Their leader—played by Rhys Wakefield, channeling Michael Pitt in Funny Games —offers Hawke a deal: If the family hands over Hodge, the Purgers will leave them alone; if they don’t, they’ll have no choice but to break into the house and kill everyone inside.
What follows is a mix of Sam Peckinpah's classic "Straw Dogs" and Michael Haneke's two "Funny Games" films, as the mild-mannered Sandins must make difficult choices and tap into their inner animals.
The tension is well sustained and the film is an effective, predictable cross between Assault on Precinct 13 (the remake of which DeMonaco scripted) and Funny Games (the fair-haired preppy leader of the sinister besiegers is a dead ringer for one of the psychopathic kids in Michael Haneke's film).
And then, the plot finally decides to begin: the gang hunting the wounded man arrives at the Sandin house, and the very articulate young man leading them (Tony Oller, who I don't suppose was cast entirely because of his uncanny resemblance to Brady Corbet, of the American Funny Games , though it surely didn't hurt) informs the family that if they don't turn out the refuge, all the security systems in the world won't stop hell from raining down on them.
But by far the worst performances, however, come from Wakefield, who should have recognized that what he’s doing was already satirized by Michael Haneke in “Funny Games,” and by Arija Barekis as a suspiciously solicitous neighbor.
Like Michael Haneke with Funny Games, DeMonaco (Staten Island) seems adamant about making sure people experience and interpret his movie the correct way, taking in the full symbolic heft of his thoughts on economic disparity, and not getting too much visceral enjoyment out of the action.