The rest of the film's targets are more in line with expectations, with "Star Wars," "Men in Black," "Aliens," "Back to the Future," "Close Encounters of the Third Kind," and "Mac and Me" all cited at one time or another.
Pegg and Frost don't give themselves material comparable to their previous work, and most of the movie references- I counted "Star Wars," "E.T.," "Men in Black," "The X-Files," "Close Encounters" and even friggin' "Mac and Me"- aren't nearly as clever as the movie thinks they are.
An odd amalgamation of E.T., Close Encounters and Men in Black gets spoofed here, all within the superstructure of a fish-outta-water buddy road picture.
Early in their journey, they encounter a real-life alien (a CGI effect voiced by Seth Rogen) who is on the run from a glowering, deadpan Men In Black-style operative (Jason Bateman) and a pair of bungling FBI agents (Bill Hader and Joe Lo Truglio).
We can pick up the nods to Men in Black and Close Encounters, and appreciate the shrewd idea that Paul resembles E.T. because that’s what humans are conditioned to expect after all those movies, but nodding to something doesn’t automatically make it comic.
The rest of this road picture, directed by Greg Mottola of “Adventureland,” is about this trio trying to smuggle Paul awayl from the “Men in Black” he’s escaped from.