Wuthering Heights (1939)
Directed by William Wyler
Young orphan Heathcliff is adopted by the wealthy Earnshaw family and moves into their estate, Wuthering Heights. Soon, the new resident falls for his compassionate foster sister, Cathy. The two share a remarkable bond that seems unbreakable until Cathy, feeling the pressure of social convention, suppresses her feelings and marries Edgar Linton, a man of means who befits her stature. Heathcliff vows to win her back.
18 connections found
View:
18 connections, in both directions
What critics compared Wuthering Heights to
That woman with the braids on her head, struggling to walk through lashing rain, falling in the mud, determinedly fleeing we don’t know what – in the dramatic opening of Cary Joji Fukunaga’s new film, she could be any fiery 19th century heroine, from Tess of the D’Urbervilles to Cathy in Wuthering Heights.
The problem with Jane Eyre has always been that Jane and Rochester are thrown together by narrative contrivance rather than by inevitability - Charlotte's sister Emily did a far better job of presenting a convincing relationship between two people who just don't make any sense together with her Wuthering Heights.
The story includes elements of the Gothic hauntings of a Mary Shelley (Frankenstein); the engaging war of wits of a Jane Austen (Pride and Prejudice); and the super-charged romantic melodrama of Brontë sister Emily (Wuthering Heights).
Films of Brontë novels have been arriving in pairs at regular intervals these past 70 years, as if a production of Emily's Wuthering Heights demanded an accompanying production of Charlotte's Jane Eyre .
The film combines the gloomy aesthetics of “Wuthering Heights,” the apparitions, family secrets and betrayals of “The Woman in Black” with the murderous straight razor chills of “Sweeney Todd.”
Although the film may hold a certain appeal for those who have spent long hours thumbing through the pages of The Picture of Dorian Gray, Northanger Abbey, Jane Eyre, and Wuthering Heights, its deficiencies make it at best an atmospheric triumph with a weak narrative.
Pride And Prejudice and Wuthering Heights are the two novels that keep coming up during Hardin and Tessa’s courtship, and it’s potentially intriguing to wonder if Hardin and Tessa are in the early days of a romantic comedy or a romantic tragedy.
The two eventually bond over their shared love of fiction books, with Tessa, running away from the prospect of kissing him during a game of Truth or Dare, being shocked to discover a copy of Wuthering Heights in Hardin's bedroom.
For two people who reference Pride and Prejudice and Wuthering Heights, they can’t make a compelling love story of their own.
As a fan of “Wuthering Heights” and “Pride and Prejudice,” Tessa can’t resist Hardin’s, umm, charms, which marry the worst aspects of Heathcliff and Mr. Darcy.
He's also able to quote from Wuthering Heights and engage in a spirited classroom argument with Tessa, about Pride and Prejudice , in which the subtext is inescapable.
Wright's Pride & Prejudice won't satisfy the purists, who will quibble over the details and complain that there's too many "Charlotte Bronte" moments (like the Wuthering Heights homage with Elizabeth staring out over a rocky precipice).
Advertisement
Teresa begins reading Emily Brontë’s classic Gothic 1847 novel “Wuthering Heights” while complaining to Jessica that this party is dead and she wants to leave.
Uiteraard kunnen we Emily Brontë’s Wuthering Heights niet uitvlakken als een subtiel, maar cruciaal verhaalelement.
Her one period picture - "Wuthering Heights" - made Heathcliff black, and set its story in the muddiest moors imaginable.
In both “Fish Tank” and her little-seen, boldly revisionist adaptation of “Wuthering Heights,” the director’s rough-hewn style seemed almost precocious in its primitivism; all that raw austerity could feel like a bit of a put-on.
Arnold's look at this undercurrent of America was inspired by her own travels across the country — a journey that began at the Salt Lake City airport rental-car counter after her adaptation of "Wuthering Heights" screened at the 2012 Sundance Film Festival.
Arnold comes to America after three films that explored a more native and personal form of picaresque, the byways of English passion; though even those movies — Red Road, Fish Tank, Wuthering Heights — had a flair and impetus beyond the norms of Cinema Blighty.
Arnold, who turned in an extra visceral adaptation of Wuthering Heights in 2011, filmed American Honey in chronological order, with much of the film improvised and like Larry Clark’s Kids, it wears its nihilism on its tie-dye sleeve but it also has the beauty and power of a Terence Malick epic.
Loosely inspired by a 2007 New York Times article by Ian Urbina on the subculture of roving “mag crews” — groups of teenagers and young adults, many of them runaways and dropouts, who sell magazine subscriptions door-to-door and in the streets — the scripted drama by British writer-director Andrea Arnold (“ Wuthering Heights ”) isn’t quite cinema vérité, although most of the young cast is composed of nonactors, and the style of filmmaking is certainly fly-on-the-wall — with a vengeance.
Unfortunately, Scodelario, so good recently in Wuthering Heights, does get lost; she does what she can, but her character seems to be waiting around for the sequel to completely reveal herself.
Then there's Scodelario, a nuanced young actress ( Wuthering Heights ) who's wasted on the tiny role of Teresa, the only girl ever to be sent to the Glade (this isn't Peeta and Katniss or Tris and Four).
A spaghetti western on the surface, Django Unchained owes as much a debt to Leone as it does to the Sergio Corbucci-inaugurated series of films that gave it its name, with the recasting of the malleable Django (Jamie Foxx) as a black guy carrying with it the same kind of fissionable charge as the casting of Heathcliff as an African in Andrea Arnold's Wuthering Heights.
Advertisement
Don't expect "Wuthering Heights" profundity or passion in "Time"; the film's basically about a couple of attractive yuppies whose lives of happy affluence are disrupted by a genetic disorder that sends Henry packing on his wedding night, at Christmas, when his wife miscarries, even the night of his own demise.
Unwholesome, sure, but arguably no more so than Wuthering Heights or Jane Eyre , two better-written Gothic romances about young women in thrall to a remote, charismatic, often cruel hero.