Frequent series director Alan Taylor, whose career is far more distinguished on television ( Homicide: Life on the Streets , Mad Men , Game of Thrones ) than in film ( Thor: The Dark World , Terminator Genisys ), doesn’t evoke this vital Jersey history as vividly as he could, despite a soundtrack that’s full of deep rock and R&B cuts.
Written by showrunner David Chase and series writer Lawrence Konner, and directed by Alan Taylor—consistently solid on TV, winning an Emmy for “Kennedy and Heidi,” and consistently underwhelming on the big screen, winning my scorn for Thor: The Dark World—The Many Saints of Newark tracks the major moments in Moltisanti’s life in order to explain how Tony Soprano came to be, and to show that nothing has changed since the ‘60s and ‘70s.
Handsomely crafted by director Alan Taylor, easily his best feature film work after the disasters of “Thor: The Dark World” and “Terminator: Genisys,” the journeyman filmmaker does his best to make scenes look evocative, sinister, and one particular scene on the beach involving a murder—strangely beautiful in its confusion—but the craft on display can’t save the picture.
(Since the show, Taylor went on to helm horrid Hollywood blockbusters like “Terminator Genisys” and “Thor: The Dark World,” so we should probably be amazed that “Many Saints” is as good as it is.)
Taylor, who’s alternated high-profile HBO gigs with the big-budget franchise maintenance of Thor: The Dark World and Terminator Genisys , gives the film’s period setting a handsome museum sheen, while staging the shoot-outs and tense encounters with anonymous proficiency.