This is a thriller, so Hitchcock is the obvious reference point (as he was in "Cape Fear").
Instead, he seems to be out to explore the conventions of the horror genre, as in Cape Fear, and to pay homage to his heroes while coming up with a few new tricks.
In tackling Shutter Island , only his second thriller since the 1991 remake of Cape Fear, Martin Scorsese, who is a master artist in the eyes of even the most jaded cynic, takes a type of story familiar to all of us and dresses its decidedly ghoulish Hitchcockian bones in something gossamer and graceful.
Martin Scorseses "Shutter Island" is the most bizarrely portentous and overemphatic Hollywood thriller Ive seen since, well, Martin Scorseses "Cape Fear."
Back in 1991, when Martin Scorsese made Cape Fear, he figured out how to direct an unabashed commercial thriller that still had the flavor of his obsessions.
“Shutter Island,” Scorsese's first attempt at terror since 1991's “Cape Fear” and Hollywood's latest adaptation of a Dennis Lehane novel (“Mystic River,” “Gone Baby Gone”), was set for release in October but pushed back to strengthen Paramount’s 2010 schedule.