The best submarine films, The Hunt for Red October , Das Boot , were military stories but performance driven.
The last notable entries in the genre were "The Hunt for Red October" (1990), "U-571" (2000) and "K19: The Widowmaker" (2002).
Director Marsh keeps things moving, stages some impressive actions sequences (I especially liked the SEALs who are so badass that they jump right into a nasty thunderstorm), and even seems to care to a degree about making the submarine experience feel authentic, as much as films like Crimson Tide or The Hunt for Red October feel (though this film is nowhere near as good as those, for the record).
I mean, for starters, Hunter Killer is like a remake of The Hunt for Red October if Michael Bay directed it, except not even Michael Bay, who at least evinces a certain level of technical flair even if it is almost always deployed in the most painfully jingoistic and propagandistic ways.
It’s like “The Hunt for Red October” if re-written by a scribe who just suffered a serious head blow.
(No, not even Crimson Tide or The Hunt for Red October.)