Passages in "Carandiru" play like a less melodramatic correction of the imprisoned macho-drag queen stuff he tried to pull off almost 20 years ago in "Kiss of the Spider Woman."
Returning to ground he covered previously in Pixote (1981) and Kiss of the Spider Woman (1985), Hector Babenco crafts a lopsided diptych: The first, more expansive part eventually unfolds as a series of picaresque episodes as told to the kindly on-site doctor (Luiz Carlos Vasconcelos); the second panel essays a grisly re-creation of the riot that ended in the early morning hours of October 3, 1992, when police killed 111 unarmed, penned-in prisoners.
Carandiru is based on the best-selling book Carandiru Station by Drauzio Varella (168 weeks on Brazil�s best-seller list) and realized by filmmaker Hector Babenco, who knows prison drama intimately (Kiss of the Spider Woman).�…
But in the hands of Hector Babenco, whose "Kiss of the Spider Woman" remains one of the best prison movies ever, the genre takes on a new -- and legitimate -- meaning.
Argentine director Hector Babenco's ninth film, Carandiru is his fourth that, at least in an ancillary fashion, has something to do with prison (the others being Lució Flávio, Pixote, and Kiss of the Spider Woman), and it's easily the least of them, justifying the men-behind-bars tropes and queen stereotypes by hiding behind its ostensible basis in Dráuzio Varella's non-fiction fiction.
Babenco had his greatest international success with Kiss of the Spider Woman (1985), another story about prison as both a reality and a state of mind, yet his personal investment in Carandiru runs deeper than that.