View:

Connections, in both directions

The Searchers poster
Writer-director Scott Cooper is confident enough to reference Ford’s work — such as framing a doorway in a manner reminiscent of “The Searchers” (1956) — while delivering a tale of racism and redemption that stands on its own.
Grave and somber, Scott Cooper ’s “Hostiles” opens with a scene that recalls John Ford ’s “ The Searchers .”
Godfrey Cheshire • RogerEbert.com • Dec 22, 2017
rogerebert.com ↗
It's an ambitious film that will remind its fans of John Ford's 1955 classic "The Searchers," and its critics of Michael Cimino's bloated 1980 box-office flop "Heaven's Gate."
With Takayanagi’s help, Cooper recalls the best of John Ford’s The Searchers , and with Bale’s help he rectifies its worst.
maddwolf • MadWolf • Jan 25, 2018
maddwolf.com ↗
Working from an unpublished manuscript by the late Donald Stewart, the filmmaker echoes The Searchers – John Ford's 1956 classic starring John Wayne as a vengeful cowboy – in tackling the way racism and violence seem to be hardwired into the American character.
Peter Travers • Rolling Stone • Dec 23, 2017
rollingstone.com ↗
Dozens more will be butchered to appease the themes of director Scott Cooper’s script: the sin and apparent redemption of the American myth, complete with visual quotations from The Searchers .
The A.V. Club • Dec 14, 2017
avclub.com ↗
GoodFellas poster
Comparisons to the films of Martin Scorsese are inevitable (and apparently obligatory), but while Goodfellas and Casino evoke a time and a place through their characters and events Cooper’s latest evokes nothing more than a reminder that Depp is a fantastic actor when he wants to be.
Film School Rejects
filmschoolrejects.com ↗
Black Mass is more The Departed than Goodfellas — Jack Nicholson’s mobster in the former actually was inspired by Bulger.
Brian Truitt, USA TODAY, Brian Truitt • USA TODAY • Sep 17, 2015
usatoday.com ↗
Without revealing too much, let’s just say that his sinister, is-he-kidding-or-isn’t-he demeanor immediately recalls Joe Pesci in Goodfellas.
Based on Dick Lehr and Gerard O'Neill's book, Black Mass: The True Story of an Unholy Alliance between the FBI and the Irish Mob, the film borrows heavily from Scorsese's Goodfellas and The Departed, though Scott Cooper's film definitely has its moments.
Cairo 360
cairo360.com ↗
Trying to match up against Goodfellas , Casino or The Departed isn’t the smartest move if you can’t at least match those all-time classics and Black Mass comes up way short.
Jeffrey Lyles • Lyle's Movie Files • Sep 18, 2015
lylesmoviefiles.com ↗
There is a sensuality in his evilness, like that of a vampire, and even a theatricality not unlike Joe Pesci’s gangster in “Goodfellas.”
Honeycutt's Hollywood
honeycuttshollywood.com ↗
The Departed poster
It’s the type of exhaustive story that demands Martin Scorsese’s stylistic eye and William Monahan’s economical storytelling, but those two only paid spiritual homage to Bulger when they carved out 2006’s The Departed .
Michael Roffman • Consequence of Sound • Sep 15, 2015
consequenceofsound.net ↗
Black Mass is more The Departed than Goodfellas — Jack Nicholson’s mobster in the former actually was inspired by Bulger.
Brian Truitt, USA TODAY, Brian Truitt • USA TODAY • Sep 17, 2015
usatoday.com ↗
(He didn’t actually give them any real info and basically played them all for dopes; Jack Nicholson’s character in The Departed is inspired by Bulger, too.)
Bulger inspired Jack Nicholson’s gangster in “The Departed” (2006), so comparisons between “Black Mass” and Martin Scorsese’s Oscar-winner are inevitable.
Based on the true story of James “Whitey” Bulger, the South Boston hood who inspired Jack Nicholson’s character in The Departed , it chronicles how Bulger (Johnny Depp) was able to stay out of prison because the FBI, led by Agent John Connolly (Joel Edgerton), uses him as an informant to help take down the Italian mafia out of North Boston.
Jarrod Jones, Emma Fraser, Jesse Hassenger, Elijah Gonzalez, Garrett Martin, Grant Sharples, Saloni Gajjar, Christina Izzo, Casey Epstein-Gross, A.V. Club Staff • The A.V. Club • Apr 19, 2022
avclub.com ↗
Fictionalized depictions of murderous crime bosses have a little rope to play with; the distance from true-life means a filmmaker doesn’t have to be squirrelly about exploring the man inside the monster of a Michael Corleone or The Departed’s Frank Costello (reportedly inspired by Bulger).
The Austin Chronicle • Sep 18, 2015
austinchronicle.com ↗
Casino poster
Comparisons to the films of Martin Scorsese are inevitable (and apparently obligatory), but while Goodfellas and Casino evoke a time and a place through their characters and events Cooper’s latest evokes nothing more than a reminder that Depp is a fantastic actor when he wants to be.
Film School Rejects
filmschoolrejects.com ↗
Trying to match up against Goodfellas , Casino or The Departed isn’t the smartest move if you can’t at least match those all-time classics and Black Mass comes up way short.
Lyle's Movie Files
lylesmoviefiles.com ↗
It doesn’t help that Scott Cooper’s Black Mass must follow in the footsteps of more dynamic pictures like Brian De Palma’s Carlito’s Way ; Martin Scorsese’s Goodfellas , Casino , and The Departed (in which Jack Nicholson played a character inspired by Bulger); and Mike Newell’s Donnie Brasco , which starred Depp as an undercover FBI agent.
Peter Canavese • Groucho Reviews
grouchoreviews.com ↗
It’s no small compliment when I tell you that I believe Scott Cooper’s Black Mass can run with Scorsese’s mob trilogy of Goodfellas, Casino and The Departed.
Sean O'Connell • CinemaBlend • Sep 17, 2015
cinemablend.com ↗
Screenwriters Mark Mallouk and Jez Butterworth concoct a strange film, because it’s tonally myopic rather than bringing you fun, or sadistic laughs like Goodfellas or Casino.
Blake Howard • Graffiti with Punctuation • Oct 12, 2015
graffitiwithpunctuation.net ↗
Pan's Labyrinth poster
But Cooper might have benefited from borrowing some of the sheer sense of fun and shameless fascination del Toro brings to telling fantastical, frightening tales such as "Pan's Labyrinth" and "The Devil's Backbone."
Dann Gire • Daily Herald • Oct 28, 2021
dailyherald.com ↗
We see a bit less of the wendigo than we’ve seen of some other creatures in del Toro films — you’ll likely remember him as a mess of horns moving through shadows, not in the detailed way one recalls the Faun or the Pale Man of Pan’s Labyrinth — and in important ways the beast is scariest before it sprouts those horns: Scott Haze, playing Lucas’ father before he has fully transformed, is monstrous and pathetic but still capable of commanding his son’s loyalty.
John DeFore • The Hollywood Reporter • Oct 12, 2021
hollywoodreporter.com ↗
Films like The Devil’s Backbone and Pan’s Labyrinth similarly used ghosts and fantastical creatures to examine concepts such as abandonment and war.
Terry Mesnard • Gayly Dreadful • Oct 28, 2021
gaylydreadful.com ↗
Well shot in dreary, small town muteness by Florian Hoffmeister ( A Quiet Passion , 2016) and just the right kind of brooding score from Javier Navarrete ( Pan’s Labyrinth , 2006) allow for a properly set stage, but ultimately both the title and so-so denouement make Antlers feel like something we would have seen in the “Masters of Horror” series from the mid-2000s (especially since John Landis had an entry in the series called “Deer Woman”).
Nicholas Bell • Ioncinema • Oct 30, 2021
ioncinema.com ↗
Produced by monster fetishist Guillermo del Toro ( Pan’s Labyrinth , The Shape of Wate r) but directed by Scott Cooper ( Crazy Heart ), the mood is overly gloomy and lacking del Toro’s signature sparkle.
Simran Hans, www.theguardian.com, simran-hans • The Guardian • Oct 31, 2021
theguardian.com ↗
The Oscar-nominated Spanish composer who provided aural chills for Guillermo del Toro’s “The Devil’s Backbone” and “Pan’s Labyrinth” does it again, setting the mood for the dark thriller.
Joe Friar, www.facebook.com • Fort Worth Report • Oct 31, 2021
fortworthreport.org ↗
A Star Is Born poster
Cooper has a pleasant twang when he sings, projecting a melancholy, afternoon-y vibe that brings to mind Crazy Heart.
Richard Lawson • Vanity Fair • Sep 7, 2018
vanityfair.com ↗
His past-his-prime alcoholic singer is channeling Jeff Bridges in Crazy Heart for sure, which isn’t a bad thing.
Chris Gore, Andy Howell • Film Threat • Sep 12, 2018
filmthreat.com ↗
I get the comparison, but a twenty years younger version of Jeff Bridgescharacter in Crazy Heart (while his career was still booming despite an approaching decline) is probably more apt.
Jared Mobarak • Buffalo Vibe • Oct 5, 2018
buffalovibe.com ↗
(If you never saw “Crazy Heart,” or how forgot how good it is, catch up.
Matt Pais • Matt Pais • Oct 11, 2018
mattpais.com ↗
As in Crazy Heart, a similarly excellent movie starring Jeff Bridges, it starts with quiet menace lurking in the wings and ends in a display of humiliation so sharp you can’t help but cringe from it.
Cooper sings decently enough to be convincing, but his performance overall feels rather like a reboot of Jeff Bridges’ turn as Bad Blake in “Crazy Heart” (or even his Rooster Cogburn, to tell the truth).
The Hunt for Red October poster
Writer-director Scott Cooper ("Black Mass") based the concept on a manuscript by the late Donald Stewart, who wrote movies like "The Hunt For Red October" before his death in 1999.
Brian Lowry • CNN • Dec 21, 2017
cnn.com ↗
He’s a man of few words, as per Bale’s masterful underplaying and Cooper’s lean adaptation of an unpublished manuscript by Donald Stewart, the screenwriter behind Missing and The Hunt for Red October.
Cooper’s screenplay, based on a manuscript given him by the widow of the late Donald Stewart ( Missing , The Hunt for Red October ), strives to make a statement about the American way of life, the genocide of the Native American people, the inescapable savagery of war, and the tenaciousness of trauma.
(Director Cooper based his screenplay on a “manuscript” by Donald E. Stewart, writer of such films as 1982’s Missing and The Hunt for Red October .
MaryAnn Johanson • Flick Filosopher • Jan 17, 2018
flickfilosopher.com ↗
He can't manage the same with his attempt at a western, mostly because the script, based on a manuscript by deceased screenwriter Donald E. Stewart (Missing, The Hunt for Red October), is too awful to salvage.
The manuscript was originally written by the late Academy Award-winning screenwriter Donald E. Stewart, who wrote Missing and The Hunt for Red October , who died almost twenty years ago.
Hellraiser poster
An inescapable itchiness starts to creep into virtually every scene around the second act, a restless sensation that cannot be alleviated by gnarly nods to genre classics like My Bloody Valentine (1981), The Thing (1982), and Hellraiser (1987).
Mama poster
The endangered children in “Antlers” will remind many of the sisters in Andy Muschietti’s 2013 entry “Mama,” another supernatural-based film produced by del Toro.
The Boston Herald • Oct 29, 2021
bostonherald.com ↗
Similar in tone and nature to Andy Muschietti’s 2013 supernatural scarer Mama , another painting with the del Toro stroke, this film largely avoids cheap jump scares and flowing blood in favour of something more psychological; that’s not to say this doesn’t have its share of violent moments, it just doesn’t rely on them to maintain its horrific personality.
Peter Gray • The Aurum Review • Oct 28, 2021
theaureview.com ↗
Song Sung Blue poster
…it’s not as simple as someone being a Bruce Springsteen fan and automatically adoring Scott Cooper’s Springsteen: Deliver Me from Nowhere…
Lexi Amoriello • Movie Recs by Lex • Nov 6, 2025
movierecsbylex.com ↗
Unlike “Springsteen: Deliver Me from Nowhere” (2025), audience members will not need any clues as to what they were supposed to take away from the film.
Sarah Vincent, www.facebook.com • Dec 25, 2025
sarahgvincentviews.com ↗
Hard Times poster
Oh, and there’s a lot of Walter Hill cooped up in there, as in his 1970s street-boxing tale, “Hard Times.”
Ray Pride • New City Film • Dec 4, 2013
newcityfilm.com ↗
A River Runs Through It poster
He’s not as out there as Edward Norton in Rounders or Brad Pitt in A River Runs Through It where it’s like, come on, you’re just asking for trouble.
Fred Topel • Crave • Nov 11, 2013
archive.org ↗
First Blood poster
That food-coma-populated valley of early December, which combines post-holiday letdown with pre-holiday anxiety, seems as good a time as any to release “Out of the Furnace,” a stridently downbeat Rust Belt drama that can’t decide if it wants to be the first half of “The Deer Hunter” or the last half of “First Blood.”
Marc Mohan, www.facebook.com • The Oregonian/OregonLive • Dec 5, 2013
archive.org ↗
Hell or High Water poster
The Cavalry escort includes Jesse Plemons (“The Post,” “Black Mirror”) as a West Point newbie, Timothée Chalamet (“Call Me by Your Name”) as a young French recruit, Rory Cochrane (“Dazed and Confused”) under heavy facial hair as Blocker’s guilt-consumed fellow soldier, and the fearsome Ben Foster (“Hell or High Water”) as a cunning, crazy racist in the mix.
Ty Burr • The Boston Globe • Jan 3, 2018
bostonglobe.com ↗
They either come from a big time director like Quentin Tarantino with Django Unchained, are remade from classics like the Coens’ True Grit and James Mangold’s 3:10 to Yuma or strike at just the right time like David Mackenzie’s Hell or High Water.
Kyle Kizu • MovieMinis • Dec 25, 2017
movieminis.com ↗
“Hostiles” also underutilizes a talented supporting cast including “Hell or High Water” star Ben Foster as a derelict officer and 2018 Academy Award best actor nominee Timothée Chalamet as a private under Blocker’s command.
Matt Ward • Cinematic Considerations • Jan 28, 2018
cinematicconsiderations.com ↗
Fans of films like Unforgiven or Hell or High Water should find this movie interesting.
Geek Girl Authority
geekgirlauthority.com ↗
While most of the film consists of the posse riding snowmobiles through the drifts, there are two set pieces that incorporate the same kind of bloody mayhem that made many film critics rave over “Hell or High Water”.
Louis Proyect • CounterPunch • Dec 22, 2017
counterpunch.org ↗
The Shape of Water poster
A mediocre horror flick from some pretty capable sorts – it’s directed by Scott Cooper (“Crazy Heart,” “Black Mass”) and produced by Guillermo del Toro (“Pacific Rim,” “The Shape of Water”).
Tom Meek • Cambridge Day • Oct 31, 2021
cambridgeday.com ↗
Also, Oscar-winning director Guillermo del Toro is credited as one of the film's producers (full-on producer, not executive producer), who won his Oscars for "The Shape of Water," another Searchlight title.
Big Picture Big Sound
bigpicturebigsound.com ↗
One of many 2020 titles that saw its original release delayed due to the pandemic, and one of the few that held its nerve and opted out of a streaming alternative, Antlers , from director Scott Cooper ( Crazy Heart , Black Mass ) and producer Guillermo del Toro ( Pan’s Labyrinth , The Shape of Water ), proves its bold mentality weaves alongside its narrative, tackling trauma, neglect, and abuse in the guise of a fantastical-leaning horror film.
Peter Gray • The Aurum Review • Oct 28, 2021
theaureview.com ↗
But, then again, the film’s creature designed by Guy Davis (“The Shape of Water”) is the scariest screen wendigo thus far.
The Boston Herald • Oct 29, 2021
bostonherald.com ↗
Del Toro, director of Oscar's Best Picture "The Shape of Water" and other beastly stories, may be a producer on the atmospheric folk tale "Antlers," but the directorial chores fall to Scott Cooper.
Dann Gire • Daily Herald • Oct 28, 2021
dailyherald.com ↗
Also likely deserving of some credit is del Toro, the director of films that include the acclaimed 2006 work “Pan’s Labyrinth” and 2017 Academy Award winner “The Shape of Water.”
Mark Meszoros • The News-Herald • Oct 29, 2021
news-herald.com ↗
The Town poster
Martin Scorsese’s “The Departed” was loosely based on Bulger, as was a key character in Ben Affleck’s “The Town.”
First came Martin Scorsese's Oscar-scooping epic The Departed, then  Ben Affleck chipped in with The Town, both movies driven by their portrayal of tightly-knit groups of characters immovably rooted in their native Bostonian soil.
Adam Sweeting • The Arts Desk • Jan 4, 2018
theartsdesk.com ↗
The Boston crime world has been such a fertile ground for Martin Scorsese’s “The Departed” and Ben Affleck’s “The Town.”
Monica Castillo • International Business Times • Sep 18, 2015
ibtimes.com ↗
Cooper has made three films – 2009's Crazy Heart and 2013's Out of the Furnace preceded this one – that touch on specific milieus in contemporary America, but Black Mass often only captures the Boston surface streaks already codified by the likes of The Departed and The Town .
Craig Mathieson • The Sydney Morning Herald • Oct 10, 2015
com.au ↗
21 Jump Street poster
If you don't count his vocal performance in "Rango" or his cameo in "21 Jump Street," you have to look all the way back to 2009's "Public Enemies" to find a credible performance from Johnny Depp, the actor having lost his way in his makeup and dress up toy chest.
Reeling Reviews • Jan 10, 2020
reelingreviews.com ↗
Last Night in Soho poster
Like Soho , it comes from a director who isn’t exactly a Horror Guy: Scott Cooper has credits like Crazy Heart and Out of the Furnace , and here funnels hardscrabble men, the women who are concerned for them, crippling addictions, and beards into a creature feature with the Guillermo del Toro seal of approval.
Jesse • SportsAlcohol.com • Oct 29, 2021
sportsalcohol.com ↗
Like Soho , it comes from a director who isn’t exactly a Horror Guy: Scott Cooper has credits like Crazy Heart and Out of the Furnace , and here funnels hardscrabble men, the women who are concerned for them, crippling addictions, and beards into a creature feature with the Guillermo del Toro seal of approval.
Jesse • SportsAlcohol.com • Oct 29, 2021
sportsalcohol.com ↗
The Last Samurai poster
In effect, he is trying to prevent Blocker from turning into the quintessential jaded Hollywood hero – a timeworn prototype – like the one Tom Cruise immortalizes in Edward Zwick’s The Last Samurai.
Rahul Desai • Film Companion • Feb 16, 2018
filmcompanion.in ↗
Bones and All poster
Both he and Chalamet—and even Rylance, in his own bohemian way—reflect junkie redneck types, like they could be Woody Harrelson’s meth fiend henchmen from Out of the Furnace .
Luke Hicks • The Film Stage • Sep 4, 2022
thefilmstage.com ↗