“What’s your favorite scary movie set on Valentine’s Day?” the ghostfaced killer of Scream might croak into a voice modulator if he was feeling a little romantic as well as homicidal.
Any audience member who has seen a “Scream” film knows to look out for unusual characters that could potentially be involved, but “Heart Eyes” doesn’t seem particularly interested in masking its twist.
Liam Gaughan, www.facebook.com•High on Films•Feb 7, 2025
…you can likely count the number of Valentine’s Day-specific slasher movies on your hand (this includes 1981’s My Bloody Valentine and 2001’s Valentine)…
We’ve seen the Valentine’s Day killer before in My Bloody Valentine (MBV) and with the exception of glowing red hearts for eyes, Heart Eyes emulates the same sinister archetype as MBV’s Harry Warden.
It isn’t until recently that the genre began to rely more on horror elements, as seen in Ready or Not (2019). Heart Eyes does the same, cementing itself in the rom-com sphere but emphasizing the thrills, with the comedy being hit or miss.
Ready or Not is now looking at one of the more influential, if not easily imitatable films of the last decade or so; a super-violent, super-hip comedy-thriller that took the gory shocks from 80’s slasher movies and repositioned them around a clever narrative that was far more than just a group of bland teenagers being massacred.
Similarly, Heart Eyes’ structure and pacing resemble the horror/comedy bounce found in the Scream franchise and Ready or Not, with self-aware jokes, eye-popping jump scares, paired with grounded, mostly sensible sequences where the victims are not total dinguses.
It's a bit like Scream meets 10 Things I Hate About You, as the dueling protagonists slowly fall in love when they are tossed headfirst into a high-stakes horror movie neither one of them asked to be in.
…you can likely count the number of Valentine’s Day-specific slasher movies on your hand (this includes 1981’s My Bloody Valentine and 2001’s Valentine)…
As one of four films released in February in honor of Valentine’s Day—“Companion” (2025), “Heart Eyes” (2025) and “Love Me” (2025)—and aim to celebrate the holiday with unexpected genre mashups that lead to heightened tension, “Love Hurts” just does not feel compelling since the stakes are virtually nonexistent.
It’s refreshing to see a sleek, canny, well-shot genre mashup now in theatres that’s predicated on Valentine’s Day violence, the surprising utility of a straw as a weapon and the climactic use of the dialogue “Love hurts.”
Too bad those complimentary descriptions above apply only to Heart Eyes and not to Love Hurts.
If you’re taking your sweetheart out on the 14th and you’ve seen this movie (or “Heart Eyes”) together, you might want to consider an upscale place where the drinks don’t invite their use, lest your date get the wrong idea.
(It certainly doesn’t help either of them that in a sequence at a drive-in, we’re shown clips of Rosalind Russell in “His Girl Friday,” and the comparison is devastating.)
A massacre sequence set at a drive-in cinema screening Howard Hawks’ screwball romance His Girl Friday (1940) nails the film’s status as a reflexive hall of mirrors…
There is also a lovely reference to a classic remarriage comedy, “His Girl Friday” (1940), which will hopefully inspire young moviegoers to check out an old movie.
Hot on the heels of Eli Roth’s blood-soaked “Thanksgiving,” another holiday-themed slasher makes its way onto the scene with the aptly timed “Heart Eyes”…
Sleepless in Seattle would be a fitting title for this film as well, as it finds the city’s citizens on high alert for the Heart Eyes Killer, who creeps up every Valentine’s Day to terrorize couples in a new spot on the United States map.
But what this quaint little “Hot Fuzz” homage lacks in scale, it nearly makes up for with a stacked cast of delightful comic actors who all deliver the goods.
The films of Edgar Wright ("Hot Fuzz" in particular) are clearly an influence here, and Ruben uses some of Wright's sharpest tools for instant, economical world-building: playful soundtrack choices (like the soda pop ditties that introduce us to Beaverton, juxtaposed with Anna Drubich's straight-up horror strings); whooshes in the sound design that ramp up one scene to a sudden cut; characters that suddenly pop into the camera's frame for comedic effect.
It’s safe to say Art the Clown with the Terrifier franchise has influenced the horror genre, pushing more filmmakers to lean on practical gore and effects.
…only a handful of films, in my opinion, have been successful, such as Arsenic and Old Lace (1944), House (1977), Scream (1996), American Psycho (2000), One Cut of the Dead (2017), and Beau is Afraid (2023).
Marios Papadoniou, Daniel Broadley, Alexander Boucher, Dan Perrin•Frame Rated•Feb 17, 2025