To conclude, The Circle is a film that, by all means, should have worked: it is directed by James Ponsoldt ( The End of the Tour , Smashed , The Spectacular Now ), contains a fine cast, including Emma Watson, Tom Hanks, John Boyega, and Karen Gillan; and, in addition, imbues timely themes of surveillance, privacy, and the fear of a potential future that the over-saturation of social networking could lead to.
Directed by The Spectacular Now 's James Ponsoldt, The Circle just feels a day late and a dollar short in its treatment of the subject matter.
“The Circle” is directed by the top-notch filmmaker James Ponsoldt (“The Spectacular Now”); it’s an adaptation of a novel by the acclaimed author Dave Eggers (who co-wrote the screenplay with Ponsoldt); it stars Emma Watson, Tom Hanks and Patton Oswalt.
Adapted by filmmaker James Ponsoldt ( The End Of The Tour ; The Spectacular Now ) and novelist Dave Eggers from the latter’s novel of the same name, the movie follows Mae (Emma Watson) as she is granted access to the fantasy of many upwardly mobile young people: an entry-level job at a Google-like digital conglomerate.
It's all so horribly disappointing, given the skill that writer/director James Ponsoldt has shown on his three previous, excellent features ( Smashed , The Spectacular Now , and The End of the Tour ), all of which dealt with deeply, movingly human flaws.
“The Circle” is all the more disappointing, given it was based on a novel by the brilliant wordsmith Dave Eggers and directed by James Ponsoldt of “The Spectacular Now” and “The End of the Tour” acclaim.