It is during this overture with the monarch resting on select plants that the dramatic theme music from Marcelo Zarvos (who basically repurposed Michel Legrand's theme for 1971's The Go-Between) plays into the concept of melodrama, and how our society feeds off it—especially when it's prepackaged in such a way as this.
The feeling of suspense is goosed by the prickling score, which Haynes borrows from another movie altogether – Michel Legrand’s theme from Joseph Losey’s 1971 film, The Go-Between. The two films hinge on furtive affairs, but more significantly, both films are about a person too unformed to understand how they are being manipulated. In May December that person is Joe, Gracie’s husband, played as an adult by Charles Melton (a former CW heartthrob, he was Reggie on Riverdale).
By adapting Michel Legrand's music for Joseph Losey's “The Go-Between,” Marcelo Zarvos' score emphasizes the roots of the film in the classical melodramas to which the writer-director paid homage in his remarkable “Far From Heaven” back in 2002.
Instead of writing a totally original score, Haynes––in a brilliant artistic recycling on par with R.M.N.'s re-use of In the Mood for Love‘s theme at Cannes last year––asked composer Marcelo Zavros to adapt one of his favorite scores: Michel Legrand's compositions for 1971's The Go-Between.
Close-up images of Monarch butterflies and their surrounding manicured flower gardens are scored by the theme from Joseph Losey’s 1971 film The Go-Between. The archly dramatic music lends a discomfiting feeling to the scenes of domesticity (a cookout for friends and family in Savannah, Georgia) that soon follow. Such a jarring juxtaposition, best encapsulated by said music leading into a character complaining about not having enough hot dogs, sets up a film that wants to suture the lurid and the mundane, creating in the process a masterful meditation on performance and predation.
Haynes—aided by a discordant score from Marcelo Zarvos, who adapted Michel Legrand's work from the 1971 film The Go-Between—trains the camera on the details that show the ripple effects of Gracie's abuse.