The American debut of kind-to-be-cruel South Korean filmmaker Park Chan-wook (“Old Boy,” “Lady Vengeance”), based on a script by the actor Wentworth Miller (“Prison Break”) with rewrites by Erin Cressida Wilson (“Secretary”) is a brisk, chilly variation on themes in Alfred Hitchcock’s “Shadow of a Doubt,” but it never finds a convincing shape of its own.
Operating in a dreamy vein that's far less gruesome than his renowned "vengeance trilogy" (Sympathy for Mr. Vengeance, Oldboy , Lady Vengeance), Park makes no gestures toward reality.
His celebrated “Vengeance’’ trilogy — “Sympathy for Mr. Vengeance’’ (2002), “Oldboy’’ (2003), and “Lady Vengeance’’ (2005) — inhabit a zone triangulated by crime films, psychological suspense, and hair-raising horror, but they also have a rarefied chill that renders them fit for the art house.
The narrative elements of Stoker are familiar enough from numerous other psychodramas and gothic tales of family madness, but the film works because Park and his regular cinematographer Chung-hoon Chung, who have now collaborated on six films, including two of the “Vengeance Trilogy” (2003’s Oldboy and 2006’s Lady Vengeance), give the film such a memorable air of fairy-tale menace.
The Korean cult director of the terrific "Oldboy," "Lady Vengeance" and "Thirst" is hardly known for restraint, but the schematic of "Stoker" (aka the too-knowing script by Wentworth Miller ) thwarts him technically.
It’s a riff on Alfred Hitchcock’s “Shadow of a Doubt” (1943, Hitchcock’s favorite film), scripted by actor Wentworth Miller and directed by South Korean Chan-wook Park of the cult fave “Vengeance” trilogy (“Sympathy for Mr. Vengeance,” “Oldboy,” “Lady Vengeance”).