Cutthroat Island poster

Cutthroat Island (1995)

Directed by Renny Harlin

Morgan Adams and her slave, William Shaw, are on a quest to recover the three portions of a treasure map. Unfortunately, the final portion is held by her murderous uncle, Dawg. Her crew is skeptical of her leadership abilities, so she must complete her quest before they mutiny against her. This is made yet more difficult by the efforts of the British crown to end her pirate raids.

6 connections found
View:

6 connections, in both directions

What critics compared Cutthroat Island to

The Bluff poster
For all their faults, at least films like At World's End and Cutthroat Island are recognizable for their own thing.
Joonatan Itkonen • RegionFree • Feb 23, 2026
regionfree.net ↗
Geena Davis’ Morgan Adams in Cutthroat Island (1995)…
Casey Chong, www.facebook.com • Fortress of Solitude • Feb 25, 2026
co.za ↗
A Cutthroat Island, if there is such a thing, for a new generation: the Hudson Hawk of swashbuckling action-adventure that almost survives on the gorgeous, talented leads.
M.N. Miller, www.facebook.com • FandomWire • Feb 24, 2026
fandomwire.com ↗
…you start to wonder if this is the pirate movie that should have been called Cutthroat Island instead of the actual film with that designated title.
Jack Martin • FilmFeeder • Feb 25, 2026
co.uk ↗
Filmmakers don’t want to make another Cutthroat Island, they want to make another Pirates of the Caribbean.
James D. Williams • InSession Film • Mar 3, 2026
insessionfilm.com ↗
Gore Verbinski who did an excellent directing job in the recent thriller “ The Ring ” conveys the true spirit of swashbuckling films in “Pirates of the Caribbean”, a film that is very reminiscent of the old Errol Flynn Pirate epics that stunned audiences in the early 1900’s in its truest essence; the swashbuckling film genre is dead only recently being brought to the screen with the bland “Cutthroat Island” a film that had style but little substance.
Felix Vasquez • Cinema Crazed • Mar 14, 2004
cinema-crazed.com ↗
And Geena Davis... well, the jury is still out as to what the hell Geena Davis was thinking when she delivered us to the evil that was "Cutthroat Island"!
Ben Nieporent • eFilmCritic
efilmcritic.com ↗
"Cutthroat Island" was one of the most expensive duds in film history and all but ruined the once-promising careers of Geena Davis and Renny Harlin.
Critic.Doctor
archive.org ↗
The pirate genre has been in a perennial funk since Errol Flynn died -- burdened by latter-day efforts like Hook and Cutthroat Island which crushed their entertainment value beneath bloat and bombast.
Flipside Archive
flipsidearchive.com ↗
Deep Blue Sea poster
Director Renny Harlin (of Cutthroat Island infamy) does nothing to make his film stylish or different.
The latest picture from Renny Harlin -- the epic action director responsible for "Cliffhanger," "The Long Kiss Goodnight" and the abysmal "Cutthroat Island" -- this release will surely draw immediate comparisons to the "Jaws" films, but clearly lifts as much source material from any of those sinking boat or aliens in tight quarters pictures.
Director Renny Harlin ( "Cutthroat Island," "The Long Kiss Goodnight" ) could have at least done us the courtesy of saving the shopworn cliches until after the opening credits.
Spliced Wire
splicedwire.com ↗
The movie is a skillful thriller directed by Renny Harlin , who made "Die Hard 2'' and "Cutthroat Island,'' and here assembles a neat package of terror, sharks and special effects.
Directed by Renny Harlin, who directed a couple of entertaining films, "Cutthroat Island" and "The Long Kiss Goodnight," which weren't commercially successful following his popular "Cliffhanger," has once again made a thriller with some teeth in it.
In an attempt to compel and arouse the viewer, Harlin does not skimp in any way on energy, nor could he ever be accused of making a "boring" film (unless, of course, it's name happens to be "Cutthroat Island").
The Movie Boy
themovieboy.com ↗
The Lost City poster
The direction of The Lost City is aiming for classic romance-comedy-adventure similar to Romancing the Stone , Six Days Seven Nights , or Cutthroat Island , but leaning heavier into the comedy than the adventure.
Leo Brady • Mar 23, 2022
amovieguy.com ↗
Advertisement
Spy Game poster
Scripted by Michael Frost Beckner (the woebegone "Cutthroat Island") and David Arata ("Brokedown Palace"), "Spy Game" details a crisis in the lives of veteran spook Nathan Muir (Redford) and his young protégé Tom Bishop (Pitt).
Calendar Live
archive.org ↗
To begin with, it seems a little presumptuous to expect political insight of a movie with a story from Michael Frost Beckner, the scenarist of Cutthroat Island , as filtered through the directorial sensibilities of Tony Scott, who handled the aggressively apolitical Crimson Tide and the generically Reagan-era Top Gun .
Blogspot
archive.org ↗
His credits include "Prince Valiant" (1997), "Cutthroat Island" (1995), "Sniper" (1993) and TV's "The Agency".
Mindhunters poster
In any case, it's no wonder this movie did poorly at the box office, despite its high-profile cast--Val Kilmer, Christian Slater, LL Cool J--and its veteran action director, Renny Harlin ("Nightmare on Elm Street 4," "Die Hard 2," "Cliffhanger," "Cutthroat Island," "Deep Blue Sea," "Driven," "Exorcist: The Beginning").
Renny Harlin can do overt silliness (Cliffhanger, Cutthroat Island), or he can do grandiose, perhaps unwarranted self-righteousness ( Exorcist: The Beginning ).

That's all the connections!