Mr. Carpenter has demonstrated that he can make good, comparatively plain, old-fashioned scare movies (''Halloween'') and effective suspense thrillers (''Escape From New York''), but he seems to lose his own head when he combines two or more genres, as he did in ''The Fog'' and does again here.
Others will disagree and argue for "The Fog," "Starman," "Big Trouble in Little China," "Christine," "They Live," or others.
Carpenter's fourth feature as a director, "The Fog" was his first relative -- albeit honorable -- misfire; it's fairly unique as a 1980s horror movie, but it remains a lesser work in a directorial filmography that includes "Escape from New York," "The Thing," "They Live," "Big Trouble in Little China," even "Christine."
It has so much wonderful atmosphere and that amazing, inimitable music that can only be John Carpenter even when it's Ennio Morricone (See or rather listen to THE THING).
Of the first bunch of Carpenter films to be updatedincluding Assault On Precinct 13, Halloween, Escape From New York, and The Thing (itself a remake)the 1980 film The Fog has the most room for improvement.
(Bottin, of course, would reach a special effects pinnacle--arguably still unsurpassed and, in today's CGI-mad environment, possibly unsurpassable--with Carpenter in 1982's The Thing.)