To compare Edwards’ work in The Creator to one of the greats, he achieves the same level of world-building that James Cameron managed with Avatar.
Much as in James Cameron’s Avatar films, the U.S. military is presented as fearsome, ruthless, and largely immoral; it creates a terrifying orbital platform named NOMAD that circles the skies, dropping gigantic bombs on targets near and far.
As in James Cameron's “Avatar,” the villains here are the growling warmongers who can't see that their adversaries have souls.
…the problem is that the script (by Edwards and Chris Weitz, who also worked on "Rogue One") never follows through on the deeper or more complex ideas it brings up, and overly simplifies its conflict and the people involved. This results in a predictable and dumbed-down story that feels like Edwards doing James Cameron's "Avatar" in terms of presenting bold worldbuilding and sci-fi ideas, but without the emotional resonance of that giant film.
Where the lush planet Pandora of James Cameron’s Avatar felt distant and fantastical, like a Roger Dean painting, The Creator’s patinated vision feels like a place you could reach out and touch.
In terms of addressing contemporary geopolitics, the film falls into exactly the same trap as James Cameron’s Avatar (2009): the USA are depicted as aggressive colonial invaders, while the blended civilisation of humans and robots in the so-named “New Asia” are blurred into an anonymous and actively colonialist “other”.