Considering how closely Butler resembles Antonio Banderas in this movie, I can't understand why the producers of this film didn't go for the much more charismatic Banderas, especially since he proved he could sing in the last film adaptation of an Andrew Lloyd Webber play, Evita.
Speaking of Madonna, the "Phantom" filmmakers could have taken some cues from director Alan Parker's rousing screen adaptation of "Evita."
Madonna's lead performance in Evita , the last film made from a Webber show, wasn't necessarily any better, but at least she makes sense from a metanarrative and marketing perspective.
He was absolutely stunning in Alan Parker�s Evita adaptation, done with style, grace and God forbid, a few chances.