McGuire also borrows liberally from the playbook of James Wan (who is not coincidentally a producer on the film), messing with the audience's sense of timing with his peek-a-boo terrors (there's even an ominous game of Marco Polo, recalling the first "The Conjuring" and its clapping game).
For a while, this mild, many-angled shocker, produced by horror impresarios James Wan and Jason Blum, seems to emerge from the same wellspring that spawned Insidious, Sinister, and The Conjuring. But unlike those deliciously scary tales of grieving families and ghostly invaders, Night Swim paddles in circles around inchoate human fears rather than diving furiously into a vortex of terror.
But with James Wan (“The Conjuring” and “Saw”) plastered on the poster as producer, McGuire keeps the tone somber even as the dialogue verges on the ridiculous. You’re not laughing with the movie, but at it when someone turns to the camera and says, “Let’s have a pool party!”
Perhaps this is because he's pulling so much from recognizable horror hits that we are inured; even the film's best sequence might be considered a riff on The Conjuring's sensational hide-and-clap sequence, notably constructed by Night Swim producer James Wan.
Given the calibre of horror talent on board with Night Swim (between them, producers Jason Blum and James Wan have such genre treats as the Halloween series, The Conjuring films, M3GAN and Malignant), as well as the fact that the short film it’s based on earned critical acclaim upon its release a decade ago, one would have hope when diving into Bryce McGuire‘s macabre waters.
And beneath that surface is precisely where the terror is meant to hide in Night Swim, the latest collaboration between Jason Blum’s Blumhouse and James Wan’s Atomic Monster film studios (responsible for The Conjuring Universe, Lights Out, Mortal Kombat, Malignant, and 2023’s runaway hit M3GAN).