View:

Connections, in both directions

The Matrix poster
Not only is Ghost in the Shell a close runner up to 1988’s Akira as one of the best Manga-based anime films (the Manga for both sagas began in the same publication: Young Magazine), but serves as an animated prototype for 1999’s The Matrix.
The philosophical concepts pondered here — the intersection of mankind and machinery, the troubling, anesthetizing spread of mass technology — are no longer as startling as they were in an era before “The Matrix,” to name the most significant beneficiary of “Ghost in the Shell’s” influence.
Justin Chang, Justin Chang Film Critic, www.latimes.com, justin-chang • Los Angeles Times • Mar 30, 2017
latimes.com ↗
Ghost in the Shell doesn’t have that mainstream pedigree, but Mamoru Oshii’s once-groundbreaking cyberpunk visual aesthetic — which inspired The Matrix — gives Snow White and the Huntsman director Rupert Sanders and his production team a blueprint to achieve some seriously eye-popping work.
While many aspects of Ghost in the Shell will be familiar to Americans from the likes of Steven Spielberg’s Artificial Intelligence: A.I. and Minority Report , James Cameron’s Avatar and above all The Matrix , that’s a tribute to the massive cultural influence of Ghost in the Shell .
Steven D. Greydanus • National Catholic Register • Mar 31, 2017
ncregister.com ↗
Ghost in the Shell poster
This week’s repackaged old idea is a live-action version of the classic Japanese comic book Ghost in the Shell , which itself inspired the 1995 anime film with the same name.
It isn’t a remake of Mamoru Oshii’s sci-fi animated feature , which is a classic of the genre, but a very studious homage; the plot is original (provided one has never played a video game influenced by Ghost In The Shell), though it draws ideas from later animated adaptations of Masamune Shirow’s manga series.
Jarrod Jones, Emma Fraser, Jesse Hassenger, Elijah Gonzalez, Saloni Gajjar, Moises Taveras, Matt Schimkowitz, Benjamin Cannon, Garrett Martin, Grant Sharples • The A.V. Club • Apr 19, 2022
avclub.com ↗
"Ghost in the Shell": From the potential blockbuster vein comes this Scarlett Johansson starrer, based on Mamoru Oshii's 1995 animated take on the same story and, apparently, some other quite nifty Japanese stuff that fans of this punky genre readily acknowledge and take very seriously.
John M. Urbancich, John M • cleveland.com • Mar 31, 2017
cleveland.com ↗
In Ghost in the Shell, based on a Japanese manga comic of the early 1990s (which inspired a fascinating 1995 animated film), Johansson plays, inevitably, a full-on robot named Major.
Will Leitch • The New Republic • Mar 31, 2017
newrepublic.com ↗
If the "ghost" of anime classic Ghost in the Shell refers to the soul looming inside of its killer female cyborg, then this live-action reboot from director Rupert Sanders really only leaves us the shell: a heavily computer-generated enterprise with more body than brains, more visuals than ideas, as if the original movie’s hard drive had been wiped clean of all that was dark, poetic and mystifying.
Jordan Mintzer • The Hollywood Reporter • Mar 28, 2017
hollywoodreporter.com ↗
A chain-smoking scientist character from “Innocence,” explicitly modeled on “A Cyborg Manifesto” author Donna Haraway, gets repurposed as a simple plot functionary.
The Japan Times
co.jp ↗
Minority Report poster
While many aspects of Ghost in the Shell will be familiar to Americans from the likes of Steven Spielberg’s Artificial Intelligence: A.I. and Minority Report , James Cameron’s Avatar and above all The Matrix , that’s a tribute to the massive cultural influence of Ghost in the Shell .
Steven D. Greydanus • National Catholic Register • Mar 31, 2017
ncregister.com ↗
Ghost in the Shell is a stunning film to look at, taking that cyberpunk aesthetic to new heights with nods to the likes of Blade Runner , Minority Report and (or course) the anime original.
Matt's Movie Reviews
mattsmoviereviews.net ↗
Blackhat poster
Blackhat is not a sci-fi film, but this comes close to being what a Michael Mann live-action take on Ghost in the Shell might look like – and until a final act reveal, it shares with that cyberpunk cornerstone the concept of a cat-and-mouse chase with an unknowable malevolent force.
The Skinny
co.uk ↗
Alita: Battle Angel poster
It’s a little Æon Flux, a little Ghost In the Shell, and even some Akira and Speed Racer.
Matt Cipolla • Film Monthly
filmmonthly.com ↗
Based upon the three-decades old Japanese comic series “Gunnm” created by Yukito Kishiro, there are a lot of expectations for this adaptation, especially in light of the whitewashing controversy surrounding the lukewarm Scarlett Johansson live-action feature Ghost in the Shell.
Grim D. Reaper • MovieCrypt • Feb 14, 2019
moviecrypt.com ↗
It has long been fact that western adaptations of eastern material (more specifically Japanese manga) have never quite hit the mark; from the casting debacle of 2017’s Ghost in the Shell to the letdown of Netflix’s Death Note that same year, so you won’t be surprised by people's trepidation going into Battle Angel, but it must be said that this is easily the most faithful manga adaptation to date - and that may be down to the fact that it’s been twenty years in the making.
Starburst Magazine • Feb 2, 2019
starburstmagazine.com ↗
Live-action adaptations of anime and manga haven’t had the best of luck in Hollywood, at least if we’re looking at big theatrical attempts like Ghost in the Shell or Dragon Ball Evolution .
Meagan Navarro • Bloody Disgusting • Feb 1, 2019
bloody-disgusting.com ↗
Two years ago, at around this same time, Scarlett Johansson's Ghost in the Shell crashed and burned due to an irresponsibly conceived story that put into stark relief the whitewashing of its main character.
Emma Stefansky • Thrillist • Feb 1, 2019
thrillist.com ↗
Dumbo poster
Directed by idiosyncratic madman Tim Burton and written by Ehren Kruger ( The Ring , Ghost in the Shell ), this update wears its larger-than-life heart on its sleeve and is singularly composed to enthrall children with its sense of magical wonderment.
Sara Michelle Fetters
moviefreak.com ↗
The new version, directed by Tim Burton and written by Ehren Kruger (credits include three Transformers movies, The Ring and Ghost in the Shell), clocks in at almost two hours and puts the human characters upfront.
Chris Knight • National Post • Mar 27, 2019
nationalpost.com ↗
The script for 2019’s Dumbo from Ehren Kruger ( Ghost In the Shell ) not only shifts the focus away from the wonderful Dumbo and onto the humans who are caring for the elephant, but also expands the tale into a larger one of self-love and the importance of family.
Douglas Davidson • Elements of Madness • Jun 23, 2019
elementsofmadness.com ↗
El guion, firmado por Ehren Kruger (quien escribió las películas de Transformers y, más recientemente, el inerte remake de Ghost in the Shell ), no agrega una pizca de profundidad a sus personajes, que tienen una presencia casi anecdótica, con la excepción de Eva Green que deslumbra cuando entra en cada escena, aunque la nueva musa del director está siendo gastada al igual que Depp en su momento.
In their place, Burton and scripter Ehren Kruger (whose credits range from the underrated pair Arlington Road and Ghost in the Shell to the awfulness of The Brothers Grimm and three — count ‘em, three — Transformers flicks) decided that they should instead focus on the human characters, because Lord knows that’s what people really want to see when they attend a movie ostensibly about a flying elephant.
Matt Brunson • The Film Frenzy • Mar 29, 2019
thefilmfrenzy.com ↗
Director Tim Burton (Sweeney Todd) uses his gothic style to darken the mood and screenwriter Ehren Kruger (Ghost in the Shell) takes the narrative into unfamiliar places in comparison to the cartoon, but when the titular pachyderm is not front and center, Dumbo feels like it’s gliding, not soaring.
Tech Tease • San Antonio Current • Jan 26, 2011
sacurrent.com ↗
A Letter to Momo poster
Though his previous work as a director was 1999's very different "Jin-Roh: The Wolf Brigade," Okiura and the key members of his creative team have connections to many classic anime, including "Ghost in the Shell," "Spirited Away" and "Paprika."
Kenneth Turan, www.latimes.com, kenneth-turan • Los Angeles Times • Aug 28, 2014
latimes.com ↗
Chalk the quality up to experience – Okiura has been in the animation game since the late 80s, and has varying credits on films ranging from Jin-Roh: The Wolf Brigade (which he directed), to Paprika (on which he was a key animator), to both Ghost in the Shell films (where he served as animation supervisor).
Movie Mezzanine • Aug 27, 2014
moviemezzanine.com ↗
He also worked as an animator or in other capacities on Akira , Ghost in the Shell, Cowboy Bebop: The Movie , Metropolis , Ghost in the Shell 2: Innocence , Paprika , and others.
Combustible Celluloid
combustiblecelluloid.com ↗
But it’s produced by renowned studio Production I.G., known for the influential sci-fi anime Ghost in the Shell.
A girl mourning the death of her father is visited by three mischievous spirits only she can see in “A Letter to Momo.” Marking a dramatic departure from his bloody 1999 debut, “Jin-Roh: The Wolf Brigade,” director Hiroyuki Okiura brings a dash of magic to this modern-day story, crafting precisely the sort of imaginative family-friendly toon auds expect from Studio Ghibli — only this one hails from Production I.G , the outfit responsible for the more adult-skewing “Ghost in the Shell” series.
Peter Debruge • Variety • Oct 5, 2011
variety.com ↗
One of the leading anime production companies currently operating in Japan, Production I.G., is best known for its work across various highbrow sci-fi and violent horror series such as Ghost in the Shell and Blood the Last Vampire.
The Matrix Resurrections poster
Although the first film plays as a For Dummies guide to Baudrillard's Simulacra and Simulation and Cartesian philosophy whose most compelling images are cribbed from Oshii's Ghost in the Shell , its sense of our collective, mechanized dehumanization and its hope that we might be, for all our despair, special, lingers on.
Bill Chambers • Film Freak Central • Dec 21, 2021
filmfreakcentral.net ↗
Snowden poster
It is here that Stone draws his picture of the nascent Snowden: shy but blunt, curious but trusting, intellectual but jingoistic… and, apparently, a big fan of Ghost in the Shell .
It’s supposed to be hip and funny that he and his girlfriend, Lindsay Mills (Shailene Woodley), strike digital sparks when they learn, in a geek chat room, that each loves the 1995 anime Ghost in the Shell .
Michael Sragow • Film Comment • Sep 15, 2016
filmcomment.com ↗
Death Note poster
Regional relocation is usually a kiss of death for cross-culture products (see: Ghost In The Shell), but Tsugumi Ohba (writer) and Takeshi Obata (illustrator), who created the cult-beloved Death Note manga, were quick to offer praise.
We Got This Covered
wegotthiscovered.com ↗
Like, it's the very definition of “whitewashed”, on par with Scarlett Johansson’s recent turn in the American Ghost in the Shell adaptation.
In the complicated and evolving conversation about Asian representation onscreen, adaptation, and erasure, it's not accurate to describe Death Note as replicating the exact outrages of Ghost in the Shell, which kept the cultural trappings of its source material while discarding the actual people.
Alison Willmore • BuzzFeed • Aug 26, 2017
buzzfeed.com ↗
This year’s Ghost in the Shell reboot, for example, attempted to address its own whitewashing controversy via the poor decision of introducing a whitewashing based twist into the narrative itself, leading to the sound of faces hitting palms in multiplexes across the globe.
Alistair Ryder, www.facebook.com • Film Inquiry • Aug 29, 2017
filminquiry.com ↗
Rough Night poster
Hillary-esque senatorial candidate Jess (Scarlett Johansson, Ghost in the Shell) is taken away to Miami for a hen’s weekend with her old friends: clingy and jealous Alice (Jillian Bell, Fist Fight), corporate queen Blair (Zoë Kravitz, TV’s Big Little Lies), trust-fund anarchist Frankie (Ilana Glazer, Broad City), and Jess’ Australian friend Pippa (Kate McKinnon, Saturday Night Life).
Johansson, who got swallowed up in the “Blade-Runner”-meets-broken-glass cyber doldrums of “Ghost in the Shell,” has long avoided this sort of unabashed megaplex comedy, but it’s a pleasure to see her take on a role in which she can coast along on the no-nonsense vibrance of her personality.
Owen Gleiberman • Variety • Jun 14, 2017
variety.com ↗
Scarlett Johansson (2017's " Ghost in the Shell ") is the straight heroine at its center, and she plays the situation real while occasionally aiming for humor that simply isn't inspired enough on the page to take flight.
Dustin Putman • The Film File
thefilmfile.com ↗
After Ghost in the Shell and Captain America: Civil War, it’s great to see Johansson in a role that lets her show her comedy chops.
Blade Runner poster
The Blade Runner theme of identity as a function of memory is raised but not explored.
Time Out
archive.org ↗
Kenji Kawai's soundtrack is just as striking, combining "Blade Runner" -like ambient blips with Oriental drumming and chants.
An anime classic, something like Blade Runner for the exploding IT industry of the ’90s, director Mamoru Oshii and screenwriter Kazunori It?’s adaptation of Masamune Shirow’s manga is a merger of the lullingly reflective and the action-propelled.
Vue Weekly
vueweekly.com ↗
Thunderbolts* poster
…the film opens on a tight close-up of Pugh before a skyscraper infiltration in the style of Ghost in the Shell…
Robbie Collin • The Telegraph • May 1, 2025
co.uk ↗
Blade Runner 2049 poster
The best sequel to Blade Runner is Mamoru Oshii's Ghost in the Shell 2: Innocence, with a long sidelong glance at Under the Skin, perhaps--and Her, too.
Film Freak Central
filmfreakcentral.net ↗
Blade Runner 2049's racial text is oft-plumbed by the horror and sci-fi genres, recently and with far more success by Jordan Peele's Get Out and Rupert Sanders's Ghost in the Shell .
Chuck Bowen • Slant Magazine • Oct 6, 2017
slantmagazine.com ↗
Heck, even this past spring’s justly maligned live-action remake of Ghost in the Shell went over this territory more efficiently.
www.fwweekly.com, kristian-lin, Kristian Lin • Fort Worth Weekly • Oct 4, 2017
fwweekly.com ↗
Death Note poster
For one thing, his Death Note doesn’t, like this year’s ghastly Ghost In The Shell, conclude with Nat Wolff’s Light revealing that, actually, he is really Asian after all.
Death Note adapted a story where Ghost in the Shell adapted a culture.
Regional relocation is usually a kiss of death for cross-culture products (see: Ghost In The Shell), but Tsugumi Ohba (writer) and Takeshi Obata (illustrator), who created the cult-beloved Death Note manga, were quick to offer praise.
Matt Donato • We Got This Covered • Aug 25, 2017
wegotthiscovered.com ↗
Like, it's the very definition of “whitewashed”, on par with Scarlett Johansson’s recent turn in the American Ghost in the Shell adaptation.
In the complicated and evolving conversation about Asian representation onscreen, adaptation, and erasure, it's not accurate to describe Death Note as replicating the exact outrages of Ghost in the Shell, which kept the cultural trappings of its source material while discarding the actual people.
Alison Willmore • BuzzFeed • Aug 26, 2017
buzzfeed.com ↗
Like 2017’s other feature film whitewash of Japanese manga, “ Ghost In The Shell ,” the pitfalls of “Death Note” only begin with its cursory adoption of an explicitly Eastern work for American audiences.
Metropolis poster
Yet anime's most visible cultural diffusion into the United States (at least until Princess Mononoke and Kawajiri's Vampire Hunter D: Bloodlust ) has been "hard" science fiction films like Mamoru Oshii's Ghost in the Shell and Katsuhiro Ôtomo's seminal Akira (easily the most-quoted "first" for most North American anime junkies).
Walter Chaw • Film Freak Central
archive.org ↗
Lacking the sheer visceral thump and mind-bending power of cyberpunk classics such as Akira or Ghost in the Shell, Metropolis is nevertheless a gorgeous and accomplished work.
CineVue • Cine-Vue • Jan 16, 2017
cine-vue.com ↗
Possessor poster
Pulling together imagery and themes explored in movies such as Ghost in the Shell and The Matrix, it envisions a retro-futuristic world (set in 2008, if you’re counting) where dubious and nefarious companies do backroom deals by jacking into the bodies of the unfortunates.
Terry Mesnard • Gayly Dreadful • Sep 28, 2020
gaylydreadful.com ↗
A queasy and intriguing horror-inflected techno-thriller that gets lost somewhere in the Bermuda Triangle between “Mandy,” “Inception,” and “Ghost in the Shell,” Brandon Cronenberg’s “Possessor” is so drunk on its own sick potential that it doesn’t have the time (or the balance) required to realize most of it.
David Ehrlich • IndieWire • Jan 26, 2020
indiewire.com ↗
But that author’s dystopian premonitions are just one aspect of its genre alchemy, a stylish mash-up of Ghost In The Shell , Inception , Under The Skin , and Olivier Assayas’ corporate-espionage thriller demonlover .
Archive poster
It winds up with direct visual echoes of Westworld and Ghost in the Shell , and its tone and setting specifics heavily recall Duncan Jones’ gloriously gritty science-fiction feature Moon .
Tasha Robinson • Polygon • Jul 10, 2020
polygon.com ↗
J3’s full body creation, with legs, hair, and skin, is an obvious homage to the shelling sequence from the opening of Ghost in the Shell .
Chris Sawin • Bounding Into Comics • Jul 7, 2020
boundingintocomics.com ↗
Jin-Roh: The Wolf Brigade poster
Written by Mamoru Oshii, director of the cult favorite "Ghost in the Shell," and directed by Hiroyuki Okiura, who worked as a key animator on "Akira," "Jin-Roh" offers a violent but compelling vision of what an animated feature can be.
CalendarLive
archive.org ↗
Written by Mamoru Oshii and directed by Hiroyuki Okiura, both of Ghost in the Shell fame, Jin-Roh begins in an alternate-reality Tokyo in which the Nazis won World War II.
Combustible Celluloid
combustiblecelluloid.com ↗
Jungle poster
In a year rife with whitewashing controversies on both the big (Ghost in the Shell) and small (Iron Fist) screens, the continued underrepresentation of Asian talent stains the film a bit.