(The raft segment recalls Life Of Pi without the preternatural beauty or the tiger.)
It may not be fair, but Unbroken suffers from comparisons to the impressionistic storytelling of Ang Lee’s metaphorical stranded-at-sea tale Life of Pi and the in-the-moment immediacy of J.C. Chandor’s All is Lost, starring Robert Redford.
The second is a liferaft picture — less the fantastical “Life of Pi” than Alfred Hitchcock’s grittier-minded “Lifeboat.”
While she’s a relative newbie in terms of direction (she’s only made one feature film previously), she’s backed by a ridiculously talented crew that includes cinematographer Roger Deakins (The Shawshank Redemption), composer Alexandre Desplat (The King’s Speech), and editors William Goldberg (Argo) and Tim Squyers (Life Of Pi).
Jolie’s not incapable of making good cinema: the entirety of the raft sequence is generally great, a more severe, realistic version of Life of Pi with noticeably crummier CGI, or a three-handed successor to All Is Lost .
We get the Olympics, the raft ordeal and the prison camp — in movie terms, Chariots of Fire plus Life of Pi plus The Bridge on the River Kwai.