Director Allen Hughes doesn't stylize Broken City quite so flamboyantly as such previous efforts as From Hell and The Book of Eli (both co-directed with his brother, Albert).
Hacked out by one of the twin Hughes brothers who directed the Jack the Ripper potboiler From Hell, Allen Hughes’s Broken City is another feverish, thickly plotted, overwritten and ultimately preposterous tale of sordid New York political corruption in which nothing much rings true.
Allen Hughes is better known for the projects he’s put out alongside his brother, Albert Hughes – Menace II Society, Dead Presidents, American Pimp, From Hell, Book of Eli – and in many ways, Broken City is an experiment to see what happens when you break the pair up.
Broken City, the first solo directorial outing by Allen Hughes (half of the twin-brother team who made Menace II Society , From Hell , and The Book of Eli ), is one of those movies that recedes in the course of its own viewing.