View:

Connections, in both directions

Harold and Maude poster
As “The Holdovers” morphs from miserablist odd-couple comedy to bittersweet road movie, it aims to remind you, sometimes with a hard nudge, of Hal Ashby classics like “Harold and Maude” and “The Last Detail”; an argument with a waitress automatically nods to Bob Rafelson’s “Five Easy Pieces.”
Justin Chang, Justin Chang Film Critic, www.latimes.com, justin-chang • Los Angeles Times • Oct 26, 2023
latimes.com ↗
Evoking the cinematographic proclivities of 1970s filmmakers (the influential likes of Hal Ashby’s Harold and Maude and Robert Altman’s McCabe & Mrs. Miller pervade the fuzzy, 35mm cinematography), Payne reverberates the eras’ ambiance via faraway zooms, sentimental Labi Siffre and Cat Stevens’ needle drops, rustic prep-school environs, and darkly-lit oaken hallways.
Paul Keelan • Film Obsessive • Dec 22, 2023
filmobsessive.com ↗
Dead Poets Society poster
Featuring spiky intergenerational negotiations and intelligent repartee all-round , The Holdovers is often reminiscent of the best parts of Peter Weir's 1989 heart-breaking coming of age drama Dead Poets Society.
Linda Marric • HeyUGuys • Jan 19, 2024
heyuguys.com ↗
If you were expecting Robin Williams’s Mr. Keating, from Dead Poets Society, a harlequin who inspires his students with poetry and benevolence, you walked into the wrong classroom.
The Village Voice
villagevoice.com ↗
Up in the Air poster
That "Election" reference leads to another observation, and that is the many parallels between "Up in the Air" and "Election's" writer/director Alexander Payne's "About Schmidt."
Reeling Reviews • Jan 10, 2020
reelingreviews.com ↗
A scenario reminiscent of Alexander Payne's About Schmidt, it's as glib and false as Bingham's spiel to stunned, newly canned ex-employees.
The Phoenix
thephoenix.com ↗
So he set his aim higher, wanting to make a film with the kind of complex, seriocomic humanity he admired in Billy Wilder, Hal Ashby, James L. Brooks, and the contemporary director he most reveres, Alexander Payne ( Sideways , About Schmidt , Election ).
Rolfe Kent (ah, the Alexander Payne connection!—for his scores on Sideways, About Schmidt, Election, and Citizen Ruth) does a masterfully complimentary score, with additional songs picked by music supervisor Randall Poster including Crosby, Stills & Nash and Charles Atlas.
Eli Savada, A.R. Handler, Phil Hall, Matthew Sorrento, www.facebook.com • Identity Theory • Dec 16, 2009
identitytheory.com ↗
So he set his aim higher, wanting to make a film with the kind of complex, seriocomic humanity he admired in Billy Wilder, Hal Ashby, James L. Brooks, and the contemporary director he most reveres, Alexander Payne ( Sideways , About Schmidt , Election ).
In particular, Anna Kendrick, who charmed in "Camp," enters a pantheon of smart young indie actresses with a breakout resembling Reese Witherspoon's in "Election."
Reeling Reviews • Jan 10, 2020
reelingreviews.com ↗
Five Easy Pieces poster
As “The Holdovers” morphs from miserablist odd-couple comedy to bittersweet road movie, it aims to remind you, sometimes with a hard nudge, of Hal Ashby classics like “Harold and Maude” and “The Last Detail”; an argument with a waitress automatically nods to Bob Rafelson's “Five Easy Pieces.”
Justin Chang, Justin Chang Film Critic, www.latimes.com, justin-chang • Los Angeles Times • Oct 26, 2023
latimes.com ↗
There are very few films in this day and age that both harkens back to the tradition of “Five Easy Pieces” exploring characters with no real future or anything to look forward to, and searching for one, while exploring the incredulously distressing and often futile machinations in the artistic experience of an author.
Felix Vasquez • Cinema Crazed • Nov 29, 2005
cinema-crazed.com ↗
The Last Detail poster
As “The Holdovers” morphs from miserablist odd-couple comedy to bittersweet road movie, it aims to remind you, sometimes with a hard nudge, of Hal Ashby classics like “Harold and Maude” and “The Last Detail”; an argument with a waitress automatically nods to Bob Rafelson's “Five Easy Pieces.”
Justin Chang, Justin Chang Film Critic, www.latimes.com, justin-chang • Los Angeles Times • Oct 26, 2023
latimes.com ↗
The Hunt poster
After review, The Hunt harks to the Alexander Payne film, Citizen Ruth.
Craig Lindsey • CultureMap • Mar 13, 2020
culturemap.com ↗
It can’t touch the Clinton-era satires The Last Supper (1995) or Citizen Ruth (1996), which succeeded for reasons other than being on “the correct side.”
The Graduate poster
And there's such spark mixed with pain in Sessa's young Dustin Hoffman-esque turn (a comparison reinforced when Paul and Angus hit the cinema to see western Little Big Man, which stars Hoffman, and by The Holdovers overall harking back to The Graduate times).
Concrete Playground • Jan 14, 2024
concreteplayground.com ↗
Love Story poster
In fact, Payne and cinematographer Eigil Bryld might cringe at this, but the snowy Barton campus even evokes a little bit of 1970’s “Love Story” (in the best way possible).
Gregory Ellwood • The Playlist • Sep 2, 2023
theplaylist.net ↗
Little Big Man poster
And there's such spark mixed with pain in Sessa's young Dustin Hoffman-esque turn (a comparison reinforced when Paul and Angus hit the cinema to see western Little Big Man, which stars Hoffman, and by The Holdovers overall harking back to The Graduate times).
Concrete Playground • Jan 14, 2024
concreteplayground.com ↗
Booksmart poster
I am reminded of Election (1999), a high-school comedy that mocked the values that Booksmart , for all its girl-centric appeal, does nothing to challenge.
The Monthly
com.au ↗
Inside Booksmart ’s Type-A protagonist Molly (Beanie Feldstein) beats the savage heart of Election ’s Tracy Flick (Reese Witherspoon), while her dreamy, sensitive best friend Amy (Kaitlyn Dever) isn’t so far from Aldys (Leelee Sobieski), the tender weirdo from Never Been Kissed .
artshub-au • ScreenHub • Jul 11, 2019
com.au ↗
Rocket Science poster
The script feels reminiscent of any number of millennial adolescent dramedies; think of films like Jeffrey Blitz’s Rocket Science – to pull one randomly from the corners of memory – that matter most to those who saw them at just the right age.
Matthew Monagle • The Austin Chronicle • Nov 3, 2023
austinchronicle.com ↗
Me and Earl and the Dying Girl poster
There are hints of undisputable inspiration in Gomez-Rejon's approach—Wes Anderson's " Rushmore " and Alexander Payne's " Election " come immediately to mind while watching—but the filmmaker uses them merely as a jumping-off point for his own uniquely perceptive viewpoint.Greg Gaines (Thomas Mann) is a die-hard cinephile and aspiring director whose 42 home-made films (most of them affectionate movie spoofs) adorn his family's living-room shelves.
Dustin Putman • The Film File
thefilmfile.com ↗
American Splendor poster
Recently divorced alcoholic schoolteacher and aspiring novelist Miles Raymond (Paul Giamatti, "American Splendor") uses his best buddy Jack's (Thomas Haden Church, TV's "Wings" and "Ned and Stacy") impending marriage for a week long male bonding trip to central California wine country.
Reeling Reviews • Jul 6, 2021
reelingreviews.com ↗
Paul Giamatti, the pudgy, balding, slightly despondent character actor of Man on the Moon and American Splendor, gives a performance of such pent-up desperation and heartbreaking moroseness in Sideways that he single-handedly cements Alexander Payne's film as one of the year's finest.
He's also coaxed great performances out of four lesser-known actors and transformed one of them, Paul Giamatti from "American Splendor," into film's most unlikely leading man.
Des Moines Register
archive.org ↗
Giamatti, a virtuoso of nervous self-loathing (witness his performance as Harvey Pekar in "American Splendor"), interacts with Church impeccably, and their friendship seems at once believable and too funny to be believed.
Eric D. Snider • Eric D. Snider • Oct 22, 2004
ericdsnider.com ↗
Whatever the case, after already lengthy careers, Paul Giamatti ( American Splendor ), Thomas Haden Church ( Tombstone ) and Virgina Madsen ( Crossfire Trail ) all give the best performances of their lives in Sideways, the new film from writer-director Alexander Payne and co-writer Jim Taylor, the team responsible for Election and About Schmidt .
George Wu • CultureVulture
archive.org ↗
Pineapple Express poster
No messy massacres like the one in Gus Van Sant's Elephant or political backstabbing à la Alexander Payne's Election.
Altman poster
It looks right. The strummed soundtrack reminds us of The Graduate. The performances are certainly on a par. But The Holdovers is more at home to redemptive sentimentality than Ashby or Altman would have allowed.
Donald Clarke • The Irish Times • Jan 18, 2024
irishtimes.com ↗
Little Children poster
The story of an illicit love affair that coincides with a presumed pedophile's move to town, "Little Children" is based on a book by Tom Perrotta, who wrote the novel "Election" (Alexander Payne's film was later based on it).
Pedigree: It's from Tom Perrotta, the writer of Election, and writer-director Todd Field (In the Bedroom).
Cowriter (with novelist Tom Perrotta, "Election")/director Todd Fields ("In the Bedroom") shifts from the murky blackness of the human heart exposed by grief that he explored "In the Bedroom" to the unfocused self-centeredness of unformed yuppies with every bit as keen an instinct for what makes people tick.
Reeling Reviews • Jan 10, 2020
reelingreviews.com ↗
"Little Children" is far from a bad movie, but it's not as deep and subtly disturbing as Fields' " In the Bedroom " or as infernally funny as Alexander Payne and Jim Taylor's film adaptation of Perrotta's novel Election.
RogerEbert.com
rogerebert.com ↗
A good measuring stick would be Alexander Payne's Election (1999), which was also adapted from a novel by Tom Perotta and was a good deal tighter and more fearless; that movie sustained its biting humor, while Little Children can't quite decide on a tone.
Combustible Celluloid
combustiblecelluloid.com ↗
Todd Field's second feature film, like his debut "In the Bedroom," is another adaptation, but this time, he collaborated with the novel's author Tom Perrotta ("Election"), which helps instill more overt humor into what is essentially a dark and quirky character drama.
The Grapes of Wrath poster
Payne is so adept at mining quiet humor ("swinging bachelors" watch The Grapes of Wrath in their hotel room) that we buy it when Sideways almost turns farcical in the late going, because we've already invested in the characters.
Jay Kelly poster
Clooney’s old-school Hollywood handsomeness, paired with the vulnerability he brought to dramas like The Descendants, allows Jay to be a fascinatingly complex shallow person.
Tim Grierson, Senior US critic, Jeremy Kay, Jonathan Romney, Allan Hunter • ScreenDaily • Aug 28, 2025
screendaily.com ↗
…a vibe he cultivated persuasively in movies like Michael Clayton, Up in the Air, and The Descendants…
The Ringer • Nov 14, 2025
theringer.com ↗
Ironically and pointedly, the film clips at the Italian homage come from Clooney’s own films.
Diane Carson • American Wildlife Foundation • Nov 13, 2025
awfj.org ↗
…indeed, it’s probably the best fit since “The Descendants.”
One Guys Opinion • One Guy's Opinion • Nov 25, 2025
oneguysopinion.com ↗
In The Descendants, it’s when he’s told his late wife was unfaithful to him.
Akos Peterbencze • Substack • Dec 14, 2025
substack.com ↗
…although he is capable of truly inspired work, as in The Descendants…
Bill Newcott • The Saturday Evening Post • Dec 4, 2025
saturdayeveningpost.com ↗
Captain Fantastic poster
As much as it recalls the family road-trip shenanigans of “Little Miss Sunshine,” “Captain Fantastic” may also remind you of “The Descendants,” Alexander Payne ’s drama about a man trying to make peace with his wife as she lies dying.
Justin Chang, www.latimes.com, justin-chang • Los Angeles Times • Jul 7, 2016
latimes.com ↗
McCabe & Mrs. Miller poster
Evoking the cinematographic proclivities of 1970s filmmakers (the influential likes of Hal Ashby’s Harold and Maude and Robert Altman’s McCabe & Mrs. Miller pervade the fuzzy, 35mm cinematography), Payne reverberates the eras’ ambiance via faraway zooms, sentimental Labi Siffre and Cat Stevens’ needle drops, rustic prep-school environs, and darkly-lit oaken hallways.
Paul Keelan • Film Obsessive • Dec 22, 2023
filmobsessive.com ↗