Hilary Swank, who has been languishing in tepid roles in films like "Insomnia" and "The Core" since winning an Oscar for "Boys Don't Cry," returns to her true level of expertise as Maggie, a woman whose toughness and resilience are matched by her inner gentility.
Hilary Swank, who just a film or so ago (The Core) was looking like she'd never again achieve the stunning effectiveness of Boys Don't Cry, is here subtle and moving.
Hilary Swank, too, is doing what she does better than anyone, narrow though it may be: playing, as she did in Boys Don't Cry, a poor, rural girl who fulfills her desire for self-determination by acting like a boy.
Hilary Swank seemed to get lost after her Oscar win for Boys Don’t Cry but here she proves that her success was no fluke.
And Swank, beefed up almost beyond recognition since her role in Boys Don’t Cry, muscles her way toward her second Best Actress Oscar.