It is because the writer, Scott Silver ("The Mod Squad") made it one by creating a rap music contest.
8 Mile, sharply directed by Curtis Hanson from a script by Scott Silver (who's a long way from the inanities of The Mod Squad ), is a real movie, not a fast-buck package to exploit the fan base of a rap nonentity (hello, Vanilla Ice, goodbye).
Hanson paints a gritty and realistic portrait of the Murder City circa 1995, but the film's problem lies with the story, written by The Mod Squad scribe Scott Silver .
Producer Brian Grazer ("A Beautiful Mind") combines his passion for hip hop with a prestige director (Curtis Hanson, "L.A. Confidential"), a music superstar and a Rockyesque genre script (Scott Silver, "The Mod Squad") for a solid commercial outing.
Screenwriter Scott Silver ("johns," "The Mod Squad" ) covers some obvious territory -- gang troubles, mom's abusive boyfriend, Rabbit's tender devotion to his baby sister, an encouraging love interest (sexy, trashy Brittany Murphy) with a hidden agenda -- but always with fresh and unexpected twists on formula.
But we are rescued from mediocrity by a strong script by Scott Silver ("The Mod Squad," but forgive him), strong direction by Curtis Hanson ( "Wonder Boys," "L.A. Confidental"), and yes, strong acting by the famous Mr. Em.