The film mixes the procedural crime elements of David Fincher’s Zodiac with a time-travel conceit that nearly mirrors James Cameron’s The Terminator , all in a much lower-tech, ground- level way.
It mixes the procedural crime elements of David Fincher’s Zodiac with a time-travel story that follows the outlines of James Cameron’s The Terminator , and leaves us with tormented characters trying to survive and say something profound under the spell of the blood moon.
But when all that ambition is in service of a banal, ill-advised twist, I can’t appreciate it, no matter how much I want to love a Terminator / Zodiac mashup.
After the film’s Fantastic Fest premiere, director Jim Mickle said he wanted it to do for Philadelphia what David Fincher’s Zodiac did for San Francisco.
Merging a procedural about an obsession with a single case like “Zodiac” with sci-fi elements is a clever idea for a B-movie but “In the Shadow of the Moon” isn’t fun enough to qualify as that.
But Mickle and the film's screenwriters hold back the inevitable reveal for so long, aiming for a Zodiac -like scope and asking the viewer to be invested in Lockhart's personal journey, that you'll likely start to lose interest down the stretch.