The strengths of Pirates of the Caribbean lie mainly in Verbinski's sincere tributes to boy's life pirate operas, from volumes of unnatural fog to the good teeth/bad teeth barometer of morality, to parrots on shoulders and characters who mutter "Arrrrrgh, shiver me timbers"--benefiting, as well, from Verbinski's and wonderful cinematographer Dariusz Wolski's (Dark City, Romeo is Bleeding, and Verbinski's own The Mexican ) colour schemes and lighting, which provide Pirates of the Caribbean with a rich texture that again reminds of Gilliam.
…probably best that director Gore Verbinski ( The Ring , The Mexican ) and writers Ted Elliot, Terry Rossio, Stuart Beattie, and Jay Wolpert embellished the plot a little, since the ride, as I remember it, mainly involves animatronic pirates yelling, drinking, shooting, looting, and chasing women.
Director Gore Verbinski has played to both his strengths, stylish horror ("The Ring") and offbeat, sometimes violent comedy ("The Mexican").
This rollicking adventure from director Gore Verbinski is in love with the sights and sounds of pirate movie tropes—sailors swinging from ship ropes, sword fights, cannon balls flying through the air, glistening pirate bounty—and benefits immensely from both the filmmaker's successful fusion of arch comedy, swashbuckling action, mild horror (a trick neither his execrable The Mexican, nor his leaden The Ring , could pull off), and his willingness to let Johnny Depp overact his heart out.
Verbinski had, at this point, made three features: the first, Mousehunt , was a live-action movie made with the physics and logic of a Tom & Jerry cartoon; the third, The Ring , was an exercise in probing the limits of terror available to a PG-13 horror movie (the second, The Mexican , is a film that nobody in the world has ever seen, despite it starring Brad Pitt and Julia Roberts).
Cinematographer Dariusz Wolski ("The Mexican," The Crow") produces sparkling visuals both above and below the waterline.