An opening sequence set in 1969 Wisconsin depicts crazed local journalist Larry Redmon ( Saw writer-director Leigh Whannell) embarking on a shotgun shooting rampage, murdering eight neighbors before killing himself.
The glare of sunlight belies the horror we’re about to witness, as Larry (Leigh Whannell of “Saw” and “Insidious” fame) targets vintage-costumed victims with a shotgun, asking them who they told.
As refashioned by Penner, the picture opens decades in the past, when a reporter named Redmon (Leigh Whannell, one of the original “Saw” creators) goes on a killing spree ending in suicide, muttering the movie’s advertising tagline, “Don’t think it.
Larry (Leigh Whannell, "Saw," "Insidious"), who mutters 'Don't think it, don't say it' over and over, has covered his living room with the warning.
There’s also a bizarre, fitfully amusing prologue (which later morphs into an impromptu flashback) featuring Leigh Whannell, the Saw and Insidious scribe having what appears to be a grand time hamming it up as a journalist who should have left a story involving a perplexing 1969 murder spree well enough alone.
Less cohesive elements would be the earnest appearance of Carrie Anne Moss as a thoroughly intuitive detective, or an outright terrible performance from Leigh Whannell (the scribe of contemporary genre films directed by James Wan, like the Saw and Insidious franchises), although these extremes are a lot more interesting than the tepid sexual tensions playing out between the three leads, all of whom give serviceable performances in rather subpar characterizations.