Their designs are suspiciously reminiscent of Steven Spielberg’s “War of the Worlds” with wide shots of monster rampage clearly ripped from “Cloverfield.”
"Skyline" comes nowhere close to the respective heights of 2005's " War of the Worlds " or 2008's " Cloverfield ," both near the top of their respective subgenre, but it's also certainly better than a shoddy disaster like 2007's " Dragon Wars ," Individual visuals, usually of an uneven CG persuasion, are the bread and butter of directors Colin and Greg Strause.
You could try the War of the Worlds or the Independence Day angle; the Cloverfield or District 9 approach; or you could just do what the creators of Skyline did: sample every single "alien invasion" flick imaginable.
Whether the Strauses are capable to spinning a yarn with the same enthusiasm and obvious care they bring to their CGI handiwork is anyone’s guess, but here they are spinning their wheels with a cynical mash-up of ideas more imaginatively explored in various incarnations of H.G. Wells’ War of the Worlds and last year’s District 9 .
What follows are the usual protocols and stereotypes found in the Alien Invasion sub-genre ( War of the Worlds is especially tapped dry), as well as some unintentionally laughable new elements that are unforgettable for all of the wrong reasons.
These dilemmas are so woodenly scripted and amateurishly performed that they play like parodies of disaster-movie dramas, though they're no more unimaginative than the run-of-the-mill aliens themselves, biomechanical squid-like creatures with probing tentacles reminiscent of those possessed by War of the Worlds 's extra-terrestrials.