Brooks is the mind behind such emotionally trenchant movies as Terms of Endearment, Broadcast News and As Good As It Gets, not to mention TV landmarks like Taxi and The Simpsons.
For a while it was being buzzed about as a potential Oscar contender, but that was based solely on the fact it's a James L Brooks (Broadcast News, Terms of Endearment, As Good As It Gets) film starring Reese Witherspoon .
Likewise casting a star of Jack Nicholson’s caliber as the father – he previously won an Oscar in Brooks’ “As Good As It Gets” – means his part has to be given much more weight, so that the business problems seem as important as the romance.
The biggest name in the cast is Jack Nicholson, who's making his fourth collaboration with Brooks (he was previously in Terms of Endearment, Broadcast News, and As Good as It Gets ).
And that’s besides the problem of Jack Nicholson ( The Bucket List , The Departed ), as George’s father and coworker, embarrassingly wheezing his way through the movie, like he’s about to keel over with a coronary; or the problem of Brooks’ ( As Good as It Gets ) never giving us the sense that he had any of his meandering story under control.