That the Coens already referenced Busby Berkeley in The Big Lebowski risks younger fans thinking they're merely paying homage to themselves — which, on some level, maybe they are.
The Coens have played with some of these threads before — the unlikely kidnap plot recalls Raising Arizona and The Big Lebowski ; the cynical view of the Hollywood machine echoes Barton Fink ; the religious imagery on the set of Hail, Caesar! and Mannix’s repeated trips to his church confessional bring back the philosophical questions about God from A Serious Man — but they’re woven together here in a fresh new way.
We meet Johansson’s starlet playing a mermaid surrounded by synchronised swimmers and a spuming whale in a Busby Berkeley-esque musical number that is the match of The Dude’s surreal dream sequence in The Big Lebowski ; Channing Tatum heads up a squad of tap-dancing sailors whose suggestive lyrics will surely test the limits of the Hays Code; Tilda Swinton plays twin-sister gossip columnists whose intense rivalry owes much to that of Hedda Hopper and Louella Parsons; and an actor being crucified on a cross is asked if he’s a principal player or an extra to establish if he merits a hot breakfast.
Siblings Joel and Ethan Coen -- the brotherly duo behind classic films such as "Fargo," "No Country For Old Men," "The Big Lebowski" and "O Brother, Where Art Thou?" among many others -- are seemingly try to tap into something similar, minus the toons, in their period comedy, "Hail, Caesar!" Alas, while it has some fun moments and features a star-studded cast, it's a disjointed and disappointing mess that might have seemed liked a slam dunk on paper, but misses the mark in filmed form.
Joel and Ethan Coen make a welcome and long-awaited return to comedy with “Hail, Caesar!,” a slap-happy valentine to the Technicolor heyday of Hollywood that lands somewhere between the trippy brilliance of “The Big Lebowski” and the goofball parable of “O Brother, Where Art Thou?”.