For all their faults, at least films like At World's End and Cutthroat Island are recognizable for their own thing.
Geena Davis’ Morgan Adams in Cutthroat Island (1995)…
A Cutthroat Island, if there is such a thing, for a new generation: the Hudson Hawk of swashbuckling action-adventure that almost survives on the gorgeous, talented leads.
…you start to wonder if this is the pirate movie that should have been called Cutthroat Island instead of the actual film with that designated title.
Filmmakers don’t want to make another Cutthroat Island, they want to make another Pirates of the Caribbean.