View:

Connections, in both directions

Romeo and Juliet poster
The parallels that can be drawn to "Romeo and Juliet" are more in evidence this time around.
Sadly, much of what I enjoyed about the first movie seems missing in the overly depressing follow-up film, which comes across like Romeo and Juliet on extra downers.
Mark Lubischer, Betty Jo Tucker • Reel Talk Reviews
reeltalkreviews.com ↗
Scenes where Bella and Edward sit through a class covering Romeo and Juliet act like a subtle wink to adults in the audience: Yes we know this is a bit overly dramatic and self-important, but, as even Shakespeare recognized, so are teenagers.
Enjoying all of New Moon 's 130-minute running time (as I did, well enough) takes the ability to swoon and snort simultaneously—say, when a fantasy Bella runs through the woods in gray chiffon, or Edward recites the closing lines of Romeo and Juliet by heart.
Mortal Engines poster
Jackson and fellow Rings producer Fran Walsh’s adaptation of a 2001 YA steampunk novel more than a decade after the release of the ill-advised flop adaptation of The Golden Compass (itself largely blamed for the fall of Rings supposed-powerhouse New Line Cinema) might have seemed craven and misguided even just a few years ago; now it feels preciously, precariously idiosyncratic, a kind of flight of fancy that must be protected at all costs just on principle.
Emily Yoshida • New York Magazine (Vulture) • Dec 11, 2018
vulture.com ↗
There have certainly been enough attempts at launching fantasy franchises in the following years: The Golden Compass in 2007, YA dystopian fare like The Maze Runner and the Divergent series, and more recently the new Fantastic Beasts franchise, which has yet to recapture the original Harry Potter ’s magic.
The Ringer • Dec 17, 2018
theringer.com ↗
It honestly feels like a film released about a decade too late; put it out around the same time as The Golden Compass or The Spiderwick Chronicles , and it might have stood a better chance.
Jennifer Heaton, Author Jennifer Heaton • WordPress.com • Dec 14, 2018
wordpress.com ↗
In many ways, it reminded me of The Golden Compass remake – a story that sacrificed it’s true heart at the altar of Hollywood.
thebookfamilyrogerson • The Book Family Rogerson • Dec 10, 2018
thebookfamilyrogerson.com ↗
Remember how The Golden Compass was a terribly disappointing movie that didn’t have to be terrible?
The Last Airbender poster
“The Last Airbender’’ is dreadful, an incomprehensible fantasy-action epic that makes the 2007 film “The Golden Compass,’’ a similarly botched adaptation of a beloved property from another medium, look like a four-star classic.
Although there’s supposedly more to come, this expensive epic has the huge, hugely desperate feel of “The Golden Compass,” “Eragon” and all those other films that were supposed to kick off kids’-movie franchises — and never got past their first installments.
The Last Airbender feels almost exactly like The Golden Compass.
Jeff Bayer • The Scorecard Review • Jul 1, 2010
thescorecardreview.com ↗
“Airbender” is kiddie fantasy so limp it makes “Narnia,” “Percy Jackson” and “The Golden Compass” look like unqualified masterpieces.
Just as likely, however, it will suffer the same fate of another fantasy it resembles: "The Golden Compass," which failed to push whatever buttons such fare needs to prosper.
Shyamalan has only directed one Airbender movie -- he's signed on for two sequels, but their fate rests with the box office grosses of this $150 million production -- and this situation feels awfully reminiscent of The Golden Compass, the first (and open-ended) installment in an intended franchise that was abandoned after audiences didn't turn out in enough numbers.
Teen Wolf Too poster
Bella is crushed and spends the next few months (signified by arguably the most unintentionally hilarious moment in a film chock-full of them), weeping herself to sleep, trembling like a withdrawing heroin addict and acting even more anti-social than usual until she begins spending more and more quality time with Jake (Taylor Lautner), her newly buff and often shirtless best pal who, it turns out, is also a werewolf (though easily the least threatening one to appear on the big screen since Jason Bateman suited up for “Teen Wolf Too“).
Ben Nieporent • eFilmCritic
archive.org ↗
Alice in Wonderland poster
And yet even much of what we see feels tediously familiar, borrowed from elsewhere: The White Queen’s (Anne Hathaway: Valentine’s Day, Bride Wars) realm is Rivendell; Alice riding the Bandersnatch is The Golden Compass’s Lyra riding the warrior polar bear Iorek Byrnison; even the Mad Hatter’s tea party is taking place in the shadow of the gearpunk windmill from Burton’s own Sleepy Hollow.
The flat climax borrows architecture and action from Narnia, animals from the "The Golden Compass" and psychedelic jungle flora from the movie it's replacing in theaters, "Avatar."
GARY THOMPSON • The Philadelphia Inquirer
archive.org ↗
There are bits of “The Lord of the Rings,’’ “Shrek,’’ “The Wizard of Oz,’’ “The Princess Bride,’’ even “The Golden Compass,’’ all given a wash of chic Gothic gloom.
The Boston Globe
boston.com ↗
The Darkest Minds poster
Call it The Golden Compass rule: No multi-part movie series should be started without a reasonable certainty that the story will be told in full.
James Berardinelli • ReelViews • Aug 3, 2018
reelviews.net ↗
The final image of the movie — a child’s hand held high in warring defiance of a villain we still don’t quite understand — isn’t so much a cliff-hanger as a “dot dot dot” for a sequel that will never get made, trailing off into the dustbin alongside such open-ended fantasy movies as “City of Ember,” “Ender’s Game,” and “The Golden Compass.”
Peter Debruge • Variety • Jul 31, 2018
variety.com ↗
Dances with Wolves poster
An Oscar pedigree is provided by actor Graham Greene ("Dances with Wolves") who has a small role as the sheriff's deputy, Harry Clearwater.
The Bridges of Madison County poster
The movie, directed by Chris Weitz, comes off very much like Clint Eastwood’s The Bridges of Madison County—professional filmmaking applied to sub-literary euphemistic trash, in this case couched in the jejune crush-fantasies of a Mormon mom stranded at home with three little boys.
Catch Me If You Can poster
Operation Finale doesn’t reach the Spielbergian heights of Munich or the cat-and-mouse thrills of Catch Me if You Can , but the sparring between Kingsley and Isaac is remarkable, and the film’s structural flaws never blunt the the touching impact of its themes.
Screen Queens • Aug 29, 2018
screen-queens.com ↗
The Queen poster
The malevolent leader of this Italian faction is Aro (Michael Sheen from "Frost/Nixon" and "The Queen") and his menacing minion is Jane (a nearly unrecognizable Dakota Fanning from "The Secret Life of Bees" and "War of the Worlds").
There is a brush with the vampire ruling class - featuring cameo appearances from Dakota Fanning, as a malevolent, blank-faced vampire girl, and Michael Sheen (recently seen as Tony Blair in The Queen ) as a suave vampire authority figure.
Philippa Hawker • The Age • Nov 17, 2009
com.au ↗
Not until Michael Sheen, of "Frost/Nixon" and "The Queen," makes an appearance as the vampire pope - a cross between Count Dooku and Voldemort, with Dakota Fanning in a small role as his sidekick - does the gloomy and lethargic film show any bite.
Underworld poster
I enjoyed it when everyone quit overcast Washington State and surried on over to Tuscany to confront a sect of ancient Italian vampires led by Michael Sheen (switching sides after playing a werewolf in the Underworld trilogy) who looks like a bloodsucking Mr Bean.
Dakota Fanning, all grown up, is seriously creepy with only about four lines as one of the Volturi, the ancient vampire ruling council (or whatever), and Michael Sheen (who gained valuable vampire/werewolf experience in the Underworld movies) hams it up delightfully as the group’s malevolent leader.
Plan 9 from Outer Space poster
I won't go as far as to say Taylor Lautner is a good actor, but he's an improvement over Robert Pattinson, who attempts to impersonate Bela Lugosi from Plan 9 from Outer Space.
Companion poster
There have been plenty of movies lately featuring AI robot companions where something goes decidedly wrong. From M3GAN to AfrAId, the ground has been pretty well covered.
Crockett Houghton, Facebook.com • Film Inquiry • Mar 4, 2025
filminquiry.com ↗
…many that try to use AI as a plot device turn out to be clunkers like the recent "Afraid."
Jeff Beck • The Blu Spot • Mar 31, 2025
thebluspot.com ↗
Notting Hill poster
After he dumps her (for reasons I can't be bothered to go into - honestly, you have to see the film) the camera revolves around her as she broods in her bedroom and the seasons change outside; it's like that bit in Notting Hill where Hugh Grant walks through Portobello Road market, the modern equivalent of pages peeling off a calendar to represent the passage of time, but I'm afraid it left me wondering how she'd stayed in that position for three months without needing to get up and go to the toilet.
The Da Vinci Code poster
These are hardly superlatives on the order of “shattering” and “beautiful,” but compared to the film versions of “The Da Vinci Code” and “Angels & Demons,” the only two movies ever made with less sex than the first two “Twilight"s, they’re matchless.
West Side Story poster
So, I’m willing to give Weitz points if he really did intend for audiences to see a riff on West Side Story — you know, the Broadway musical based on R&J — with that half-naked Native American gang in the woods.
MaryAnn Johanson • Flick Filosopher • Nov 19, 2009
flickfilosopher.com ↗
Vampires Suck poster
The plot, for lack of a better word, is based on a pastiche of moments from the first two "Twilight" films, "Twilight" and "The Twilight Saga: New Moon."
Instead, they merely plop down some sequence practically lifted wholesale from Twilight or The Twilight Saga: New Moon, add a gross-out gag, a piece of knockabout humor or a pop culture reference that will seem hopelessly dated in just a few years, and leave it at that.
The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring poster
It ends, like The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring, with more story yet to be told, and more tickets to be sold.
Combustible Celluloid
combustiblecelluloid.com ↗
Perhaps Weitz's oddest creative choice was concluding the film on an open-ended note a la Fellowship of the Ring.
All the Boys Love Mandy Lane poster
Also worth noting, Anna Kendrick (soon to hit it big with her Oscar-worthy performance in " Up in the Air") and Michael Welch (whose " All the Boys Love Mandy Lane " still hasn't found a U.S. release) are wonderful in the supporting roles of Bella's pals Jessica and Mike.
Dust Input Man
dustinputman.com ↗
Nuremberg poster
Other films have explored the pursuit and prosecution of post-war Nazi criminals (e.g., 2018’s Operation Finale)…
Brett McCracken • The Gospel Coalition • Nov 7, 2025
thegospelcoalition.org ↗