disappointed to discover that the film had more in common with Quentin Tarentino.
Columbia University
columbia.edu ↗
In a society of children and adolescents who have no homes and no money, crime is the natural way of survival, but they're not very good at it (the gangs in " City of God ," made 20 years later, are much more sophisticated).
RogerEbert.com
rogerebert.com ↗
Long before Fernando Meirelles and Kátia Lund made "City of God" in 2002, about Rio de Janeiro's youth-centric atmosphere of organized crime, director Hector Babenco set the bar for such explosive cinema with his brilliant 1981 film "Pixote."
ColeSmithey.com
colesmithey.com ↗
American Made poster
And it is, for a while, as Uruguayan cinematographer César Chalone (City of God) lays on vibrant images to a golden oldies soundtrack (think "A Fifth of Beethoven" and "Hooked on Classics").
Peter Travers • Rolling Stone • Sep 28, 2017
rollingstone.com ↗
It’s an entertaining one, shot in a variety of textures by City Of God cinematographer César Charlone: Exterior shots often pop with saturated color, while interiors have the faded look of a CRT display.
The A.V. Club • Sep 27, 2017
avclub.com ↗
Liman has more potent ploys at his disposal, like the cinematography of César Charlone, who shot “ City of God ” (2002), and who endows the new film, especially in its early patches, with the hot-but-faded glow that you get from an old transparency.
Anthony Lane • The New Yorker • Sep 25, 2017
newyorker.com ↗
The visual structure of American Made is erratic, combining a warm colour scheme (the frame looks like it’s been rubbed in orange rind) with wobbly camerawork from Uruguayan cinematographer César Charlone, who shot the 2002 classic City of God .
The Daily Review
com.au ↗
Enlisting “City of God” cinematographer César Charlone proves a canny move, as the Uruguayan’s roving, agitated camera style (not to mention a perspiring, overripe palette, heavy on hot yellows) implies antsy tension even in comparatively banal domestic scenes.
Guy Lodge • Variety • Aug 17, 2017
variety.com ↗
Liman writes each change in location, alliance and job across cinematographer César Charlone’s (Oscar-nominated for City of God ) warm-lit frames, or tasks editors Saar Klein (After the Fall), Andrew Mondshein ( The Mummy ) and Dylan Tichenor ( Triple 9 ) with keeping things snappy.
Sarah Ward, Jeremy Kay, Nikki Baughan • Screen Daily • Aug 17, 2017
screendaily.com ↗
What Ever Happened to Baby Jane? poster
Jonathan Pryce and Anthony Hopkins deliver a sit-back-and-marvel double-act masterclass that will be spoken of in the same breath as Travolta and Jackson in Pulp Fiction or Davis and Crawford in What Ever Happened to Baby Jane?
The Times • Nov 29, 2019
co.uk ↗
Jonathan Pryce and Anthony Hopkins deliver a sit-back-and-marvel double-act masterclass that will be spoken of in the same breath as De Niro and Pacino in Heat or Davis and Crawford in What Ever Happened to Baby Jane?
Mean Streets poster
A birds eye massacre echoes the finale of Taxi Driver, a 360-degree camera move borrows from The Matrix, and the messy, unpredictable violence is cut from the same cloth as Mean Streets and Goodfellas.
Nitrate Online
nitrateonline.com ↗
Amores Perros poster
Given that Amores Perros was routinely referred to as ‘the Mexican Pulp Fiction’, it might seem a little disingenuous to refer to City of God as ‘the Brazilian Goodfellas’.
ViewLondon
co.uk ↗
This ultra-realist MTV-style spectacle has the style and urgency of Amores Perros but none of its moral ambiguities—every other line of Rocket’s more or less throwaway voiceover makes gratuitous reference to the holiness and irony of the film’s title and everyone’s not-so-divine function as god, devil or angel of vengeance.
Ed Gonzalez • Slant Magazine • Nov 14, 2002
slantmagazine.com ↗
In 2001, Alejandro González Iñárritus Amores perros made use of Pulp Fictionesque skewed chronology, hip, lowlife heroes, kinetic camera work and editing, glib cynicism, and lurid violence in a redolently squalid Mexico City setting.
The Boston Phoenix
bostonphoenix.com ↗
Like the similarly potent Amores Perros and Black Hawk Down, City of God is not merely a rubberneck tour of an urban underbelly or war zone.
North Bay Bohemian • Jul 7, 2005
newsreview.com ↗
Cut from the same glossy mold as Alejandro I��rritu�s Amores Perros and Alfonso Cuar�n�s Y Tu Mam� Tambi�n, City of the God, despite its myriad flaws, gives the impression that it�s going to be similarly well-received and viewed by many as the arrival of a major international talent.
Movie Martyr
moviemartyr.com ↗
Tsotsi poster
Like Fernando "City of God" Meirelles, Gavin Hood is definitely a filmmaker to keep a close eye on.
ComingSoon.net
archive.org ↗
What does it say that this South African export won the 2006 Oscar for Best Foreign-Language Film when the similar but more shattering City of God didn't even place back in 2003?
Director Gavin Hood keeps the movie moving at a breezy, unsentimental clip with a fast-paced, gritty style similar to City Of God, while energetic Kwaito music blasts throughout the picture.
Corey Chichizola published, Eric Eisenberg published, Dirk Libbey published, Nick Venable published • CinemaBlend • Feb 1, 2026
cinemablend.com ↗
A widescreen wallow in socially enforced slum nihilism brought to you by Miramax, Tsotsi could be pegged as City of God relocated to the Soweto shanties, but it eschews the ironic swagger and strobe-speed action of Fernando Meirelles's lurid jigsaw for a more conventional arc: the tough guy humanized by a cute kid.
Jessica Winter • The Village Voice • Feb 24, 2006
archive.org ↗
Writer-director Gavin Hood easily could’ve stripped down Athol Fugard’s novel of personal responsibility and cultural empathy into a Hallmark-esque distillation of “City of God.” Instead, Hood retained this redemption song’s minor key — bullets, blood and beatings meant to illustrate a descent into dangerous living.
With its unflinching look at impoverished youth running rampant, brandishing handguns and attitude in equally volatile amounts, "Tsotsi" invites comparisons with the brilliant Brazilian film "City of God" ("Cidade de Deus").
The Third Man poster
Ralph Fiennes stars as a mild-mannered member of the British High Commission in Kenya whose radical activist wife (Rachel Weisz) is brutally slain; investigating her murder, he gradually pieces together a tale of corruption involving the pharmaceutical industry that's every bit as horrific as (and much more timely than) Harry Lime's killing of babies with diluted penicillin in The Third Man.
It was the classic The Third Man that showed that such films succeed by relying on well-defined, intriguing characters who drive the story so that message (in that case, the evil of black-market drug dealing in post-war Vienna) simmers in a back seat.
Fiennes proves why he’s one of Hollywood’s best, Weisz earns that Oscar nomination, and Merielles gives some utterly amazing direction in a truly worthy successor to “The Third Man” with a sad, taut, and excellent global mystery.
Felix Vasquez • Cinema Crazed • Feb 20, 2006
cinema-crazed.com ↗
Taxi Driver poster
A birds eye massacre echoes the finale of Taxi Driver, a 360-degree camera move borrows from The Matrix, and the messy, unpredictable violence is cut from the same cloth as Mean Streets and Goodfellas.
Nitrate Online
nitrateonline.com ↗
7 Prisoners poster
It seems wearily inevitable that comparisons will be drawn between 7 Prisoners , the newest drama from rising star Alexandre Moratto, and City of God , perhaps the defining film of 21st century Brazilian cinema (that multi-award-winning drama’s director, Fernando Meirelles, is on producing duties here, alongside Ramin Bahrani of The White Tiger fame.)
Produced by renowned Brazilian filmmaker Fernando Meirelles, known for his iconic, Rio-set film City of God and whose latest film The Two Popes was also on Netflix.
television journalist, Ben regularly writes reviews, attends film festivals. Also • AwardsWatch • Sep 7, 2021
awardswatch.com ↗
As far as texture goes and ambition goes, this isn’t “City of God” and Moratto isn’t Fernando Meirelles.
Roger Moore → • Rogers Movie Nation • Nov 12, 2021
rogersmovienation.com ↗
Two of the producers, Ramin Bahrani and Fernando Meirelles, have made a fair number of these films, including “99 Homes,” “The White Tiger” and “City of God” between them.
Noel Murray, www.latimes.com, noel-murray • Los Angeles Times • Nov 4, 2021
latimes.com ↗
Filmmaker Fernando Meirelles, director of “City of God,” is a producer here, and “7 Prisoners” shares that Oscar-nominated gangster drama’s cinéma vérité sensibility.
Alan Zilberman • The Washington Post • Nov 1, 2021
washingtonpost.com ↗
Like White Tiger , another foreign-language exploration of class released on Netflix earlier this year, 7 Prisoners was produced by Ramin Bahrani (along with City of God director Fernando Meirelles and others) and finds a tidy metaphor for capitalism in miniature.
Jessica Toomer, Josh Kurp, Steven Hyden, Reyna Cervantes, Derrick Rossignol, Philip Cosores, Jason Tabrys, UPROXX Entertainment • Uproxx • Oct 18, 2024
uproxx.com ↗
Ajami poster
The two new Israeli co-directing filmmakers, Yaron Shani, a Jew, and Scandar Copti, a Palestinian, surmount the Crash-like coincidences through the realistic improvised dialogue and interactions of the many nonprofessional actors whose life-stories were matched to the characters, creating a similar feel to how Fernando Meirelles and K�tia Lund integrated their nonprofessional cast�s experiences into City of God.
Indeed, comparing it to some of Amos Gitai's better films ( Yom Yom , Alila , etc.) it feels rather graceless, and compared to something like City of God , it feels practically inert.
Combustible Celluloid
combustiblecelluloid.com ↗
Set in the multiethnic city of Jaffa, this Academy Award nominee for Best Foreign Language Film is like an Israeli Amores Perros crossed with City of God.
By showing how people fail to live together – in a film you could call Israel’s City of God, with its sectarian-feuding story lent power and immediacy by improvisation and non-professional casting – Ajami shows how they might or should live together.
7 Boxes poster
“City of God”-like, agile camerawork by commercials cinematographer Richard Careaga is smudgy yet breathtaking, and combined with a pumping score that mixes electronic music and local, traditional instruments it delivers, well, the goods.
A cat-and-mouse thriller imported from Paraguay, "7 Boxes" evokes the developing-world amorality and senseless crime caper of "City of God," the 2002 Brazilian sensation that earned four Academy Award nominations, including one for Fernando Meirelles' slick, hyper-stylized direction.
Children of Men poster
Children of Men did it with infertility.
PopMatters
archive.org ↗
Julianne Moore (2006's " Children of Men ") is remarkable, sometimes a one-woman show in the way that she stands apart from the others and tries with all her might to keep a brave face.
TheMovieBoy
themovieboy.com ↗
Like 2006's Children of Men, the story functions within a palpable reality, but unlike that superior film, its message is emphasized over that story rather than the other way around.
Todd Gilchrist • IGN
archive.org ↗
But compared with more successful examples, such as "Children of Men," "28 Days Later" and even the spotty "I Am Legend" (which also featured Braga as a mother-surrogate leading an orphaned boy through the apocalypse), "Blindness" feels stilted, claustrophobic and more stylish than substantial.
Calendar Live
archive.org ↗
It’s an adaptation of the 1995 novel by Nobel Prize winner José Saramago, and at first blush it seems to fall into the same mold as Children of Men: a serious film that uses the sci-fi premise of a near-future dystopia to comment on the modern-day dystopia already upon us.
The Magdalene Sisters poster
The Two Popes is a far cry from critical Peter Mullan’s The Magdalene Sisters or Pablo Larrain’s The Club, but it benefits from tackling difficult subjects, but packaging them in a manner that will have broad appeal.
Kaleem Aftab • The National • Jun 20, 2021
thenational.ae ↗
The Two Popes is a far cry from the deconstruction of the institutions of the church seen in films such as Peter Mullan's Golden Lion winner The Magdalene Sisters or the Berlin Grand Prix laureate The Club.
Kaleem Aftab • Cineuropa • Dec 12, 2019
cineuropa.org ↗
Bird Box poster
At least, that’s what should be frightening about the “Bird Box” premise, which author Josh Malerman hatched in novel form, where readers’ imaginations were free to fill in that unseen terror as they saw fit — a device that he may as well have lifted from Stephen King’s “The Mist” or José Saramago’s “Blindness.”
Peter Debruge • Variety • Nov 13, 2018
variety.com ↗
Rio poster
This is a lightweight family cartoon, not City of God or something.
www.facebook.com, Steven D. Greydanus • Decent Films Guide
decentfilms.com ↗
Clearly, Blue Sky Studios (the team behind the “Ice Age” movies) were merely looking for as colorful a setting as possible but anyone who knows the real-life story of Brazil (or has seen “City of God”) may think that this was an unusual subject matter.
HollywoodChicago.com
hollywoodchicago.com ↗
It's not exactly "City of God," but there's at least some acknowledgment that life's not all about samba and sunbathing in Rio.
Leslie Felperin • Variety
archive.org ↗
So Blu and his human, Linda, do like Fred and Ginger and fly down to Rio, Rio by the sea-o, where they run afoul of some "City of God"-inspired thieves and their murderous cockatoo henchman ( Jemaine Clement ) and spend most of the picture searching for each other.
Chicago Tribune • Chicago Tribune • Apr 14, 2011
archive.org ↗
City of God in a kids’ movie?
Brazil, of course, has a strong movie past with City Of God among the many stories to have used the country as a backdrop.
Beasts of No Nation poster
At first, the scene recalls the ruthless killings by the child gangs in 2002's "City of God ," but unlike that scenario, these boys aren't murdering for power or acclaim.
Oliver Whitney • The Huffington Post • Sep 15, 2015
huffingtonpost.com ↗
Nashville poster
Like Altman's "Nashville", the city itself is a character in the film, with its broken housing, dirt parks and rampant crime.
Big Picture Big Sound
bigpicturebigsound.com ↗