Under the workmanlike direction of Mark Waters ("Freaky Friday," "The Spiderwick Chronicles"), the movie centers around the fundamental gimmick of pitting Carrey and his trademark physical comedy against a group of scurrying and noisy penguins (lensed with a combination of live-action shots and well-rendered CGI animation), which seem to take to Popper's pad like fish to water, even settling down in a cozy corner of his freezer.
It’s hard to believe that this junk was directed by Mark Waters, who presided over the big-screen adaptation of The Spiderwick Chronicles , a smart, scary adaptation of a children’s book series that honors its source material almost as much as Mr. Popper’s Penguins doesn’t.
So what the screenwriters and Mark Waters, the director of “Ghosts of Girlfriends Past“ and “The Spiderwick Chronicles,” do is turn it into a generic and sentimental dad-lost-his-family-because-he-was-married-to-his-job story, sort of “The Haunted Mansion” or “Imagine That” without Eddie Murphy.