He based the look of The Yards (2000) on the work of French realist painters, drew on the narrative structure of Dostoevsky's White Nights for Two Lovers (2009), and took inspiration from Puccini's operas for The Immigrant (2013).
The writer-director James Gray specialises in brooding tales of fraught families ( The Yards , We Own the Night ), though until now they’ve been earthbound and haven’t usually revolved around a taciturn figure with only his internal monologue for company.
This crazily ambitious film, sometimes successful but never less than mesmerically odd, seems an unlikely departure for the usually pragmatic, earthbound American director of The Yards, Two Lovers, and The Immigrant—although one might would have said the same for Gray’s daringly old-fashioned jungle exploration yarn The Lost City of Z.
In the past, Gray has granted solid roles to actresses such as Faye Dunaway, in “The Yards” (2000), and Gwyneth Paltrow, in “Two Lovers” (2008), but the women of “Ad Astra” are given astronomically short shrift.
His best film is last year’s excellent, “The Lost City of Z.” The rest, ranging from “The Yards” (pretentious) to “Two Lovers” (insulting), always seem like they should mean more than they do.
While Gray has found tremendous success with the live-wire intensity of frequent collaborator Joaquin Phoenix (The Yards, We Own the Night, The Immigrant), the director’s partnership with Pitt might be his greatest.