“Young” is funnier and lighter than “Greenberg,” but their existence together and with Baumbach’s 2013 film “Frances Ha” (a collaboration with actress/screenwriter and Sacramento native Greta Gerwig), which centered on a failed dancer, suggests the director holds a fondness for tales of the artistically incomplete.
Baumbach is fascinated by such tense neurotics; remember the cynical indie-band dud of “Greenberg” and the longing also-ran female dancer in “Frances Ha”? His new characters, entering their 40s without children or exciting communication, miss the romantic younger versions of themselves.
By the time she took center stage in Frances Ha, a newfound warmth had found its place in Baumbach's already formidable comedic arsenal.
I suspect the extravagant praise lavished on Noah Baumbach’s films (“Frances Ha,” “Greenberg”) comes from those who can relate to the misery of snarky, neurotic New Yorkers.
In the years between, Baumbach has made some fine pictures (Frances Ha) and some deadening, hermetic ones (Margot at the Wedding), but it's While We're Young that really fulfills the promise of his brash but fine-grained debut.
These are details that, as with his previous film, “Frances Ha,” no doubt benefit from Baumbach’s dating much younger actress Greta Gerwig (who might have made a great Darby), just as her improv-comfortable peers (among whom Driver is fast emerging a star) benefit from such a solidly written screenplay.