View:

Connections, in both directions

Beauty and the Beast poster
Visually, the characterization makes a nod to the scowling-eyed Beast from Jean Cocteau’s immortal “Beauty and the Beast” (1946), but he also comes off as a kind of royal version of the Elephant Man: a melancholy freak trapped in solitude.
Owen Gleiberman • Variety • Mar 3, 2017
variety.com ↗
Largely devoid of imagination, this Beauty And The Beast will likely hit its mark with plenty of viewers—those old enough to get a buzz of recognition from “Be Our Guest” (busily reconceived as a vortex of ones and zeroes) and those too young to know they’re watching a faded copy of last millennium’s family entertainment.
Stevens is one of the best parts of this “Beauty and the Beast” — right up there with Luke Evans’ blustery, conceited Gaston, with Kevin Kline’s doddering father, and with Ewan McGregor’s spastic, ostentatiously French-accented candelabra-man Lumiere.
Beauty and the Beast poster
“Beauty and the Beast” is far from spectacular, and it’s certainly leagues away from touching the iconography of the 1991 animated version, but it’s more than fine as a beautiful and touching homage to a film the writers, directors and stars clearly adore.
Allyson Johnson, Tom Meek, Oscar Goff, Zoe Beketova, Iris Zhan • Cambridge Day • Mar 14, 2017
cambridgeday.com ↗
Now, however, we have a remake of an undeniable classic—1991’s “Beauty and the Beast,” which had already been reworked for Broadway, and it’s more a direct copy than a remake.
One Guys Opinion • One Guy's Opinion • Mar 16, 2017
oneguysopinion.com ↗
While the recent versions of Cinderella and The Jungle Book featured small amounts of music from their animated inspirations, Beauty and the Beast goes all in, not only using all of the songs from the beloved 1991 film, but also adding a few new ones (the better to garner Oscar nominations).
Las Vegas Weekly
lasvegasweekly.com ↗
The only way Disney’s live-action remake of its own “Beauty and the Beast” works is if you don’t compare it to the 1991 animated masterpiece.
Eric D. Snider • Eric D. Snider • Mar 18, 2017
ericdsnider.com ↗
To say that the first trailer for Beauty and the Beast was evocative of the 1991 animated classic would be an understatement; it was a live-action carbon copy, and if Disney’s remake of Cinderella was any indication, we were in for yet another tedious — if visually stunning, well-acted, and beautifully designed — exercise in nostalgia.
Britt Hayes • ScreenCrush • Mar 3, 2017
screencrush.com ↗
The Sound of Music poster
On the downside, though, one of the first scenes shows Beauty standing on a hill à la Julie Andrews in The Sound of Music (1965).
Tony Medley's Reviews
tonymedley.com ↗
In a nervy move, Condon even references an iconic moment in “The Sound of Music.”
calvin wilson • St. Louis Post-Dispatch • Mar 17, 2017
stltoday.com ↗
Watson might be at her best right out of the gate while performing the song “ Belle ,” which begins with her bemoaning her provincial existence in a small town and ends with her singing on high amid lush green hilltops dotted with yellow wild flowers while channeling Maria in “The Sound of Music.”
RogerEbert.com
rogerebert.com ↗
While there's a certain obligatory quality to the staging, Condon has brought true buoyancy to several of the numbers, from Belle's introductory song -- which, in live action, looks more conspicuously like an homage to "The Sound of Music" -- to an appropriately rousing rendition of "Be Our Guest."
Brian Lowry • CNN • Mar 15, 2017
cnn.com ↗
Heaven knows, Julie Andrews was equally sweet in “The Sound of Music,” but she could also let rip with “I Have Confidence,” arms flung wide, as if to confess that sweetness alone would get you nowhere.
Anthony Lane • The New Yorker • Mar 27, 2017
newyorker.com ↗
Mary Poppins, The Hunchback of Notre Dame, Aladdin, even Fox’s The Sound of Music and Moulin Rouge are distilled into this emotional, exuberant, if somewhat de-fanged musical makeover.
Fionnuala Halligan, Chief Film Critic, Robert Daniels, Jeremy Kay, Amber Wilkinson • Screen Daily • Mar 3, 2017
screendaily.com ↗
The Invisible Man poster
Although he did a handful of other intelligent films, he is remembered for the witty, leisurely horror classics Frankenstein (1931), The Old Dark House (1932), The Invisible Man (Claude Rains’s 1933 starring début) and The Bride of Frankenstein (1935).
Mark Lubischer, Betty Jo Tucker • ReelTalk Reviews
reeltalkreviews.com ↗
For that matter, there was no housekeeper named Hannah (Oscar-nominated Lynne Redgrave, who was robbed that year by the Academy), but both probably are loose fits for Whale’s last lover and character actress Una O’Connor, who had remained Whale’s friend since The Invisible Man (1933) and Bride of Frankenstein (1935).
Mountain Xpress
archive.org ↗
Whale (1889-1957) directed some 21 films, but is best remembered for seven made between 1931 and 1939: "Frankenstein," "The Old Dark House," "The Invisible Man," " Bride of Frankenstein ," "Show Boat," "The Great Garrick" and " The Man in the Iron Mask."
RogerEbert.com
rogerebert.com ↗
Adapted from the book "Father of Frankenstein" by Christopher Bram, the new movie Gods and Monsters tells the story of film director James Whale, who completed 21 movies in Hollywood but will forever be remembered for only four: Frankenstein (1931), The Old Dark House (1932), The Invisible Man (1933), and The Bride of Frankenstein (1935).
Combustible Celluloid
combustiblecelluloid.com ↗
He lifts scenes from these and Whale's other movies (which also include "The Invisible Man" and the 1936 version of "Show Boat") for dream sequences and he draws a parallel between Frankenstein's monster and a hunky, uncultured yard man named Clay (Brendan Fraser), with whom Whale forms an uneasy, esoteric bond.
SplicedWire
splicedwire.com ↗
"Gods and Monsters" is very loosely based on the last days of 1930s film director James Whale (played, in the best performance of his screen career, by Ian McKellen), an un-closeted homosexual who was responsible for directing such memorably off-kilter films as "Frankenstein," "The Bride of Frankenstein," "Show Boat," and "The Invisible Man."
Footloose poster
The worst offender being John Lithgow whose portrayal of Kinsey's fundamentalist preacher father sticks out as a caricature (perhaps the casting was a nod to his righteous reverend in "Footloose") until a quiet moment towards the end of the film which nearly redeems his whole performance.
Big Picture Big Sound
bigpicturebigsound.com ↗
Kinsey’s father (played by John Lithgow, reliving his “Footloose” sanctimony), a small-town moral tyrant, preaches that “the modern inventions of science have been used to cultivate immorality” — the same argument that very sensible people today make about Internet pornography and such, except that HE’S talking about inventions like electricity and the telephone.
Eric D. Snider • Eric D. Snider • Dec 17, 2004
archive.org ↗
Condon depicts Kinsey as the spitting mirror image of his hellfire-preaching Sunday schoolmaster daddy (John Lithgow, far more moving than he was in his superficially similar bluenose-pop role in Footloose).
Jungle Book poster
This might be a clever nod to the true love story believed to have inspired the fairy tale (Google: Pretus Gonslavus), but the character never looks photo-real in the way of “Jungle Book”s incredible detailed furry heroes.
Kristy Puchko • CBR • Mar 3, 2017
cbr.com ↗
Jon Favreau made a live action "Jungle Book" with one human actor entirely surrounded by CGI and most wouldn't known they were not looking at real wilderness.
Reeling Reviews • Jan 10, 2020
reelingreviews.com ↗
It can work, as witness the charming “Cinderella” (2015) and the dazzling “Jungle Book” (2016).
Ty Burr • The Boston Globe • Mar 15, 2017
bostonglobe.com ↗
But most of these do-overs, from the lightly revisionist Maleficent to last year’s state-of-the-art Jungle Book , at least attempt to do something different with their source material.
But 2016’s Jungle Book was a triumph, even though, ironically, it was still mostly animated, this time with CGI instead of pen-and-ink.
Fantasia poster
But then, who cares, when we're caught up in the spectacular, toe-tapping 'Be Our Guest' extravaganza, nodding to everything from Fantasia to Cabaret to Busby Berkeley?
Rosie Fletcher • Digital Spy • Mar 17, 2017
digitalspy.com ↗
And that’s a problem, because the cartoon is already basically perfect: the best and most justly beloved film of the 1990s Disney renaissance, and the only cartoon Disney ever made after the mid-1940s that I would rank alongside their early masterpieces, Snow White , Pinocchio , Fantasia and Bambi .
Steven D. Greydanus • National Catholic Register • Mar 13, 2017
ncregister.com ↗
The attention to detail in this film is exquisite, from the gold flakes on Belle’s ballroom gown to the “ Fantasia ”-like theatrics of the “Be Our Guest” feast.
Star-Telegram • Mar 14, 2017
star-telegram.com ↗
Animated dance numbers by enchanted objects feels like Fantasia being performed at the Tonys, sponsored by a confetti company.
Roe McDermott • Hot Press • Apr 5, 2017
hotpress.com ↗
“Be Our Guest” in particular is a choreographic extravaganza that enfolds decades of Disney history (all the way back to “Snow White” and “Fantasia”) in contemporary cinematic craft.
Sherlock: Case of Evil poster
In the last decade alone, three contemporary takes on Holmes have inspired popular TV shows ("Sherlock," "Elementary," and "House").
Indeed, more than a few of Sherlock Holmes’s identifying features – an “elementary” quote, that deerstalker hat – actually originated in stage and film adaptations.
Donald Clarke • The Irish Times • Jun 19, 2015
irishtimes.com ↗
Frankenstein poster
Writer-director Bill Condon won the Oscar for Best Adapted Screenplay with his previous film, Gods and Monsters, a biopic of Frankenstein director James Whale.
ViewLondon
co.uk ↗
The writer-director of Gods and Monsters, a fantastical account of the latter days of Frankenstein director James Whale, plays it fairly straight in biographing famed sex researcher Alfred Kinsey.
Las Vegas CityLife • Nov 24, 2004
archive.org ↗
Kinsey makes no apologies for its subject's often infuriating behavior -- in that manner, it has much in common with writer-director Bill Condon's previous feature Gods and Monsters, which presented Frankenstein director James Whale as tragically flawed yet allowed us a look at those personal demons that all too often defined his very being.
Six years ago writer/director Bill Condon fashioned a highly speculative account of the waning days of iconographic filmmaker James Whale, the man who made "Frankenstein."
It's subject was the late James Whale, who directed the original Frankenstein and it's first sequel in the 1930s, and went on to win an Academy Award for his work on Show Boat.
Maleficent poster
Now that all the old films are out there in the public domain, live-action remakes are the best way to keep the story brands alive, starting with Maleficent in 2014, Cinderella in 2015 and now this.
Leslie Felperin • The Hollywood Reporter • Mar 3, 2017
hollywoodreporter.com ↗
Beauty and the Beast is the fifth film in Disney’s ever-growing slate of live-action revisits, which started with Maleficent , but didn’t really kick off until Cinderella .
Britt Hayes • ScreenCrush • Mar 3, 2017
screencrush.com ↗
Beauty’s hugely successful Disney live action predecessor, Maleficent, reimagined Sleeping Beauty from the point of view of the iconic 1959 villain (Angelina Jolie).
1994’s “Rudyard Kipling’s The Jungle Book” and 1996’s “101 Dalmatians” would end up early test runs for the full-on blitz that began in 2014 with “ Maleficent .”
Cinemix Tape • Mar 27, 2017
cinemixtape.com ↗
It’s just the latest in a series of experiments in back-catalog mining that have become a regular presence on the release schedule, following The Jungle Book , Pete’s Dragon , Cinderella , and Maleficent .
Jesse Hassenger • BKLYNER • Mar 14, 2017
bkmag.com ↗
While the 2015 “Cinderella” was a delightful surprise, efforts such as “Snow White and the Huntsman” and “Maleficent” fell flat.
Allyson Johnson, Tom Meek, Oscar Goff, Zoe Beketova, Iris Zhan • Cambridge Day • Mar 14, 2017
cambridgeday.com ↗
Inglourious Basterds poster
After Roy and Betty catch a showing of Inglourious Basterds (which places the film in 2009 and, yes, that matters), she objects to its fictionalization of World War II.
Seven Days Staff • Seven Days • Jul 23, 2025
sevendaysvt.com ↗
They click quite nicely and there are further dates, including a screening of Inglourious Basterds , which Roy finds unsettling due to its rewriting of history.
The Adelaide Review • Dec 6, 2019
com.au ↗
They watch Quentin Tarantino’s Inglourious Basterds , and the two have a cordial debate about whether the film’s ahistorical representation poisons the minds of the young.
Slant Magazine
slantmagazine.com ↗
The Good Liar relies on lengthy flashbacks to fill in the details of its characters, spread across decades encompassing post-war Berlin (look closely at the title sequence) up to 2009 (perhaps only used to squeeze in a thematic reference to Inglourious Basterds ?).
The following scene has them taking in a screening of Quentin Tarantino’s revisionist history lesson Inglourious Basterds of all things, one of many semi-subtle clues foreshadowing a progressive tightening of the suspense that underlies the entire film.
Marc Savlov • The Austin Chronicle • Nov 15, 2019
austinchronicle.com ↗
On their first night out together after meeting on a dating site for widowed septuagenarians (OK Boomer?), Roy Courtnay (Ian McKellen) and Betty McLeish (Helen Mirren) take in a screening of “Inglourious Basterds” at a London cinema.
David Ehrlich • IndieWire • Nov 7, 2019
indiewire.com ↗
Show Boat poster
It's subject was the late James Whale, who directed the original Frankenstein and it's first sequel in the 1930s, and went on to win an Academy Award for his work on Show Boat.
The Little Mermaid poster
Arguably, it’s an appropriate tribute to the late lyricist Howard Ashman (who also wrote songs for The Little Mermaid and Aladdin , and who died of AIDS four days after the animated Beauty and the Beast ’s first screening).
Beauty and the Beast 2017 is a direct remake of the 1991 interpretation, which was notable for a number of reasons: it was the first animated film to be nominated for a Best Picture Oscar, it was the last full collaboration between lyricist Howard Ashman and composer Alan Menken, and it accelerated the renaissance of Disney animation begun in 1989 with The Little Mermaid .
James Berardinelli • ReelViews • Mar 17, 2017
reelviews.net ↗
This small token offers an opportunity to remember and honor a genius behind the cinematic scene, the openly gay Ashman, whose lyrics for The Little Mermaid, Aladdin and Beauty and the Beast helped bring these tales as old as time to unforgettable life.
Nancy Churnin • GuideLive • Mar 15, 2017
guidelive.com ↗
Thanks to his work on The Little Mermaid and Beauty , Ashman—who died of AIDS-related complications in 1991—had as much to do with the revival of Disney’s animation legend as anybody.
Robert Horton • Seattle Weekly • Mar 15, 2017
seattleweekly.com ↗
Even more so than its immediate predecessor The Little Mermaid (1989), Beauty and the Beast’s integration of big Broadway-style tunes into the narrative helped reshape our understanding and expectations of an animated musical, which is perhaps why is remains so beloved to this day despite some clear narrative shortcomings (just so you know, I’m in something of a minority in not ranking the animated original among my favorite Disney films, although I can see why people love it).
Q Network
qnetwork.com ↗
The new, murky, 3-D, live-action romantic musical “Beauty and the Beast” is as advertised — an almost beat-by-beat remake of the 1991 Disney animated film that young people cherished as children with the same beloved-by-some musical score by lyricist Howard Ashman and composer Alan Menken, who also provided the music for the Jeffrey Katzenberg era’s “The Little Mermaid” and “Aladdin.”
Migration User • The Boston Herald • Mar 17, 2017
bostonherald.com ↗
Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs poster
After discovering that audiences will reach deep into their pockets for any remake of an animated favourite, Disney has put into production adaptations of Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs, Peter Pan, Sleeping Beauty, Cinderella, Alice in Wonderland, The Jungle Book, The Lion King, Mulan, The Little Mermaid and Aladdin.
Matilda Dixon-Smith • Junkee • Mar 24, 2017
junkee.com ↗
I hope that I’m wrong, and that children rear back from this ogre as their grandparents did from the witch in “Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs.”
Anthony Lane • The New Yorker • Mar 17, 2017
newyorker.com ↗
The form was invented by Disney eighty years ago, with “Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs” (1937), a film I still think has never been surpassed, and when you watch something as transporting as “Snow White” — or “Bambi,” or “Toy Story,” or “Beauty and the Beast” — every gesture and background and choreographed flourish, from the facial expressions to the drip-drop of water, flows together with a poetic unity.
Owen Gleiberman • Variety • Mar 3, 2017
variety.com ↗
Cinderella poster
Now that all the old films are out there in the public domain, live-action remakes are the best way to keep the story brands alive, starting with Maleficent in 2014, Cinderella in 2015 and now this.
Leslie Felperin • The Hollywood Reporter • Mar 3, 2017
hollywoodreporter.com ↗
And, while Kenneth Branagh’s reinterpretation of Cinderella offered a glimpse at what these movies can be, most fall short of their hand-drawn inspirations.
James Berardinelli • ReelViews • Mar 17, 2017
reelviews.net ↗
Aladdin poster
Yet, this "Beauty and the Beast" lacks the magical zip-a-dee-doo-dah of the 1991 original, a jewel (along with "The Little Mermaid" and "Aladdin") in the crown from Disney's renaissance period.
Dann Gire • Daily Herald • Mar 15, 2017
dailyherald.com ↗
It was the last completed film score by the team before Ashman’s AIDS-related death in March of 1991, although some of his songs were used in the following year’s Aladdin.
Stephen Silver, www.splicetoday.com • Splice Today • Apr 7, 2017
splicetoday.com ↗
The new, murky, 3-D, live-action romantic musical “Beauty and the Beast” is as advertised — an almost beat-by-beat remake of the 1991 Disney animated film that young people cherished as children with the same beloved-by-some musical score by lyricist Howard Ashman and composer Alan Menken, who also provided the music for the Jeffrey Katzenberg era’s “The Little Mermaid” and “Aladdin.”
Migration User • The Boston Herald • Mar 17, 2017
bostonherald.com ↗
Abraham Lincoln: Vampire Hunter poster
Ironically, he did play a 19-year-old Neeson in "Kinsey," but he and Neeson have a lot in common.
Benjamin Walker never overcomes his stiffness and his odd similarity to Liam Neeson (he actually played the young Kinsey to Neeson's adult one in the biopic "Kinsey").
Beth Accomando, www.kpbs.org, beth-accomando • KPBS • Jun 21, 2012
kpbs.org ↗
On the side of right and might, stage actor and sometime Liam Neeson look-alike Walker (he played the 19-year-old version of Neeson in Kinsey) does a solid job as Mr. Lincoln.
He looks like a young Liam Neeson (and in fact played the younger version of Neeson’s titular character in Kinsey), and shares that actor’s generous onscreen spirit as well.
MaryAnn Johanson • Flick Filosopher • Jun 19, 2012
flickfilosopher.com ↗
Benjamin Walker, who looks more like Liam Neeson than Lincoln (and played a younger version of Neeson's title character in "Kinsey"), stars as the Great Emancipator, who also was apparently great at driving an axe into the skull of the undead.
As Abe, Walker looks like a young Liam Neeson (and in fact played a younger version of Neeson’s character in Kinsey), but lacks intensity.
MovieHabit
moviehabit.com ↗
A Beautiful Mind poster
I was reminded of Russell Crowe's work in " A Beautiful Mind " (2001), also the story of a man whose brilliance was contained within narrow channels.
RogerEbert.com
rogerebert.com ↗
Like other recent biopics of influential but troubled men such as Ray and A Beautiful Mind, Kinsey is willing to allow its subject to be a flawed human being — up to a point.
Decent Films Guide
archive.org ↗
(Kinsey is remarkable for making scientific concepts clear and comprehensible without resorting to the gimmickry of A Beautiful Mind.)
PETER KEOUGH • The Boston Phoenix
bostonphoenix.com ↗
Laura Linney has a thankless role, that of the supportive woman who stands by her obsessed, brilliant man (see also Jennifer Connelly in “A Beautiful Mind,” Marcia Gay Harden in “Pollock” ), but she does it stoically and with grace.
Eric D. Snider • Eric D. Snider • Dec 17, 2004
archive.org ↗
Sherlock Holmes poster
Where Guy Ritchie’s two “Sherlock Holmes” movies played up brawny, boneheaded action that felt dishonest to the source material, “Mr.
Patrick Dunn, The Detroit News • The Detroit News • Jul 16, 2015
detroitnews.com ↗
In very un-Holmesian ways, the detective now writes a person’s name on his sleeve so he can discreetly glance down to retrieve it when his mind fails, or he attends the local movie theater to watch a “Sherlock Holmes” mystery based on Watson’s version of events in the case, hoping it will jog his own recollections.
Christine N. Ziemba • Paste Magazine • Jul 17, 2015
pastemagazine.com ↗
Psycho poster
That’s inevitable if you’re doing a shot-by-shot remake of a stone cold classic (as Gus Van Sant’s much-reviled but somewhat interesting Psycho experiment proved in 1998).
The Film Experience • Mar 19, 2017
thefilmexperience.net ↗
Beauty and the Beast isn’t Exhibit A of how a remake goes wrong by treating its classic source material as a sacred text (that’s probably Gus Van Sant’s remake of Psycho ), but it’s in the top 10.
Steven D. Greydanus • National Catholic Register • Mar 13, 2017
ncregister.com ↗