Carpenter's fourth feature as a director, "The Fog" was his first relative -- albeit honorable -- misfire; it's fairly unique as a 1980s horror movie, but it remains a lesser work in a directorial filmography that includes "Escape from New York," "The Thing," "They Live," "Big Trouble in Little China," even "Christine."
Of the first bunch of Carpenter films to be updatedincluding Assault On Precinct 13, Halloween, Escape From New York, and The Thing (itself a remake)the 1980 film The Fog has the most room for improvement.
A feature-length yakker with Carpenter and former filmmaking partner Debra Hill is lively and informative and again lifted from a 1995 LaserDisc (though not as lively and informative as Carpenter's commentaries with Kurt Russell for The Thing, Escape from New York (recorded for Laser, coming soon to DVD), and Big Trouble in Little China ), and a new, DVD-specific documentary ("Tales from the Mist: Inside The Fog") submits thirty minutes' worth of observations (only a few rehashed) about the literary sources of the film (Poe, Lovecraft, E.C. Comics) and the late-edit woes.
The majority of the film was not shot in New York City, but rather in a burnt-out section of downtown St. Louis, which allowed Carpenter and cinematographer Dean Cundey (who had previously shot Carpenter’s Halloween and The Fog) to fill the ’Scope frame with wide, seemingly endless expanses of deserted, trashed-out urban terrain (although not to the extent that the movie poster and subsequent video box promised, as the Statue of Liberty’s head remains firmly attached to her shoulders).
The Fog (1980) is about a crew of pirate zombies taking revenge on the descendants of a California town who robbed them; it became one of the most enduring films of its kind, inspiring many imitators.
Escape from New York is not as enthralling as the metaphor-rich, Reagan-era They Live and the parallel action isn't as pronounced or intoxicating as it was in The Fog , but its politics are no less immediate (the constantly shifting alliances, individualism versus collectivism, the distrust of authority and the overriding public relations fiasco that closes the film).