View:

Connections, in both directions

Armageddon poster
Emmerich directs a script he co-wrote with Harald Kloser and Spenser Cohen and it comes close to camp, recalling ’90s disaster flicks like “Armageddon,” some high concept from “Interstellar,” some Emmerich DNA from “The Day After Tomorrow” and even call-backs to “2001: A Space Odyssey” and “Planet of the Apes.”
Mark Kennedy, obit, apnews.com, mark-kennedy • The Associated Press • Feb 3, 2022
apnews.com ↗
Along the way, the film samples liberally from Emmerich’s past projects, with a dash of Independence Day and plenty of The Day After Tomorrow to go along with 2012 ‘s conspiracy-friendly inspiration, and it’s hard to miss the overt similarities to some films he didn’t make, like 1998 meteor-disaster adventure Armageddon .
Rick Marshall, www.facebook.com • Digital Trends • Feb 4, 2022
digitaltrends.com ↗
(Let’s also take this as a sign to continue making blockbusters where the actors actually have chemistry, people!) Wilson confronts the potential end of the world with a subtlety reminiscent of Bruce Willis in Armageddon: He’s tormented but not brooding, disheveled but not hopeless, brave but not a martyr.
Moonfall has moments that recall obvious sci-fi influences like The Matrix as well as his one-time competitors like Michael Bay's Armageddon and half-forgotten curiosities like Brian De Palma's Mission to Mars .
Jesse Hassenger • TheWeek • Feb 3, 2022
theweek.com ↗
Additionally, the music by Harald Kloser (who’s also one of the film’s co-writers) may be a pastiche of warmed-over themes from “Armageddon” and “The Day After Tomorrow,” but it attempts to inject some tension and excitement into the film.
Rob Dean • Bullz-Eye.com • Feb 3, 2022
bullz-eye.com ↗
With them as they launch off on an “Armageddon” (1998)/“Don’t Look Up” (2021)-like mission is a nerdy extrovert with IBS (a very Rickey Gervais-esque John Bradley of “Game of Thrones,” bringing the much-needed comic relief).
Tom Meek • Cambridge Day • Feb 4, 2022
cambridgeday.com ↗
The Tomorrow War poster
The Tomorrow War manages to combine the best bits of Edge Of Tomorrow , Arrival , Armageddon , Alien , Independence Day , and God knows what else in the kind of movie that Michael Bay or Roland Emmerich would’ve directed in their primes if they’d had more talent.
Jessica Toomer, Josh Kurp, Steven Hyden, Reyna Cervantes, Derrick Rossignol, Philip Cosores, UPROXX Entertainment, Jason Tabrys • Uproxx • Oct 18, 2024
uproxx.com ↗
Here’s a high-concept sci-fi film attempting to channel the energy of Independence Day , complete with some decent star power and capable action direction.
Aaron Neuwirth, www.facebook.com • WeLive Entertainment • Jul 1, 2021
weliveentertainment.com ↗
Earth has been invaded by aliens, à la “Independence Day.” Said invasion is actually occurring in 2051, so the children of the next generation who haven’t been born yet have been sent back via wormhole in search of help with a last stand, à la “Terminator.”
Bundel • NBC News • Jul 1, 2021
nbcnews.com ↗
When compared to the ultimate in this category, “Independence Day,” where the President literally gets in a plane (after a stirring St. Crispin’s Day-style speech) to fight the aliens, it is impossible not think about what prompted it.
If you’re a fan of the Alien movie franchise or Independence Day then The Tomorrow War will be right up your alley.
Emmanuel "E-Man" Noisette, www.facebook.com • The Movie Blog • Jul 1, 2021
themovieblog.com ↗
It’s reminiscent of the anti-fascist “Starship Troopers,” the father-daughter centered “Interstellar,” and the punch-the-air alien conflict driving “Independence Day.”
Robert Daniels • Los Angeles Times • Jul 1, 2021
latimes.com ↗
Die Hard poster
Among today’s actors, someone like Bruce Willis could pull it off as well (and did so to a degree in the "Die Hard" films.)
Critic.Doctor
archive.org ↗
Unlike so many '90s films, though, the form that WHD takes is not exactly " Die Hard in an X", with X referring in this case to the White House; it was this exact tack taken by this spring's Olympus Has Fallen , a cheaply-made rushed knock-off of WHD that, as it turns out, is almost precisely at the same quality level as the movie it was copying, though for different reasons.
Director Roland Emmerich takes a break from blowing up the entire world (and completely blowing Anonymous ) to direct this Die Hard knock-off without shame, and he’s perfectly suited to the material, transforming a concept that Olympus Has Fallen made gruff and violent into an over the top crowd-pleaser.
William Bibbiani • Crave • Jun 26, 2013
archive.org ↗
While there’s more than a little of a “Die Hard” vibe here (more than in “Die Hard 5,” actually), Emmerich and screenwriter James Vanderbilt wisely don’t try to turn Tatum into a junior Bruce Willis.
Lou Lumenick • New York Post • Jun 26, 2013
nypost.com ↗
White House Down is yet another take on the old Die Hard formula, with more than a few nods to the fun Air Force One (1997) and to Emmerich's own Independence Day (1996).
Combustible Celluloid
combustiblecelluloid.com ↗
With its  Die Hard -in-the-White-House premise already taken out in a pre-emptive strike by  Olympus Has Fallen  earlier this year,  White House Down  suddenly had to do more than just rely on its high concept.
Steve Newall • Flicks • Sep 4, 2013
co.nz ↗
Oblivion poster
You know a pictures derivative when a list of titles in the same genre technically constitutes a string of spoilers Blade Runner, Independence Day, The Matrix, Moon, Planet of the Apes, Star Wars, WALL-E, 2001.
adminnewspack, Lucy Tompkins, Colin Flanders, Hannah Bassett, Ken Picard, Vermont Stage, Kevin J. Kelley, Mary Ann Lickteig, Alice Dodge, Melissa Pasanen • 7 Days in Vermont • Jun 25, 2025
7dvt.com ↗
So despite the fact that well-read sci-fi fanatics might get distracted while mentally ticking off familiar plot points (Independence Day, Moon) and visual references (2001: A Space Odyssey), the upside is that, derivative as Oblivion may be in many respects, it still manages to hold our attention by presenting compelling ideas about our concept of reality, and prodding our imaginations by avoiding simple answers and explanations.
, who proved with "Independence Day" that you can make an entire entertainment out of nothing but shameless references to past sci-fi hits.
Mike Russell | Special to The Oregonian, Mike Russell, Special to The Oregonian • The Oregonian/OregonLive • Apr 18, 2013
oregonlive.com ↗
Along the way, my mind turned to "Wall-E," "Moon," "Independence Day," and even "An Affair to Remember," to name only a few of the many other works Kosinski borrows from.
Cuz then you walk into Oblivion with no recollection of 2001: A Space Odyssey and Independence Day and 2012 and The Road Warrior and Planet of the Apes and the entire history of science fiction movies, and hence you’ll enjoy yourself ever so much more.
Focusing on duplicating a litany of big screen inspirations like Independence Day, Moon and, surprisingly, The English Patient, Kosinski doesn’t seem interested in carving out a unique voice for himself.
CinemaSight
cinemasight.com ↗
The Poseidon Adventure poster
Inspired by popular pseudoscientific claims that the Mayan calendar predicts the world will end on Dec. 12, 2012, the film is a sort of disaster-genre greatest hits collection, gathering the tidal waves from "The Perfect Storm" and "The Poseidon Adventure," the temblors from "Earthquake," the volcanoes from "Volcano" and "Dante's Peak," the fireballs from "Armageddon," and other special-effects traumas into that paradoxical form of entertainment that allows viewers to escape their real-life woes by imagining something far, far worse.
John Beifuss ( Contact ), GoMemphis.com Friday, John Beifuss • The Commercial Appeal • Nov 13, 2009
archive.org ↗
He has become the modern day “Master of Disaster,” a title once bestowed on filmmaker Irwin Allen thanks to the success of his back-to-back blockbusters The Poseidon Adventure and The Towering Inferno.
Rumoured to cost some $260 million (U.S.) – figure most of it went for CGI – 2012 liberally lifts from the Irwin Allen playbook, especially The Poseidon Adventure, right down to the cruise ship turned turtle by a gigantic tsunami.
Even “master of disaster” Irwin Allen liked to shake up the status quo in such films as The Poseidon Adventure and The Towering Inferno, but Emmerich has no imagination: His A-listers live, his support players die.
When the ill-fated cruise ship of The Poseidon Adventure (1972)?a film Emmerich and co-writer Harald Kloser reference here more than once?was capsized by a tidal wave, my 10-year-old self may have understood that flesh-and-blood stuntmen, not actors, were hanging off those upside-down cocktail tables, but I still feared for them and, by extension, for the film's characters.
The Village Voice
villagevoice.com ↗
Emmerich is more of a kindred spirit to the late schlockmeister producer Irwin Allen ("The Swarm," "The Poseidon Adventure") than he is to Michael Moore, and "Day" is far more effective as a guilty-pleasure popcorn extravaganza than as any kind of a serious political statement.
Interbridge
archive.org ↗
2001: A Space Odyssey poster
Borrowing liberally from The War of the Worlds, 2001: A Space Odyssey, Close Encounters of the Third Kind and seemingly every other sci-fi outing this side of Santa Claus Conquers the Martians, the picture somehow manages to recycle these reference points and come up with something that works on its own terms.
Matt Brunson • Creative Loafing Charlotte • May 4, 2016
clclt.com ↗
Emmerich directs a script he co-wrote with Harald Kloser and Spenser Cohen and it comes close to camp, recalling ’90s disaster flicks like “Armageddon,” some high concept from “Interstellar,” some Emmerich DNA from “The Day After Tomorrow” and even call-backs to “2001: A Space Odyssey” and “Planet of the Apes.”
Mark Kennedy, obit, apnews.com, mark-kennedy • The Associated Press • Feb 3, 2022
apnews.com ↗
Note the visual nods to wallpaper from The Shining (1980) and the white void from 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968), then watch Room 237 (2012).
Brian Eggert • Deep Focus Review • Feb 4, 2022
deepfocusreview.com ↗
By the time the story reaches its out-there conclusion — involving aliens’ ability to channel our inner thoughts in order to communicate with us in terms we can understand — it’s become clear that the screenwriters have seen 2001: A Space Odyssey too many times.
Frank Scheck • The Hollywood Reporter • Feb 3, 2022
hollywoodreporter.com ↗
Stylistically, “Moonfall” has roots in everything from “2001: A Space Odyssey,” the granddaddy of speculative science-fiction films, to the “Terminator” series, with its deadly, self-aware AI, and the look and piloting wizardry of the “Star Wars” films.
The Boston Herald • Feb 4, 2022
bostonherald.com ↗
These involve a primordial conflict, aliens, A.I., and the creation of the human species, and they’re brought to the screen with audaciously flimsy versions of key moments from the Stargate sequence in “2001: A Space Odyssey.”
Richard Brody • The New Yorker • Feb 4, 2022
newyorker.com ↗
Bloodshot poster
The most noticeable influence is “Universal Soldier,” a film that shares so many plot elements that “Bloodshot” can be classified as a blatant rip-off.
Odie Henderson • RogerEbert.com • Mar 13, 2020
rogerebert.com ↗
Wilson’s Bloodshot is a lame Universal Soldier ripoff starring an aged Vin Diesel as the title superhero.
Evan Dossey • Midwest Film Journal • Mar 25, 2020
midwestfilmjournal.com ↗
Such a concept traverses much of the same territory as Universal Soldier and RoboCop , among others.
Todd Jorgenson • Cinemalogue • Mar 13, 2020
cinemalogue.com ↗
Bloodshot is based on a Valiant comic, but for less comic book literate viewers, it may remind you more of sci-fi films like Robocop or Universal Soldier .
Fred Topel • CheatSheet • Mar 11, 2020
cheatsheet.com ↗
Van Damme's biggest hit – debatably – was a cheerfully nonsensical load of rubbish called Universal Soldier , in which Van Damme starred alongside Dolph Lundgren as soldiers who had been killed in action, reanimated by some futuristic technology, to carry out nefarious missions under the cover of being, err, dead.
Graeme Tuckett • Stuff • Mar 12, 2020
co.nz ↗
Hey, this critic’s pulse probably never broke 35 during the 109-minute runtime, and say what you want about the schlocky, soldiers-turned-cyborgs “Universal Soldier” (1992), but at least Dolph Lundgren stood opposite Jean-Claude Van Damme throughout the cheesy nonsense.
Jason Carney • Phoenix Film Festival • Mar 13, 2020
phoenixfilmfestival.com ↗
Pearl Harbor poster
One return to form was Midway , although it suffered from low-quality CGI after being practically self-financed, yet it was easily better than Michael Bay’s abomination Pearl Harbor.
Grim D. Reaper • MovieCrypt • Feb 4, 2022
moviecrypt.com ↗
Midway pays tribute to fallen American heroes even as the film may also be a spiritual sequel to an earlier Pacific-set World War 2 film, Pearl Harbor .
Danielle Solzman • Solzy at the Movies • Nov 6, 2019
solzyatthemovies.com ↗
Director Roland Emmerich thankfully relies on the (barely) competent special effects to make the battle scenes exciting but otherwise, there’s a bunch of second-rate aerial photography and copycat shots from Michael Bay’s “Pearl Harbor” (like a tired p.o.v.
Screen Zealots • Screen Zealots • Nov 8, 2019
screenzealots.com ↗
Oh, it's not "Pearl Harbor" horrific, and most of the actors do their best with a wholly clunky script that plays like an homage to John Wayne "war pictures," but this "Midway" was made for the ADHD generation.
Frank J. Avella • Edge Media Network • Feb 18, 2020
edgemedianetwork.com ↗
Both of these specimens of testosterone-fueled all-American derring-do (played by Brits who periodically struggle with their accents) are real historical figures, as are almost all of the characters in Midway , which attempts to dramatize the most famous naval battle of World War II by drawing equal inspiration from the monotonous historical reenactments of 1970’s Tora! Tora! Tora! , the butt-numbing soap-opera spectacle of 2001’s Pearl Harbor , and the Irwin Allen influences of Emmerich’s own disaster movies.
That’s not to say the script has to go into full-on weepy romance territory like Michael Bay’s “Pearl Harbor” (2001), but Moore is too big a star not to use her considerable talents.
Jason Fraley • WTOP • Nov 11, 2019
wtop.com ↗
Godzilla poster
Before long I realized that it could not compare to “Independence Day”, another earth is in danger—what will we do type flick.
Louis Proyect • CounterPunch • May 23, 2014
counterpunch.org ↗
It'll absolutely leave your jaw dropped — assuming you've never seen a Transformers film, Independence Day, Armageddon, 2012, War of the Worlds, Cloverfield, Pacific Rim or any of the dozens of other ear-splitting effect fests that have offered pixelated spectacles of mass destruction since the dawn of CGI.
Seven Days Staff • Seven Days • Jul 23, 2025
sevendaysvt.com ↗
Although he’s the lead actor, Taylor-Johnson plays the role with resignation, as if Edwards didn’t want him to act like Will Smith from “Independence Day.”
BlackFilm • Dec 5, 2018
blackfilm.com ↗
This rebooted Godzilla owes a lot of its structure to Emmerich's outstanding Independence Day.
Kristy Puchko • CinemaBlend • May 11, 2014
cinemablend.com ↗
The story begins in the Philippines in 1999 (the year after the last Godzilla , directed by Roland Emmerich–a dreadful picture to which this one makes no reference).
Kurt Loder, Jared Dillian, Jacob Sullum, Elizabeth Nolan Brown, Eric Boehm, Billy Binion • Reason • May 16, 2014
reason.com ↗
Godzilla returns in an installment that's certainly better than Roland Emmerich's disastrous 1998 effort, with the movie's relatively subdued vibe ensuring that the film, at the outset, stands in sharp contrast to most contemporary blockbusters (which are, with few exceptions, overblown and oppressively frenetic).
Pacific Rim poster
It would be too easy to write Pacific Rim off as a bad mash-up of the worst components of Roland Emmerich’s alien-invasion extravaganza Independence Day (1996) and Michael Bay’s insufferable Transformer movies had it been directed by someone other than del Toro, the Mexican-born fantasy-horror auteur whose sharply pronounced visual acumen and obsession with everything weird, surreal, and uncanny has made him one of the most fascinating filmmakers of the past decade.
Q Network
qnetwork.com ↗
At one point, the squadron’s stern leader (Idris Elba, commanding in a stock role) delivers a pep talk virtually identical to Bill Pullman’s inspirational speech in Independence Day .
Matt Schimkowitz, Saloni Gajjar, Oliver Sava, Casey Epstein-Gross, Paste Staff, Christina Izzo, Madeline Blondeau, Elijah Gonzalez, Jim Vorel, William Hughes • The A.V. Club • Apr 19, 2022
avclub.com ↗
“Independence Day,” another Roland Emmerich joint).
Cinemix Tape
cinemixtape.com ↗
There's plenty of strategic talk and grim pronouncements counteracted by inspiring speeches of the "Independence Day" variety, but the real stars of "Pacific Rim" are the set pieces.
Eric Kohn • IndieWire • Jul 8, 2013
archive.org ↗
Then there’s a kendo sparring match straight out of The Matrix and its kung-fu forerunners, a cheer-inducing pre-battle speech with echoes of Independence Day (“Today, we are canceling the apocalypse!”), and a finale in which a bomb must be placed in the aliens’ lair/cavern/alternate dimension.
See if you can catch those Independence Day and/or Deep Blue Sea moments and you’ll know the sort of “borrowing” I’m referring to.
Kofi Outlaw • Screen Rant • Jul 12, 2013
screenrant.com ↗
The Abyss poster
Emmerich is apparently a big James Cameron fan, since huge chunks of Moonfall are ripped off from The Abyss (with a little Terminator-flavored “AI strikes back against its human creators” concept).
James Berardinelli • ReelViews • Feb 4, 2022
reelviews.net ↗
In Moonfall , the voyage to the moon is reasonably interesting, even if it shamelessly borrows from The Abyss and Contact , so what happens on earth is more of a distraction.
Alan Zilberman • Spectrum Culture • Feb 3, 2022
spectrumculture.com ↗
Moonfall cribs from the best with beats clearly inspired by The Terminator , The Abyss , and others as the story grows from silly to inane, and while its Elon Musk love is disturbing and its “Karen” joke already outdated there’s still plenty to have fun with here.
Rob Hunter • Film School Rejects • Feb 4, 2022
filmschoolrejects.com ↗
Elements of 2001: A Space Odyssey , The Abyss , the Terminator franchise, and so many other massive science fiction stalwarts crash into one another with freewheeling abandon.
Sara Michelle Fetters
moviefreak.com ↗
Simply take a pinch of Contact, a dash of The Abyss, a tablespoon of Independence Day, and a cup of Armageddon, mix them all together and the result is Moonfall.
Allison Rose, www.facebook.com, FlickDirect Inc • FlickDirect • Feb 3, 2022
flickdirect.com ↗
More than two hours of cobbled together bits of everything from The Abyss to the Terminator series, 2001 , The Core , Prometheus , Transformers: Dark of the Moon , Melancholia and Armageddon , all packaged in a blur of second-rate CGI and pseudo-science that attempts to quote Carl Sagan, but has more in common with the conspiracy theories of David Icke.
James Croot • Stuff • Feb 3, 2022
co.nz ↗
Battleship poster
The plot sounds like a combination of “Independence Day,” “Armageddon” and “Transformers,” and in many ways, this film tries to replicate the formula that made those three pictures massively successful.
John. P. Hanlon • Breitbart News • Jul 21, 2025
breitbart.com ↗
Nevertheless, for a film based on an outdated board game, “Battleship” delivers a nice balance of action and humor that reminded me a lot of another alien invasion movie, “Independence Day.” It’s probably more on par with the first “ Transformers ” than the Roland Emmerich sci-fi classic, but the sheer fact that it's entertaining at all makes “Battleship” more of a hit than a miss.
Jason Zingale • Bullz-Eye • May 18, 2012
bullz-eye.com ↗
Simply put, if you have a hankering for a mindless two-hours plus of a movie that combines elements of that along with familiar bits of the "Transformers" films and "Independence Day," you could do far worse than what's offered here.
The script by Erich and Jon Hoeber get away with setting a naval battle at Pearl Harbor by teaming up the Japanese and the Americans against a shared enemy, but they still err just a little too much on humanizing the inhuman villains-- we can deal with either anonymously evil aliens (Independence Day style) or oddly sympathetic ones (District 9 style), but not some middling combination of the two.
Katey Rich • CinemaBlend • May 27, 2016
cinemablend.com ↗
There are small moments where the movie achieves the kind of dopey fun Roland Emmerich delivered in Independence Day.
Whereas a movie like Independence Day (in all its cheese) told a globe-hopping story with enough time to take a breath and get to know the people being blown up, Battleship spends over two hours (over two hours!) doing exactly one thing: lobbing explosives back and forth.
Film School Rejects • May 18, 2012
archive.org ↗
Arrival poster
They don't start firing lasers like "War of the Worlds" or blowing up the White House like "Independence Day."
Scripted by Eric Heisserer based on Story of Your Life, by short-fiction writer Ted Chiang, Arrival is more or less the anti-Independence Day.
David Rooney • The Hollywood Reporter • Sep 1, 2016
hollywoodreporter.com ↗
But unlike your typical "Independence Day" fare, "Arrival" is more focused on the suspense and nuance of an actual alien encounter.
Deseret News • Feb 2, 2026
deseretnews.com ↗
That's what Arrival tries to capture, in its own low-key, non-Independence Day kind of way.
Beginning conventionally in the vein of an Independence Day or The Day The Earth Stood Still, the film opens with the sudden arrival of twelve mysterious alien spaceships in various locations around the world.
Concrete Playground • Nov 10, 2016
concreteplayground.com ↗
While sci-fi fans might flock to see the thing thinking that it’s some alien invasion epic like an Independence Day, this is more strange and even cerebral, and is less about ‘Them’ than ‘Us’, and how powerful our words can be – especially when misinterpreted.
The Adelaide Review
com.au ↗
Apocalypto poster
Regardless of one's critical opinions of individual films, it's hard to deny the balls-out, ultra-visceral, stylistically audacious approaches of "Apocalypto" and "300" injected some fresh excitement into a long-dormant and generally derided genre.
Todd McCarthy • Variety
archive.org ↗
An amalgamation of much better movies, riffing on offerings as diverse as Quest for Fire, Apocalypto, The Ten Commandments, and any number of creaky ancient myths, Emmerich has finally hit the Monterey Jack-pot.
PopMatters
archive.org ↗
Emmerich's version of the Pleistocene epoch has just about everything - woolly mammoths, a sabre-toothed tiger, feathered dinosaurs with jaws like white pointers and a tribe of extras who look as if they have wandered across from Mel Gibson's Apocalypto.
Sandra Hall, reviewer • The Sydney Morning Herald • Mar 6, 2008
com.au ↗
If those evil folk sound suspiciously like refugees from Mel Gibson's "Apocalypto," that's not the only movie "10,000 BC" plunders.
Emmerich borrows from BRAVEHEART and APOCALYPTO, so such conjecture has a basis in what turns up on screen.
D'Leh's heroic journey begins after his love, Evolet (Camilla Belle), is kidnapped along with numerous other tribespeople by the slave raiders of a far-off civilization, ruled -- as in "300" and the quite similar "Apocalypto" -- by sophisticates whose superior learning, technology and architectural ingenuity are equated with cruelty, idolatry and sexual perversity (the steps of their Cyclopean pyramids are rife with Mandarin-nailed eunuchs).
X-Men: Apocalypse poster
Many moons ago, the first mutant Poe Dameron… whoops, sorry, make that Apocalypse (Oscar Issac) was inexplicably blindsided by a bunch of slaves he thought were under his thumb who buries him for all time — cue Stargate theme — right up until someone foolishly unearths his tomb in Egypt and provides exactly the right ingredients to bring him back to life.
Grim D. Reaper • MovieCrypt • Dec 14, 2016
moviecrypt.com ↗
Isaac’s bellowing “all-powerful” Apocalypse, who strode the Earth in 3,600 B.C., appears to have been borrowed from the deliberately camp 1994 mashup of sci-fi, ancient Egypt and transgender daring that was “Stargate.”
Migration User • The Boston Herald • May 27, 2016
bostonherald.com ↗
But here’s an entry that starts more like “Stargate” or “The Fifth Element” than “Captain America: Civil War.” It’s here we meet our main baddie: the eponymous blue meanie, played by the usually charismatic Oscar Isaac, trapped in makeup and a suit that make him look and act like a block of painted granite that talks (occasionally, a bit).
This messy sequel (technically still a prequel) goes back further to ancient Egypt, where a proto uber-mutant’s Temple of Doom- style-meets- Stargate regeneration is stalled, only to resume in 1983.
Mark Kermode, www.theguardian.com • The Guardian • May 22, 2016
theguardian.com ↗
Braveheart poster
Emmerich borrows from BRAVEHEART and APOCALYPTO, so such conjecture has a basis in what turns up on screen.
Strait easily is the worst actor ever tasked to give the “Braveheart” morale speech — by now so easy a caveman could do it.
It’s like Apocalypto meets Stargate (the movie, not the TV show) with bits of Jurassic Park and Braveheart thrown in, cuz those were great movies, right?
Stealing cues from “Apocalypto,” “Braveheart,” and his own “Stargate” (not to mention numerous other films), Emmerich has assembled a funky bouillabaisse of derivative material glued together by the CG sequences, which imagine a land populated with grazing mammoths, fierce saber-tooth tigers, and massive ostrich-like creatures that allow Emmerich a chance to rip-off the Velociraptor attack from “Jurassic Park.”
Brian Orndorf
brianorndorf.com ↗
Unfortunately, visual effects and far-out ideas aren’t enough to overcome a film overflowing with banal dialogue spoken in an unconvincing accent (supposedly a mix of Standard English and Arabic), a bland love story that borrows from "Apocalypto" and "Last of the Mohicans," a dully self-doubting hero unwilling to “heed the call” and become a leader in the "Braveheart" mold, not one, but two plot-propelling prophecies short on logic, a thumbs-down worthy supernatural turn, and one too many unanswered questions about the pyramid builders and where they came from.
JFK poster
A much-loved actor who shall remain nameless gets a choice cameo wherein he Explains Much that recalls his even choicer cameo wherein he Explains Even More in Oliver Stone’s “JFK” (1991).
Mark Feeney • The Boston Globe • Feb 3, 2022
bostonglobe.com ↗
And the 86-year-old Donald Sutherland shows up for about two minutes to reprise his JFK role, 30 years later, as the guy who explains the whole conspiracy and then exits the movie.
Stephen Silver • Goomba Stomp • Feb 4, 2022
goombastomp.com ↗
Fragmented-family problems ensue, along with the gravity problems, plus tidal waves; moon chunks hurling into mountains and skyscrapers; and, because the plot depends on a massive government conspiracy to hide the truth, a brief cameo from Donald Sutherland in “JFK” mode.
(Remember the character Sutherland played in that excellent scene in Oliver Stone’s 1991 drama “JFK”?
Mark Meszoros • The News-Herald • Feb 3, 2022
news-herald.com ↗
I suspect that Emmerich wanted the scene to play with the furious momentum of the actor’s famous sequence in JFK (1992), where Sutherland expounds on the many factors that led to Kennedy’s assassination.
Brian Eggert • Deep Focus Review • Feb 4, 2022
deepfocusreview.com ↗
At one point, Donald Sutherland shows up at an unlikely location, blurts out some helpful information about a government coverup faster than you can say "JFK" and disappears almost as quickly.
Brian Lowry • CNN • Feb 3, 2022
cnn.com ↗
Battle: Los Angeles poster
“The Dark Knight’s” Aaron Eckhart maintains a stern upper lip and has to spout a number of cheesy lines without any of the humor that worked so well coming out of Will Smith’s mouth in the similar and superior “Independence Day.”
Daily Film Fix • Mar 10, 2011
dailyfilmfix.com ↗
We’ve seen enough war films (‘Black Hawk Down,’ ‘Saving Private Ryan‘), and we’ve seen our share of alien films (‘Independence Day,’ ‘Starship Troopers,’ ‘District 9‘), and when you combine both of those elements in one film, we’ve also seen plenty of that as well.
BlackFilm • Dec 5, 2018
blackfilm.com ↗
The Recipe: One part War of the Worlds, one part generic stoic army guy movie from 1957 set during WWII, one part Independence Day, one part goofy dialogue that makes it seem like the screenwriter watched Airplane!
Dave White • Movies.com
movies.com ↗
It's more Hurt Locker than Independence Day.
Grae Drake • Movies.com
movies.com ↗
The script for “Battle: Los Angeles,” by Christopher Bertolini, uses every “save the earth from aliens” cliché it can lay its hand on, like “War of the World” (the bad one with Tom Cruise, not the good one with Gene Barry) and, especially, “Independence Day.” Aaron Eckhart must have known, while making “Battle: Los Angeles,” that he is the star of nonsensical sci-fi drama that relies more on the (well-done) special effects than on good writing.
Reeling Reviews • Jan 10, 2020
reelingreviews.com ↗
Rather, Battle: Los Angeles follows the playbook of Independence Day and Godzilla, as filtered through the more manageable budget of the likewise shaky-cam Cloverfield: monsters come to your town and take heavy artillery, as Soldiers and Relatable Innocent Civilians duck for cover.
Peter Canavese • Groucho Reviews
grouchoreviews.com ↗
Mission to Mars poster
Moonfall has moments that recall obvious sci-fi influences like The Matrix as well as his one-time competitors like Michael Bay's Armageddon and half-forgotten curiosities like Brian De Palma's Mission to Mars .
Jesse Hassenger • TheWeek • Feb 3, 2022
theweek.com ↗
But as it blasts into space — cue the strikingly topsy-turvy image of a shuttle struggling to rise amid cascading water — the increasingly, entertainingly ludicrous story seems to draw as much inspiration from “Gravity,” “Prometheus,” “The Terminator” and “Mission to Mars,” to say nothing of Emmerich’s own past space operas like “Independence Day” and “Stargate.”
Justin Chang, Justin Chang Film Critic, www.latimes.com, justin-chang • Los Angeles Times • Feb 3, 2022
latimes.com ↗
The filmmaker, working with a script he co-wrote with Harald Kloser and Spenser Cohen, also gets to flex his penchant for wild conspiracy theories, and ends up churning out a film that feels heavily indebted to Brian De Palma's somewhat forgotten 2000 sci-fi movie "Mission to Mars."
Chris Evangelista • /Film • Feb 3, 2022
slashfilm.com ↗
Barring a third-act expository info-dump (which, incidentally, positions this madness as Emmerich’s mega riff on De Palma’s misunderstood Mission to Mars ) Moonfall just never stops.
Luke Gorham • InReview • Feb 3, 2022
inreviewonline.com ↗
Interstellar poster
Emmerich directs a script he co-wrote with Harald Kloser and Spenser Cohen and it comes close to camp, recalling ’90s disaster flicks like “Armageddon,” some high concept from “Interstellar,” some Emmerich DNA from “The Day After Tomorrow” and even call-backs to “2001: A Space Odyssey” and “Planet of the Apes.”
Mark Kennedy, obit, apnews.com, mark-kennedy • The Associated Press • Feb 3, 2022
apnews.com ↗
Wilson is an actor ideally suited to a role like this: a combo of spacefaring machismo and soft-hearted dad vibes, he feels like an off-brand attempt at recapturing the McConaughy magic of Interstellar , and though that’s typically meant as an insult, oftentimes (at least when it comes to soda and beer) it works just as well.
Nick Johnston, www.facebook.com, nick.johnston • Vanyaland • Feb 4, 2022
vanyaland.com ↗
It’s like the silliest parts of Contact and Interstellar slammed into each other, but without either of their scientific foundations.
Dov Kornits • FilmInk • Dec 21, 2024
com.au ↗
There is a surprising swerve into 2001/Interstellar territory in the third act that perks things up, but otherwise way too many of the 130 minutes are devoted to the thinly drawn familial dynamics of characters played by Patrick Wilson, Halle Berry, John Bradley, Michael Pena, and Charlie Plummer.
josh • Larsen on Film • Feb 7, 2022
larsenonfilm.com ↗
Without even getting into Emmerich's (he co-wrote the script with Spenser Cohen and Harald Kloser) "Interstellar"-like final act or his depiction of A.I. as a big black blob, there's little to recommend here outside of campy, accidental laughs.
Adam Graham, The Detroit News • The Detroit News • Feb 3, 2022
detroitnews.com ↗
Moonfall has quite a few things in common, visually and thematically, with films like Robert Zemeckis’ Contact and Christopher Nolan’s Interstellar , which looked at our place in the universe with wonder, awe, and a posture of serious inquiry.
Stephen Silver • Goomba Stomp • Feb 4, 2022
goombastomp.com ↗