The film definitely borrows liberally from haunted house lore, but the two most obvious sources are Fulci’s House By the Cemetery and The Beyond, and since those are two of my favorites, those aspects really worked for me.
Writer/director Brendan Muldowney’s “The Cellar” builds upon the corpses of other memorable basement films like “The Amityville Horror,” The “Silence of the Lambs,” and “The Evil Dead” but adds elements of a new mythology that combines mystical numeracy with your average “Devil in the basement” arcana.
There’s an identity crisis at the heart of The Cellar , caught between the grounded supernatural elements of A Dark Song (2016) and the propulsive, pulpy horror of Insidious (2010), without committing to either.
The plot treads the same water that superior films like House, The Conjuring and Insidious have treaded but without a clever screenplay or developing its characters in a way that brings them to life.
Brendan Muldowney's "The Cellar" is an adventurously melancholic representation of Irish horror much like Corin Hardy's "The Hallow" or Lee Cronin's "The Hole in the Ground."
Muldowney shows real flair for establishing a scary atmosphere without feeling the need to overplay his hand, the camera crawling along the floor and lingering on seemingly innocuous dark spaces until we start questioning what we’re looking at, Blair Witch style.
The plot treads the same water that superior films like House, The Conjuring and Insidious have treaded but without a clever screenplay or developing its characters in a way that brings them to life.