Beyond the general idea, however, Lepeniotis and co-writer Lorne Cameron (2006's " Over the Hedge ") bring nothing to the material that is fresh or engaging.
Writer/director Peter Lepeniotis was an animator at Disney/Pixar, while co-writer Lorne Cameron worked on Disney’s “Brother Bear” and DreamWorks “Over the Hedge.”
That's a shame, because there's fun in the basic premise of the film, even despite the obvious debt owed to 2006's "Over the Hedge," which -- like "The Nut Job" -- tells the story of a group of woodland animals who stage the mother of all heists.
And so, with the animals’ goal so easily achieved, Lepeniotis and co-writer Lorne Cameron (“Over the Hedge”) are left to fall back on stale twists, such as revealing Raccoon as an “Animal Farm”-style tyrant who manipulates his herd according to the motto “Animals are controlled by the amount of food they have.”
Director Peter Lepeniotis, working with co-writer Lorne Cameron (Over the Hedge), could have let the two heists, the animal and the human one, parallel each other in a more ingenious way.
A conflict over ransacking a nut cart ends in Surly’s banishment, but when he and Buddy discover a nut shop—owned by a group of thieves attempting to tunnel under a bank vault across the street—the “ Ocean’s Eleven meets Ratatouille with a dash of Over The Hedge ” plot commences.