A nerve-wracking reimagining of Ernest Hemingway’s The Old Man and the Sea, All Is Lost’s grandiose portrait of honour in struggle is a lucid and indomitable celebration of the endurance of the human spirit that makes for one hell of a ride.
Maybe not in the same minimalist style — but, between Castaway , Life of Pi , The Perfect Storm and The Old Man and the Sea (fun fact: Spencer Tracy was 57 when he made that; Redford’s 77), these are familiar waters.
The film is being compared with John Sturges' 1958 adaptation of Hemingway's The Old Man and the Sea, but over the years Sturges' film has become ripe for parody with its booming Dimitri Tiomkin score and a script that has Spencer Tracy holding extended conversations both with himself and the marlin he is trying to catch.